“Hindsight is 20/20,” they say. And a slew of expressions agree: Anyone can be a “Monday morning quarterback.” It’s easy to be “wise after the event.” Which is why we call it “the benefit of hindsight.”
Well, okay. Fair enough.
Then it’s probably a good idea to take advantage of that!
A dyslexic approach to problem-solving, where we begin with the ending and work our way back, is actually how PR pros build marketing plans: We figure out where the brand wants to be — and then we plot our path backwards. The better we can describe the ending, the better our plan.
‘Cause that’s all a marketing plan is: a roadmap between two points.
And so are post-election autopsies. You start with the death, pinpoint the mortal wounds, and then reverse-engineer what the hell happened.
Let’s apply this to the 2026 midterms. After all, we already know where we are: on the wrong side of a landslide. Even if you figured we’d lose (I predicted we’d lose the House and Senate), the size and scope of the blue wave caught everyone off guard — including the Democrats. They didn’t think they’d sweep Texas, Maine, Mississippi, Michigan, Kansas, Iowa, South Carolina, and Alaska, either.
(Nor did I. I figured the House was toast and the Senate was almost certainly kaput, but the GOP would win at least a few of the battleground races. Instead, we were shut out completely, and now the Senate is 56-44 Democrat.)
So what were the five biggest mistakes that led to the GOP’s drubbing?
Since a mistake is the byproduct of a decision, I’m not going to include what’s arguably the biggest reason that Republicans lost: historical headwinds.
The truth is, it’s exceedingly improbable for the in-power party to win a midterm election, and if Kamala Harris had won in 2024, there wouldn’t have been a blue wave.
If anything, the wave would’ve been red.
No more stalling. Here’s the list:
Honorable mention: Deaths of Renée Nicole Good (Jan. 7, 2026) and Alex Jeffrey Pretti (Jan. 24, 2026)
It was less the deaths themselves than what these deaths symbolized: President Donald Trump and the Republican Party lost the PR image war in the immigration debate. What once was Trump’s strongest issue was negated by bad press, bad execution, and partisan blowback. It helped energize Democratic activism, outrage, and turnout.
Only the ham-fisted GOP could turn one of the most remarkable success stories in government history — securing our border, lowering crime and drug deaths, and saving 50,000 American lives — into a political albatross! (It’s morbidly impressive.)
Part of the blame belongs to Kristi Noem. She turned out to be an abysmal cabinet selection (and the bizarreness of the homeland secretary’s home life wasn’t exactly helpful either). Part of the blame belongs to the Republican Party, for failing to help the American people connect the dots between a secure border, lower crime, safer streets, and fewer addicts dying.
But when you’re the president, the buck stops with you. From the top-down, the immigration debate was botched from the get-go.
And now, the top five…
Number Five: Tariff Day, a.k.a. “Liberation Day” (April 2, 2025)
Post-Trump, it’s unclear if the Republican Party will be a pro-tariff party. In many ways, it’s an unnatural fit for the party of limited government. Tariffs appeal to isolationists (and quite a few realists), mostly because other countries cheat at trade and/or manipulate the rules. Without protectionist policies, they argue, American jobs will vanish.
The purpose of this column isn’t to advocate for or against tariffs. I’m simply reporting the political reality: Americans blame tariffs for the so-called “affordability crisis.”
Which is why it hurt us on Election Day.
In fact, for all the handwringing about the Iran War, more Americans blamed President Trump’s tariff policies than the Iran War for higher prices:
More voters blame Trump's tariffs for raising cost of living than Iran war: poll https://t.co/NTyaiPKa4d https://t.co/xTN6xFQC8m
— New York Post (@nypost) November 19, 2026
Some track his decline in the polls to “Liberation Day”:
The Woke Right, who actually have been pushing this stuff in the White House, are desperate to make sure people don't recognize this simple truth. They have seemingly known it all along too. Trump inherited a country that just suffered high inflation and other reasons for high prices, and people wanted economic stability and improvement. The logic, if not just post-liberal stupidity, is that this kind of economic protectionism would drive manufacturing back to the U.S. and, inexplicably, level out trade deficits, as if that's some kind of a goal for the holder of the world's reserve currency. While a little of that happened, I don't think tariffs would work even in the long term for the goals they were seeking, but even if they would have, they wouldn't work in two years. They kept prices high and caused a lot of ancillary problems across the board. Tariffs are expensive, and autarky (economic self-sufficiency) is also expensive. That means goods and services are expensive. The graphs of approval ratings for Trump clearly show a negative trajectory from the day he imposed them, which he also inexplicably called "Liberation Day." In my opinion, the Trump administration overall, and Trump himself, own this mistake and should correct it. I know post-liberal idiots like Oren Cass, a close advisor and friend of JD Vance, and his American Compass outfit were instrumental in keeping them going, so they should probably eat more of the blame, but Trump wears these himself too. Period. But, the Woke Right took advantage of these high prices and even maintained inflationary rates to blame the Iran War for the prices the second that it started. They blamed nothing else. Iran closing Hormuz made this explanation stick like glue, and the graph shows another incredible tanking of approval that correlates to it. The thing is, it's not the war that raised the prices. That was always malicious propaganda, serving New Right, Russian, and Iranian interests (no coincidence that it's all of these at once). The war became the bogus primary explanation for high prices when, in fact, it was a modest increase. The wicked New Right, Russia, and Iran would have understood all of this, that they could pin the high prices that were largely a combination of the legacy of Bidenflation plus the way Trump's (and Vance-Cass's) tariffs scheme maintained those high prices and inflation rates. The war was big, obvious, and visible, so of course it made things more expensive, or so the logic goes. In truth, things were expensive mostly for other reasons, including the stupid tariffs, and the propaganda turned people against Trump over the war. Now, the New Right, along with Russia and Iran, no doubt, are pushing the line as hard as possible that the war, largely because of affordability concerns, was the primary driver in losing the midterms, which is also starkly out of step with any real, sober analysis (many other factors weigh heavily, not least the tariffs and their economic consequences). There are many reasons for this. One, it allows Vance's people to target their enemies in the administration effectively by blaming the war and thus those who supported it, especially Trump, Hegseth, and Rubio. A lot of that will be successful, even though it's grotesque, malicious, and false. Two, I'm not saying they have deals with the Russians or Iranians or are doing their bidding, but... I didn't say that. Three, it allows them to keep anger about the war high and to leverage to pull out of it, which serves... Russian and Iranian, if not also Chinese, interests most. The New Right also depends on this anger to mobilize its infantile base. Four, autarky is always expensive and therefore has to be propped up by "nationalist" policy that they want to force on people, so these bad policies become a lever to accomplish their worse policies. Five, it allows them to maintain their "nationalist" push for autarkic policy (high tariffs) even though they're the main cause of the problem, which fits with their "nationalist" (national socialist...) agenda along with Russia/China's Dugin-driven "multipolarity" theory, which requires an isolated America ("America First"). Six, repeating that last one for emphasis: it lets them keep doing the stupid tariffs, which they want for bad reasons that run a fairly wide gamut, none of which are genuinely in American interests. I don't know if there's corruption there they're profiting from (I guarantee there is), or if that's how these foreign entities that benefit so much from their policies might be controlling them (...), but it's a decent bet, too. Which is like a seventh reason: they have to because they're compromised through their own crooked deal-making. At any rate, the tariffs were not a good policy. If the proposed mechanism was going to work, it wouldn't work in the time allotted, and it is unlikely that they'd actually work (autarky is always expensive and requires a lot of "nationalist" policy to keep it going). Nonetheless, the New Right (and its foreign alignments) ran an extremely successful propaganda campaign that they are now accelerating vigorously to lead people to the wrong conclusions and to dramatically undercut Republicans (so they can leverage that to try to take over the party with more bad ideas).
— James Lindsay, anti-Communist (@ConceptualJames) November 6, 2026
Perhaps tariffs are a necessary evil; perhaps they’re self-destructive and foolhardy. (Believe whatever you want.) But in 2026, they were politically hurtful. Thems the facts, bro.
In an election where the #1 issue was affordability, tariffs were a high-visibility scapegoat.
Number Four: Pam Bondi’s Epstein Files (mis)release (Feb. 27, 2025) and Elon Musk posting on X that Trump “is in the Epstein Files” (June 5, 2025)
The irony is, the Biden administration stonewalled the release of the Epstein Files; President Trump was the one who shared them with the public.
But when ex-Attorney General Pam Bondi overpromised and underdelivered, the blowback was extraordinary. She promised scandalous new info — tens of thousands of hours of shocking video footage — yet delivered tired old news.
It was catnip for the tin-hat crowd. Suddenly, everyone was talking about Jeffrey Epstein.
This was the beginning of the drip-drip-drip.
Then, on June 5, Elon Musk threw a temper tantrum over the Big Beautiful Bill and posted one of the most damaging, ill-advised statements in social media history. He’s since deleted it, but the internet never forgets:
“Time to drop the really big bomb: @realDonaldTrump is in the Epstein files. That is the real reason they have not been made public. Have a nice day, DJT!” https://t.co/j0v472W0Fg
— WBTV News (@WBTV_News) June 7, 2025
“Epstein Class” became shorthand for government corruption, unaccountable billionaires, Donald Trump’s friends, and businessmen with suspiciously Semitic-sounding names. The one-two punch of Bondi’s bungling and Musk’s X post elevated a side-issue into an ongoing distraction, and Epstein isn’t going away in 2027.
The House Democrats are calling for a special counsel to investigate Trump’s ties to Epstein. And now that they control Congress, they’ll get what they want. All the way through, the Epstein debacle is a textbook example of what NOT to do in crisis communications.
We literally handed the Dems a club to beat us over the head.
Number Three: GOP legislative incompetence, especially the SAVE Act (June 4, 2026)
Actually, the SAVE Act failed quite a few times. It passed the House in April of 2025 yet never advanced in the Senate. The revised SAVE Act passed the House in February of 2026 and then failed to overcome the Senate’s 60-vote filibuster.
Then, it failed twice in the Senate, including on June 4, losing 48-50 both times. Republican Senators Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski, Mitch McConnell, and Thom Tillis all voted against it.
This was a life-and-death issue for the GOP base. Few issues mattered to us more. Watching it crash and burn was painful.
It demotivated Republican turnout. This was the GOP’s opportunity to give us a reason to vote FOR them.
But instead of delivering, they gave the base the finger.
Lots of us voted anyway, but we really weren’t voting for the Republicans anymore. All we had left was voting against the Democrats.
If you want to know why Republicans were slaughtered in the enthusiasm gap, the death of the SAVE Act is a great place to start!
(And, of course, if you’re suspicious of the Democrats’ dramatic jump in midterm turnout, the absence of the SAVE Act is — at least for some — potential evidence of untrustworthy results. Which isn’t healthy for democracy, either.)
Number Two: The Iran War (Feb. 28, 2026) and the Iran MOU (June 17, 2026)
Some blame the Iran War, some blame the Iran MOU. I’m gonna split the difference and blame ‘em both.
Because they both point to the same problem: an unsatisfactory conclusion.
President Trump insists he did the right thing, and perhaps his decision will be well-received in time. But the immediate impact was detrimental: It spiked gas prices right before the midterm, it divided elements of the MAGA movement, and this on-again, off-again Schrödinger’s cat of a conflict lacked a clear, convincing victory.
It also became a wedge issue for Israel-bashers to exploit. If you’re a Zionist voter, the Iran War might’ve saved millions of people from a nuclear holocaust, but it further damaged Israel’s reputation in the West. (I’m not saying this with a smile on my face; I’m just calling balls and strikes.)
Without the Iran War, Abdul El-Sayed’s campaign would’ve lost its go-to whipping horse. The war itself — and the sputtering way we prosecuted it — hurt the Republican Party.
Either in conception or implementation, we screwed the pooch. (Politically, at least.)
Number One: The murder of Charlie Kirk (Sept. 10, 2025)
His death wasn’t a “mistake” — it was a deliberate, preplanned crime. Calling it a mistake lets Tyler Robinson, the alleged murderer, skate culpability.
But allowing his death to divide the MAGA movement? That was a yuuuuge mistake.
It’s one we still haven’t recovered from.
The first tragedy was the murder itself. Charlie was just 31; he left behind a wife and two children. Our heart aches for all of them.
The second tragedy was how MAGA reacted. Because, under different circumstances, this could’ve been the moment we rallied together, realized that the people who killed Charlie would’ve happily killed any of us, and dedicated ourselves to honoring Charlie’s life.
Instead, his murder became fodder for moronic conspiracies. Sleaze-merchants monetized his name for YouTube views. His widow and his children were exploited — over and over again — for clicks.
I don’t have access to Candace Owens’ finances, but I wouldn’t be surprised if she made millions by desecrating Charlie Kirk’s memory.
And she’s not alone. Tucker Carlson and others have repeatedly evoked his memory to link him to causes he never supported, including antisemitism, hatred of Israel, and support of Islam.
As a result, our movement has splintered. We spent much of the last year fighting with ourselves.
Meanwhile, the Democrats were so unified against all-things MAGA, the DSA and the Democratic establishment were working together.
It’s sad. It’s a shame. And it wasn’t even a little bit necessary.
But like it or not, it happened — and in 2028, we’ll have to reassemble our movement yet again.