For years, the medical establishment handed vulnerable people a solution to complex psychological pain: radical, irreversible surgery. And to make matters worse, these barbaric procedures were approved casually and quickly without proper mental health evaluations. Now detransitioners who have had their bodies and lives destroyed are fighting back. The wave of legal challenges against gender medicine providers is growing, and it looks like litigation will finally accomplish what public debate alone never could.
There are reportedly 30 active lawsuits against gender medicine providers nationwide. In February, detransitioner Fox Varian won a $2 million judgment against providers who referred her for a double mastectomy at just 16 years old. Chloe Cole, one of the most prominent detransitioner voices in America, has filed her own medical malpractice lawsuit. And now, this week, a 36-year-old Oregon woman named Camille Kiefel reached a confidential settlement with multiple mental health providers she accused of improperly approving her for a double mastectomy.
Kiefel sought $3.5 million in damages from the counselors and their employers.
Kiefel's story is a damning indictment of how the transgender industry operates. Would you believe that it took just two quick Zoom calls, one from a licensed clinical social worker and the other from a licensed professional counselor, for her to get referral letters for surgery?
That’s it.
According to her lawsuit, these providers approved her for the procedure despite knowing her history of trauma, depression, suicidal ideation, and ADHD. When you learn Kiefel’s backstory, you discover that she should have gotten mental health counseling, not irreversible surgery. Trauma shaped her childhood, including the sexual assault of her best friend when she was in fifth grade, which she said left her feeling profoundly uncomfortable in her own body and led her to dress more masculinely as a form of self-protection. In college, a women's studies class (of course) introduced her to the concept of being nonbinary, and she latched onto that identity as an explanation for years of unresolved pain.
Two Zoom calls later, she was approved for an irreversible double mastectomy.
After the surgery in August 2020, things only got worse. Kiefel reported developing vertigo, tinnitus, and Raynaud's syndrome. She began working with a naturopath, overhauled her nutrition, and started researching the gut-brain connection. As her physical health improved, her mental health followed. Then the doubts set in.
"So while I'm addressing all my physical health issues, I start to question whether or not the surgery was helpful for me," she told Fox News Digital. She detransitioned about a year and a half after the operation.
What she was left with was clarity — and permanent loss. "It's difficult because now I'm the most mentally healthy and most mentally stable I've been in my entire life, but I now no longer have my breasts," she said. She describes seeing "ugly scars" every time she looks in the mirror, noting that dresses no longer fit the same way. And then there's the grief over what the future may not hold.
"I'd like to have kids, but I would never be able to nurse them, and I'll never have that connection with them, and then they won't get the benefits of breast milk. So it's been difficult," she said.
Recommended: Democrats Vote Against a Women's History Museum. Can You Guess Why?
Days before the trial, the case was settled. But Kiefel is clear-eyed about why she fought. "I didn't want what happened to me to happen to other vulnerable girls and women," she said. "And I wasn't given true informed consent. And that's something that everyone deserves to have for any medical procedure."
She believes litigation is one of the most powerful levers available. "It's incredibly important that these lawsuits are brought forward," she said. "So for many, I think a lot of this is going to be the lawsuits that are actually going to create change."
She's right. The transgender industry expanded as fast as it did largely because it was so profitable. Gender clinics, surgeons, therapists, and pharmaceutical companies all had financial incentives to affirm, refer, and operate. I wrote back in 2022 that it was projected that the transgender surgery industry would reach $5 billion by the end of this decade. Now that the money is starting to flow in the other direction, so does their conscience. If mounting malpractice liability makes those procedures financially toxic, the economic engine driving this tragedy will stall. And it’ll be a great day when it all collapses.
