Roger Pielke ("The Honest Broker") has been a climate skeptic for at least two decades, since his first book, The Honest Broker: Making Sense of Science in Policy and Politics, was published in 2007. He is a Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a professor emeritus at the University of Colorado Boulder, where he founded and directed the Center for Science and Technology Policy Research.
Pielke is a valuable source because he pulls no punches and takes on the sacred cows of science. His most recent column, "The Shadow NGOs of Climate Advocacy," highlights a problem that afflicts government agencies across the board.
What happens when the government gives money to a non-profit organization for one purpose, but it's used for something entirely different?
"For years I have discussed an important evolution in institutions of expertise," Pielke writes. "Publicly-funded institutions that have been created to conduct, assess, and coordinate science increasingly act as advocates for a political agenda — just like any garden-variety NGO advocating for its favorite cause?"
Except they're not non-governmental organizations (NGOs). They are Intergovernmental Organizations, or IGOs. Organizations like the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) and UNESCO are treaty-based international bodies funded by assessed dues from member governments. They exist under international law rather than domestic corporate or non-profit tax codes.
Pielke makes clear there is nothing wrong with these groups "organizing to appeal for outcomes that its members value," like climate change mitigation. "However, it is wrong for institutions of science funded by taxpayers to be repurposed to play the role of an advocacy group supporting the political agendas of the individuals who happen to lead these organizations," Pielke notes.
Three taxpayer-funded organizations are called out by Pielke for their advocacy:
“The World Climate Research Program (WCRP) coordinates and facilitates international climate research to develop, share, and apply the climate knowledge that contributes to societal well-being.”
"Future Earth’s mission is to advance research in support of transformations to global sustainability.”
“The Earth League provides scientific insights on change and transformation within the Earth system and informs decision-making for global sustainability”
Their political agenda is about what you'd expect.
1. Phase out fossil fuels quickly.
2. Litigate climate damages.
3. Restrict the political participation of opponents.
4. Redistribute wealth (YAY).
5. Change what people eat.
6. Recast disagreement as obstruction.
"The political agenda articulated by these three organizations would no doubt receive a friendly hearing among many committed neo-Malthusians, degrowthers, and would-be speech censors," writes Pielke. "However, beyond that small bubble, there is little evidence for broad public support."
In the United States, Pew Research Center found in 2024 that 29% of Americans favor a complete phase-out of oil, coal and natural gas, and 69% prefer a mix of fossil and renewable sources; even among Democrats, 45% favor a phase-out and 53% prefer the mix.
In Sweden, home of the Future Earth hub that coordinates the report, researchers found that only 16% to 27% of respondents support higher carbon taxes on transport fuels. In 2023, the Swedish government cut fuel taxes and the biofuel blending mandate despite warnings from the national Climate Policy Council, then partly restored the mandate in 2024.
In Germany, which funds the Earth League’s host institutions, YouGov found in April 2026 that 69% of respondents oppose banning the sale of petrol and diesel cars. Only 16% of Germans said wealthy countries should “take on most of the responsibility of tackling climate change,” and 30% said they would limit meat and dairy to two or three meals a week.
The age-old leftist trope that "We know what's best for you, so sit down, shut up, and listen" is the basis upon which these and most other taxpayer-funded climate groups see their mission. They don't care what you think. They don't care what you want. These are people who would murder your grandparents if they believed it was a necessary way to save on healthcare costs.
And now, many of them are in positions of power in Congress and the agencies. They have allied themselves with Luddites and one-worlders with the goal of destroying capitalism, castrating the United States, and empowering China and Russia.
It's often been said that climate change advocacy is anti-capitalism dressed up in khakis and Birkenstocks. It's also dressed in Brooks Brothers tailored suits.