JD Vance or JD France? The Great Debate Over Forever Wars, Surrender, and Why We Lost the Midterms.

Nov 18, 2026 1:20 PM
Advertisement
JD Vance or JD France? The Great Debate Over Forever Wars, Surrender, and Why We Lost the Midterms.
AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein, Pool

Ironically, Vice President JD Vance’s decision was a political “war of choice” — which now threatens to become a “forever war” that destroys the Republican Party. (If discretion is the better part of valor and the test of political leadership is knowing which wars not to fight, then Vance just bombed his 2028 audition.)

Advertisement

Because it wasn’t necessary. Not even a little bit. 

Nobody was banging the table, demanding to hear the vice president’s postmortem:

Advertisement

“War is politics by other means,” which implies, of course, that politics is war by other means, too. Because, in both instances, a wise leader chooses his battles carefully. 

One must avoid quagmires — don’t kick sleeping dogs — and always make sure the juice is worth the squeeze.

That’s what’s so perplexing about Vance’s X post: It was more downside than upside. The strategery behind it defied common sense:

Our voters did show up. …The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.

[…]

Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were: 

1) End the war 
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation 
3) Put America First 
4) Change our relationship to Israel 

Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats.

[…]

The reason we lost is the war.

Only it’s not, because “the” reason doesn’t exist. The GOP didn’t get shellacked because of one thing; that theory is absurd. It was a convergence of factors, including historical headwinds, GOP congressional incompetence and/or malfeasance, lousy candidates, botched messaging, economic dissatisfaction, and the president’s low approval ratings.

Furthermore, the GOP’s biggest problem wasn’t voters switching sides — it was dissatisfied Trump voters staying home:

Advertisement

Did the Iran War matter? Of course! It was a big, oxygen-sucking story that spiked gas prices.

But it wasn’t the only thing that mattered — FAR more Trump voters stayed home than switched sides — and it’s disingenuous for Vance to pretend otherwise.

Yet the veep keeps insisting it was all about the Iran War:

If you'd like to argue [the Iran War] was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest. 

But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.

Well, okay — I’m a fan of “honest conversations.” So let’s discuss, Mr. Vice President:

Advertisement

My predictions, Laura, is that whatever the president ultimately decides to do [in Iran], there are going to be people who demand more. Who want the war to go on indefinitely. …The people who want it to become a forever war, they can attack me all they want… Despite the fact that a lot of neoconservatives and a lot of other people want to stay [in Iran] forever, we’re not going to stay there forever…

Holy strawman, Batman! Where, exactly, are all the people clamoring for a “forever war”? Maybe they’re not inviting me to their (((neocon))) meetings, but I’ve yet to meet a single dude who’s crossing his fingers, rubbing his rabbit’s foot, and hoping the Iran War will last 20 years.

But at the same time, we don’t want to end the war by surrendering.

Is he JD Vance — or JD France? Because a GREAT way to avoid a “forever war” is to win the damn fight, spike the football, and go home! C’mon, being a cheese-eating surrender monkey isn’t our only option.

Like Ultron said to Captain America, “I think you’re confusing peace with quiet.” And so was Vance with his utterly unworkable MOU.

In hindsight, it was a devastating foreign policy blunder. Instead of focusing on shattering the resolve of our enemy, the MOU gave the Iranians breathing room, BILLIONS in new oil revenue, hope and legitimacy, and the wherewithal to believe that time was on their side.

The mullahs didn’t interpret the MOU as an olive branch, but as a sign of weakness.

President Donald Trump signed the MOU in June. He canceled it in July. It was an embarrassment from the get-go.

Had we spent the summer bombing instead of haggling, who knows what might’ve happened? Hey, war is unpredictable and results aren’t guaranteed, but we know the MOU took us down the path of a long, protracted, never-ending stalemate, culminating in sky-high gas prices on Election Day. The option we chose led to disaster.

So why is the Iran War to blame for the midterm loss — but not the MOU?

The vice president wanted an “honest conversation.” Now he’s getting it:

Advertisement

If Vance’s political objective was solidifying his 2028 support with isolationists, anti-Zionists, and Tucker Carlson fans, his X post was a home run. He dropped all the right breadcrumbs, blaming the Iran War, neocons, and our relationship with (((Israel))). The veep made it crystal clear where he stands.

(Including to his boss, who promptly fired him from all foreign policy work, directing him to focus his “complete and total attention” on city- and state-level crimes.)

Maybe his gamble will pay off. Maybe, in a 2028 GOP field with multiple pro-Israel candidates, Vance is fishing alone in an untapped pond. Maybe Ted Cruz, Ron DeSantis, and others will split the pro-Israel vote — enough pro-Israel Boomers will die off — and Vance is skating where the puck is heading.

Or maybe this was a stupid, senseless “war of choice” that will lead to a “forever war” between Vance and other Republicans.

Advertisement

Before the midterms, the veep was the undisputed Republican frontrunner — and the odds-on favorite to win the 2028 nomination. After his X post, public demotion, and foot-in-mouth interviews, he’s hemorrhaging GOP support. Even middle-of-the-road Republican commentators like Brian Kilmeade have seen enough:

But that’s not the worst thing that could happen. The real danger is if enough Republicans take Vance up on his offer to have an “honest conversation.”

Because, the honest-to-God truth is, the MOU was an unmitigated disaster, it absolutely contributed to the midterm blowout, and JD Vance’s fingerprints were all over it.

After all, the MOU didn’t fail because of neocons, (((Mark Levin))), Israel, AIPAC, or any of Vance’s other strawmen. It failed because the vice president grotesquely misjudged the nature of the enemy.

The Iranians weren’t seriously seeking peace! They agreed to the MOU to buy time!

Memo to Vance: Peace through victory is good, peace through surrender is bad.

Next time, have the wisdom to know the difference. (It’s kind of important.)

This is America, not France.

“The core thing about the progress we’ve made over the last few weeks,” the veep told CNN in June, hyping the success of his newly-negotiated MOU, “is that you see people within the Iranian system — senior leadership, even IRGC officials say, ‘Y’know what? We may have some animosity, we may have some mistrust, but we recognize the way that we’ve done business with the United States for 47 years was a mistake, let’s try something else.’”

“Let’s try something else.” Wise words indeed.

Many Republicans, I suspect, will feel similarly in 2028.

One Last Thing: We lost the midterms, but our fight continues. Our fight ALWAYS continues. And in many ways, our real fight is just beginning: The radical left has never been so emboldened — or their goals so ambitious. 

We need your help to fight back!

As a PJ Media VIP member, you’ll receive exclusive access to our behind-the-paywall content, commenting privileges, and an ad-free experience. VIP Gold gets you the same level of “insider access” across our entire family of sites (PJ Media, Townhall, RedState, Twitchy, Hot Air, and Bearing Arms). That means: More stories, more videos, more content, more fun, more conservatism, more EVERYTHING!

And if you CLICK HERE and use the promo code FIGHT, you’ll receive a yuuuge 60% discount!

Thank you for your consideration.

Comments

VIP

Join the Conversation

VIP members get the ability to comment on articles.

Recommended

Trending on PJ Media Videos