The city of Chicago is in dire financial straits. The Windy City is running a budget deficit of $882.4 million, and Mayor Brandon Johnson has promised so much to so many groups that he can't decide where to cut.
Instead of cutting, the mayor wants to play a shell game with cash that hasn't been collected yet, hiding the structural budget problems with smoke and mirrors.
His biggest problem is that he can't find a Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to play hide-and-seek with the budget numbers. He has had three CFOs since the beginning of the year, and none have wanted to destroy their reputations by trying to hide the massive trouble the city's finances are in.
Jill Jaworski left City Hall in January for a job at Navy Pier. This was shortly after a City Council majority rejected Johnson’s corporate head tax and passed an alternative city budget. Jaworski's replacement, Steven Mahr, served eight months and abruptly resigned in July just as the budget process was getting underway. He probably saw the writing on the wall and knew what he would be asked to do.
The city hired a Wall Street veteran of ratings agencies as CFO in August, Ashlee Gabrysch, to oversee the coming clown car calamity of a dishonest budget process, a massive pension crisis, and a mayor who wants to sweep it all under the rug.
On Friday, Gabrysch resigned rather than lie to the people, the city council, the ratings agencies, and Wall Street about how precipitous Chicago's finances truly are.
“Throughout my career, I have remained committed to upholding the highest standards of financial integrity and transparency, and in my short time as Chief Financial Officer, I have faithfully discharged this duty," Gabrysch said. "It has become apparent, however, that to continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations. I therefore have concluded that I must step down from my role, and hereby tender my resignation.”
In an op-ed in the Chicago Tribune, Gabrysch unloaded on Johnson, “I couldn’t remain the official on whom investors, rating agencies, City Council and taxpayers rely while the city’s public description of its budget differed from its own published numbers. A CFO who can’t stand fully behind how the city’s finances are described should step aside. So I have."
According to Crain's Chicago Business, Gabrysch was in a "tense" meeting with Johnson earlier in the week, where the mayor discovered that the CFO was not going to play ball on cooking the books. The week ended on November 13, "ahead of a meeting where she believed she would be fired, according to sources familiar with the talks," says Crain.
Gabrysch laid out the city's problem: Kicking the can down the road was no longer an option.
For years, Chicago has kept that scale level by pressing a thumb on it: one-time revenue, using up our dwindling reserves, refinancing for upfront savings, borrowing to cover everyday spending like back pay and police misconduct settlements. A thumb holds the scale still for a moment, but it doesn’t fix the imbalance. When you lift it, the scale tips back, usually further than before.
That’s why presentation matters. When a budget looks healthier than it is, every new program looks affordable. This year’s budget adds new investments, many of them worthy, while relying on borrowing to pay for costs we already have. Making the numbers look better doesn’t make room for new commitments. It only hides how far the scale has already tipped.
The imbalance didn’t arrive last year or under any one mayor. It was built over decades. Saying so isn’t an argument against ambition. It’s the precondition for it. A city that can’t pay its bills can’t help the families who depend on it most, as mine once did. Fiscal discipline isn’t austerity. It’s protection. Budgets that hide borrowing don’t protect public investments. They guarantee deeper cuts and higher taxes later.
“Credit to her for holding a line that has been fuzzy at best during this administration and doing one of the most important things that a senior-level person in that position can do, which is to say no when something crosses the line,” Civic Federation President Joe Ferguson said. “We don’t know what that line is. We don’t know what she has been asked to say that caused her to draw that line.”
Ald. Bill Conway (34th), a former investment banker who teaches college finance, stated flatly that Gabrysch’s resignation letter was an “obvious indication that she was asked by the mayor’s office to present false information.”
Mayor Johnson fired back, accusing Gabrysch of wrongdoing.
“The City of Chicago is facing a serious budget crisis following decades of mismanagement. It is concerning that, during her short tenure, Ashlee was largely absent during critical periods of the City’s budget preparation process,” the statement said. “Additionally, her decision to direct the City Treasurer to issue a $75 million payment without proper legal authority or following the required processes raises serious concerns."
The $75 million payment was authorized but did not win final approval by the City Council. It was a technicality, not a firing offense.
“Our administration made multiple attempts to meet with her to discuss this action and seek an explanation, including shortly before her public resignation," the mayor's statement said. "Those attempts went unresolved. Given the seriousness of these concerns, we will refer the matter to the city’s Office of Inspector General for independent review. We welcome a full review of the conduct at issue.”
"This effort by the administration to deflect from the serious issues at stake and attack those who attempt to hold them accountable is disappointing but not surprising," Gabrysch fired back. "I stand by my statement and will continue to operate in accordance with my values and integrity.”
In essence, Johnson wanted the record to reflect that the $17 billion city budget was 76% structurally balanced. "Gabrysch said only 56% of the moves the mayor had made to erase a $882 million shortfall were structural, because settlements tied to allegations of police abuse — and the $480 million in borrowing that Johnson ordered to cover those costs — should not count as structural solutions," according to the Chicago Sun-Times.
In other words, Gabrysch wouldn't lie to Johnson.
“There was a collective gasp in the City Council chamber because no CFO has ever said, ‘Here’s the truth,’” said 32nd Ward Ald. Scott Waguespack, the former Finance chair. “However they’re cooking the books, she was not gonna put her name on it... She probably just looked at it and said, ‘I’m not gonna compromise my integrity and degrees for a political agenda.’”
There will be an investigation that Johnson allies on the City Council will make sure doesn't amount to much. Chicago's real deficit, real pension shortfall, and real political problems are combining to create the perfect storm of a civic catastrophe that the people of Chicago are going to end up paying for.
Editor’s Note: Every single day, here at PJ Media, we stand up and FIGHT, FIGHT, FIGHT against the radical Left and deliver the conservative reporting our readers deserve.
Help us continue to tell the truth about the Trump administration and its successes. Join PJ Media VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.