You're Asking the Wrong Question About John Fetterman

Nov 19, 2026 9:18 PM
Premium
Advertisement
You're Asking the Wrong Question About John Fetterman
AP Photo/Steven Senne, File
VIP

For a couple of years now, speculation has run rampant about Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) switching parties. I've said consistently that he isn't going to do it, and I stand by that. People read far too much into his friendly words for Republicans, his support for Israel, and his rare votes for sane policies.

See, Fetterman isn't a moderate.

He votes with Democrats 95% of the time. Republicans might love him as a Democrat, but they'd hate him as a Republican. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I know he recently said he'd consider leaving if Democrats make Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) their majority leader, but leaving the party and joining the GOP are two different things, and people keep forgetting that.

Anyone still getting their hopes up and asking when he might switch parties is asking the wrong question.

For sure, the Democrat Party has made it clear he's no longer welcome in their “big tent.” But Fetterman hasn't committed to a 2028 reelection bid, and the list of Democrats eyeing his seat grows longer by the week.

Ahmed Moor, the Palestinian American writer and businessman, launched his campaign less than a week after the midterm election. Moor is a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, won’t condemn Hamas, and could be Pennsylvania's Abdul El-Sayed.

Rep. Madeleine Dean (D-Pa.) has also said she's weighing a challenge of her own. Dean said she has been concerned about Fetterman's "family and his health" and is "very disappointed in his activity as a senator and in his votes."

ICYMI: Hakeem Jeffries Is Preparing to Go Full Stalin on the Entire MAGA Movement

Then Rep. Chris Deluzio (D-Pa.) said on Sunday he's seriously considering a run. "Fetterman's been a mess and he doesn't take the job seriously," Deluzio said. "That guy [Fetterman] is not going to be the senator in '28."

He’s probably right.

The question is whether Fetterman fights for his party’s nomination, or decides it’s not worth it. I don’t see a viable path for him to win the nomination. I’m sure many of Democrats still supporting him at this point don’t see one either.

So what does Fetterman make of the growing pack of challengers? "Oh … ask [former Rep.] Conor Lamb. What's he doing?" Fetterman said when asked whether a primary worries him.

He beat Lamb in Pennsylvania's 2022 Democrat Senate primary.

He saved a sharper shot for Rep. Brendan Boyle (D-Pa.), who passed on a challenge and stayed in the House. "You have the little guy from Philly. You can ask him why he chickened out," Fetterman added.

That may sound like he’s ready to rumble, but then MSNOW reporter Mychael Schnell asked him on Thursday the question that matters most: whether he'll actually run in 2028.

"I am considering things," Fetterman said.

Considering things?

That's not what a man who is definitely running again says. So, the question isn’t whether he’ll switch parties; it’s whether Fetterman stays in the Senate at all, and I get the feeling he may choose not to.

Personally, I think he's more likely to skip reelection. I also think Pennsylvania Democrats will nominate someone too radical for his tastes, and he'll endorse the Republican candidate. That would likely be the best scenario for the GOP in 2028.

Comments

Recommended

Trending on PJ Media Videos