News & Politics

Germans Angry at Merkel's Botched Security at Summit

(Sipa via AP Images)

The riots in Hamburg during the G-20 summit didn’t help the re-election chances of German Chancellor Angela Merkel. In fact, according to this Reuters report, German newspapers devoted as much coverage to the violence as they did to the summit itself.

Many Germans were embarrassed at the site of hundreds of hooded thugs looting businesses, torching cars, and fighting with police. And the blame for the security fiasco is resting squarely on Angela Merkel’s shoulders.

About 20,000 police struggled to contain several hundred anti-capitalist militants who torched cars, looted shops and hurled Molotov cocktails and stones during the July 7-8 summit. Tens of thousands more people demonstrated peacefully.

Overall, 476 officers suffered injuries ranging from cuts and firework burns to eye damage from laser pointers. Police said on Sunday they had arrested 186 people and took 225 into custody.

German newspapers devoted far more space to pictures of police firing water cannon onto hooded anarchists and other protestors than they did to Merkel’s diplomatic balancing act with fellow leaders of major world economies.

“Embarrassment for Germany” was Tagesspiegel’s description. “The pictures of helpless police who could not secure state order and protection of property are a political catastrophe,” columnist Gerd Nowakowski wrote in the paper.

Top-selling Bild am Sonntag splashed pictures of masked anarchists and politicians on its front page with the headline “Criminals and Losers”. Inside, a political scientist described the scenes as an ‘orgy of violence’.

International media have focused more on U.S. President Donald Trump’s first meeting with his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin at the summit, as well as Trump’s diverging views on climate change and trade from those of the other leaders.

Nevertheless, an Emnid poll showed that a majority of Germans, 59 percent, believed the riots damage the image of their country – even though violence has affected a number of international meetings around the world over the years.

Merkel was forced to defend her choice of Hamburg, saying other cities, like London, had hosted similar meetings. Hamburg, a seaport which is Germany’s second biggest city, has a strong radical leftist tradition. It was also home to an al Qaeda cell that carried out the 9/11 attacks on U.S. targets in 2001.

Merkel had wanted to demonstrate to G20 partners, including Putin and Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan, her commitment to freedom of speech and rejected the notion that some cities were out of bounds as summit venues.

The strategy has backfired, said some commentators.

“I can barely breathe with anger because Chancellor Merkel and Hamburg mayor (Olaf) Scholz trivialize the brutal riots as ‘not acceptable’,” wrote a commentator in Bild am Sonntag.

The Social Democrats (SPD), trailing Merkel’s conservatives by 12-15 percentage points in polls, squarely blamed Merkel.

“The invitation to the G20 was issued by the Chancellor. She was the host… That some conservatives are now pushing responsibility onto the SPD and Olaf Scholz is cheap,” one of the SPD’s deputies Ralf Stegner told RND media.

The riots won’t make Merkel any more sanguine about the election. But the chancellor’s CDU coalition is still comfortably ahead and German observers believe it is Merkel’s contest to lose at this point.

It’s hard to put too much blame on the German government. Perhaps the summit could have been held somewhere else, but if 20,000 police can’t keep the peace, you have to wonder what more Merkel could have done. I’m sure the tactics of police will be examined under a microscope — but short of shooting down the rioters, it’s not clear what peaceful tactics could have been used to gain control of those bent on destruction.