This past Friday I reported here at PJ Media on the attack just hours before the beginning of Ramadan on Coptic Christian pilgrims in Upper Egypt who were on their way to pray at a remote monastery in the desert.
On Eve of Ramadan, Islamic Gunmen Kill 28 Coptic Christians on Pilgrimage in Egypt https://t.co/AenrRu6kqE via @pjmedia_com pic.twitter.com/2wyfSR5fdk
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) May 26, 2017
Three vehicles full of gunmen opened fire on a bus with mostly women and children, killing 28. Only three children survived the attack.
Video of attack survivor https://t.co/HKzk5GROyg she lost sister, husband, daughter, …, about 20 members of her family in total
— Samuel Tadros (@Samueltadros) May 26, 2017
This most recent attack, claimed Saturday by the Islamic State, comes amidst a rising tide of anti-Coptic incitement by leaders of the Muslim Brotherhood here and abroad.
Over the weekend Eric Trager of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy published an article at Foreign Policy identifying some of the recent examples of Muslim Brotherhood incitement and encouragement of terrorism targeting Coptic Christians.
The Muslim Brotherhood is a hate group, and in @ForeignPolicy I provide examples of its sectarianism: https://t.co/kvtzmULbOh
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) May 27, 2017
Prominent Islamists and Muslim Brotherhood members are fanning the flames of hatred against Egyptian Christians. https://t.co/q0m3cu4f0V
— Foreign Policy (@ForeignPolicy) May 27, 2017
Among the examples Trager discovered after Friday’s attack on Coptic pilgrims was a Facebook post by Muslim Brotherhood youth leader Ahmed El-Moghir:
Disgusting post by Muslim Brother: Christians must reconcile w/Muslims "or their blood will continue to run like rivers & nobody will care" pic.twitter.com/Ao7DAYvm3h
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) May 26, 2017
That comment has caught the attention of several Middle East media outlets. Here in the U.S., not so much.
#تقارير24| "دماؤهم ستجري أنهاراً".. #الإخوان يحرضون على العنف ضد الأقباط
https://t.co/tCjly4fLNO pic.twitter.com/YD4NYjHbQF— 24.ae (@20fourMedia) May 28, 2017
https://twitter.com/AlBawabaEG/status/868676304660574213
This is far from the first time that El-Moghir has made the news:
Muslim Brother Ahmed Al-Mogheer: MB make a mistake abandoning terrorism, should return to terrorism to win: https://t.co/bKPQYXqlNO #Egypt
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) January 22, 2016
FJP denies links to activist who calls for armed resistance http://t.co/h0q5ohKdD6
— Egypt Independent (@EgyIndependent) April 4, 2014
After the dual Palm Sunday church bombings last month, Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood leader Wagdi Ghoneim justified the attacks that killed 49 because Coptic Christians had supported the Egyptian government.
Egyptian Islamist in Exile Wagdi Ghoneim: Churches Attacked Because Coptic "Crusaders" Supported "Despicable-Sisi" pic.twitter.com/0csgxJglZK
— MEMRI (@MEMRIReports) April 18, 2017
State Department records going back to the late 1980s identify Ghoneim as a Muslim Brotherhood leader back to the time he was one of the group’s most visible figures in Alexandria.
https://twitter.com/Mokhtar_Awad/status/852758338420867072
But as I noted on Twitter yesterday, Ghoneim was also a senior leader in the American Muslim community in Southern California until he was deported by authorities in December 2004:
Wagdi Ghoneim was also the former president of the North American Imams Federation before he was deported in 2004 https://t.co/rL6gi502sX
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) May 26, 2017
And as I reported earlier this month, Muslim Brotherhood fanboi and former Homeland Security adviser Mohamed Elibiary also justified the attacks on Coptic Christians, saying they had it coming:
Islamic State Threatens More Attacks on Egypt's Christians, Obama #CVE Adviser Says They Have It Coming https://t.co/rTqY8twMLa @pjmedia_com pic.twitter.com/tWlHxNd3qN
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) May 8, 2017
It's critical to note Elibiary literally exults – "subhanallah" (glory to allah) – in ISIS killing Coptic Christians https://t.co/WNDdN7ZgZC
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) May 8, 2017
Nor was this the first time that Elibiary engaged in anti-Christian incitement:
Disgraced Homeland Security Adviser Mohamed Elibiary Scapegoats Egypt's Christians — Again https://t.co/vJl5cP1MHq pic.twitter.com/XYBxE413w1
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) June 25, 2016
Mohamed Elibiary is not the only Muslim Brotherhood supporter in the U.S. engaging in anti-Christian rhetoric.
New York-based Ayat Oraby, a former Egyptian state news anchor, recently directed Islamic supremacist comments at the Coptic Christians in Egypt:
NY-based Brotherhood supporter, ex-TV anchor Ayat Oraby (@ayaa00): "The Crescent Must Always Be on Top of the Cross" https://t.co/6HhVuvUzYc
— Oren Kessler (@OrenKessler) September 27, 2016
After Friday’s attack she was at it again:
In typically bigoted rant, NY-based Islamist says #Egypt intel & Coptic Pope behind massacre of Copts. (She lobbied Congress in early May.) pic.twitter.com/jiIzZWpA9y
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) May 26, 2017
It should be noted that she was on Capitol Hill earlier this month lobbying against the proposed terror designation of the Muslim Brotherhood, a $5 million effort that the Muslim Brotherhood has bragged about in Middle East media.
Ayat Orabi (woman to the left) at Congress in early May.
Fact is Political Islam is sponsored by the left in the US as well as Londonistan. pic.twitter.com/a9qGaKp5iN— sherif ahmed 🇪🇬 (@sherifa78060270) May 26, 2017
Opinion: The Muslim Brotherhood Lobbies Congress https://t.co/0VkBP1i77R pic.twitter.com/GEiLSkKOQW
— Daily Caller (@DailyCaller) May 21, 2017
Since before the beginning of the Arab Spring in 2011, the Muslim Brotherhood has engaged in direct attacks targeting Christians in Egypt.
As I reported here at PJ Media, in April 2014 I toured several churches and monasteries in Upper Egypt that were targeted by the Muslim Brotherhood for looting and arson in August 2013 following the massive protests calling for the removal of Mohamed Morsi as president and his subsequent ouster.
Revisiting the Muslim Brotherhood's August 2013 'Reign of Terror' Targeting Egypt's Christians https://t.co/Rf31VJzz4z #homelandsecurity
— PJ Media (@PJMedia_com) August 14, 2016
I noted in that report that Coptic church officials specifically identified the Muslim Brotherhood as leading the attacks on their churches and monasteries:
This church in Minya I visited burned down by the Muslim Brotherhood was torched when MB mosque around the corner called out "GO ON JIHAD!" pic.twitter.com/HIdyVj3GBv
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) February 27, 2017
This Muslim Brotherhood FB page in Helwan openly incited attacks on churches and Christians in Aug 2013 pic.twitter.com/Cp4ZyUOsep
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) February 27, 2017
The Brotherhood’s involvement was not a state secret.
Muslim Brotherhood and Morsi supporters torch Egyptian churches http://t.co/OIjMrwF0ME
— The Jerusalem Post (@Jerusalem_Post) August 14, 2013
One of the international media’s favorite “moderate” Islamists, Tariq Ramadan, grandson of Muslim Brotherhood founder Hassan al-Banna, claimed that the government, not the Muslim Brotherhood, was to blame for the torching of the 70+ churches and monasteries throughout Egypt:
An Intellectual, grand son of Hassan el-Banna pretends army is burning #Copt churches to blame Muslim Brotherhood http://t.co/PQZgDn8lOz
— Etienne Rouault (@RouaultEtienne) August 19, 2013
Last month I visited the Two Saints Church in Cairo targeted by a suicide bomber during a worship service last December.
EXCLUSIVE: My Visit to the Site of the December Coptic Church Suicide Bombing in Cairo https://t.co/EfsTPiJUbD via @pjmedia_com pic.twitter.com/PvjwQv4g3o
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) May 9, 2017
While the Islamic State claimed credit for the attack, the bomber had previously been arrested for Muslim Brotherhood activity.
Suspect in Egypt chapel bombing that killed at least 25 had past run-in with cops https://t.co/f7FQnkn4Hc pic.twitter.com/tJjxHU7mNX
— New York Daily News (@NYDailyNews) December 13, 2016
The Egyptian Interior Ministry specifically fingered Muslim Brotherhood elements operating in the Gulf for their role in the Two Saints Church bombing.
Resurgent Terror in Egypt https://t.co/tluE2QS1gg The Muslim Brotherhood seeks revenge. By Yoni Ben Menachem.
pic of Copt Church after bomb pic.twitter.com/d4Wp2Tpu75— Jerusalem Center (@JerusalemCenter) December 18, 2016
https://twitter.com/JoumanaGebara/status/808581949740683265
The December and Palm Sunday bombings were preceded by the 2011 New Years Day bombing of a Coptic church in Alexandria that killed 23 people.
In that instance, senior Muslim Brotherhood official Essam El-Erian later boasted that the 2011 bombing had helped bring down Egyptian President Mubarak just a few weeks later.
Killing of Christians helped bring down Mubarak: Brotherhood's El-Erian – News – Aswat Masriya http://t.co/X1ktwkM24k #Egypt #مصر
— Aswat Masriya_En (@AswatMasriya_En) April 11, 2013
After the election of former Muslim Brotherhood spokesman Mohamed Morsi as president, attacks on the Coptic Christian community accelerated.
Protests that began in November 2012 after Morsi publicly declared himself above the law and the courts continued for months afterwards. When Christians rallied against Morsi’s policies in March 2013, Muslim Brotherhood cadres were unleashed to seize and torture the Christians inside a mosque near the presidential palace.
#Egyptian mosque turned into house of torture for #Christians after #Muslim #Brotherhood protest http://t.co/tQBRvGRElj
— Fox News (@FoxNews) March 26, 2013
Just days after, five Coptic youths who were killed in sectarian clashes were mourned during their funeral at the Coptic cathedral in Cairo. During the funeral, the cathedral was attacked by mobs with rocks and molotov cocktails.
Coptic Christians under siege as mob attacks Cairo cathedral http://t.co/ZhFtk2Ofl5
— Indy World (@IndyWorld) April 8, 2013
One of Morsi’s aides later blamed the Copts for the attack on the cathedral.
#Egypt presidential aide blames #Christians for cathedral attack, sparks fury – http://t.co/ketKtssnr4 #Coptic
— Al Arabiya English (@AlArabiya_Eng) April 10, 2013
The April 2013 attack on the Coptic cathedral was one of the defining moments that galvanized opposition to Morsi and led to the June 30, 2013, protests against Muslim Brotherhood rule — the largest protests in recorded human history. Morsi was removed from office days later.
One of the things that concerned many Egyptians was the Muslim Brotherhood’s direct role in inciting sectarian attacks:
During December protests against Morsi at the presidential palace, which ended with clashes that killed 11 people, senior FJP leader Mohamed El Beltagy said in a television interview that the majority of the anti-Morsi protesters were Christian. The Muslim Brotherhood’s official Arabic website published stories suggesting that the founder of an anarchist group called the Black Bloc, vilified by the Brotherhood, was a Christian who also led a Christian militia. During the referendum on a new constitution, the website published multiple stories alleging violations by Christian voters.
FJP officials sometimes associate with nonmembers who stir up tensions with their comments. Safwat Hegazy, a preacher who is not a member of the Brotherhood, spoke at campaign rallies on Morsi’s behalf and last year warned Christians that if they “splash water” on the legitimacy of the president, “we will spill his blood.” The FJP-dominated Shoura council, the upper house of parliament, appointed Mr. Hegazy to the National Council for Human Rights last year.
RT @kristenchick: And here is my article from yesterday about rise in sectarian rhetoric, including from FJP and MB http://t.co/6ztyMGwz69
— The Christian Science Monitor (@csmonitor) April 14, 2013
I’ve already noted the August 2013 attacks by the Muslim Brotherhood on churches throughout Egypt.
https://twitter.com/KirstenPowers/status/370524342834057218
But even before that campaign of destruction, 16 human rights groups in Egypt issued a statement calling on the Muslim Brotherhood and their supporters to stop religious incitement and anti-Christian rhetoric:
Islamist Groups Must Stop Inciting to Sectarian Violence; Protection of Christians Responsibility of the State – http://t.co/bHI180Mniu
— CIHRS (@CIHRS_Alerts) August 7, 2013
Needless to say, the attacks on Christians only escalated.
Muslim Brotherhood, Aug 15: Copt taxi driver is lynched, killed on street in Alexandria, car burned http://t.co/0IfG7nEg2h Graphic video
— Rorate Caeli (@RorateCaeli) August 16, 2013
In the Upper Egypt village of Delga, where I toured the 1,600-year-old monastery and its three churches that had been completely destroyed, a Christian man was set upon by a Muslim Brotherhood mob and literally torn to pieces. When some of the few Christians remaining in the village buried his remains, his body was dug back up by the local mob.
Attacks on Christians by Muslim Brotherhood mobs have continued on a regular basis.
Funeral held for Copt slain by Muslim Brotherhood: Cairo, on 5 February / MCN/
The funeral of Mina… http://t.co/nmeac3Zsy5 #Christian— MCN (@MCNdirect) February 5, 2014
Coptic Christian Mary Sameh, stabbed to death by Muslim Brotherhood protest mob in April http://t.co/odWxjSXRik pic.twitter.com/diT9xepS4N
— Patrick Poole (@pspoole) July 30, 2014
Copt shot in his shop during Brotherhood protest, says relative: Cairo, Jan. 27 /MCN/ by Michael Wa… http://t.co/CcH3VolOM8 #Christian
— MCN (@MCNdirect) January 27, 2015
In one horrific incident, two Coptic women were videotaped as they were raped by a Muslim Brotherhood mob.
Egypt, members of Muslim Brotherhood rape two christian copt's women at day: http://t.co/nds5j4ajeB Zionist Western intel criminalizes Islam
— S. Albert (@Harkonen2) July 16, 2014
When 21 Coptic Christian men were beheaded by ISIS in Libya in February 2015, the Muslim Brotherhood issued a statement blaming President Sisi for the murders:
#AMAY | Brotherhood blames presidency for Copt murders in #Libya
for more details: http://t.co/nH70JCI8Bv pic.twitter.com/o20HUO8iYZ
— Egypt Independent (@EgyIndependent) February 17, 2015
And yet just a few weeks later the families of many of those martyred Coptic men in Libya were attacked by the Muslim Brotherhood in the village in Upper Egypt where many of them came from:
Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood Mob Attacks Family of Coptic Christian Martyr Beheaded by ISIS in Libya http://t.co/GRIbRvEI1f #tcot
— PJ Media (@PJMedia_com) March 29, 2015
A documentary done later showed the families continued to live in a state of fear.
And so the violence and incitement by the Muslim Brotherhood not only continue, but become more extreme. And the Islamic State has decided to draft off the Muslim Brotherhood’s anti-Christian activity as they have bombed three separate churches since December and committed the attack on pilgrims last Friday.
https://twitter.com/Mokhtar_Awad/status/851065783434260480
The Muslim Brotherhood can condemn attacks on Copts all they like. They help foster a climate in which extremism flourishes. #Egypt
— Julie Lenarz (@MsJulieLenarz) April 9, 2017
The Palm Sunday suicide bomb attacks displayed how deep the anti-Christian hatred runs through the group:
MB issued a statement in English "condemning" #Egypt attacks; yet in Arabic it accuses sec forces of creating "illusion of terror"
— Menna منّة (@TheMiinz) April 9, 2017
The Muslim Brotherhood authors a conspiracy theory accusing #Egypt gov of "orchestrating or facilitating" the terrorist attacks on churches: pic.twitter.com/4XlhPdbRSz
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) April 9, 2017
The sectarian rot driving the Muslim Brotherhood comes directly from the group’s leadership.
Istanbul-based MB 'youth' spreads hideous conspiracy theory that Coptic Pope was informed of today's attack & left before it happened. pic.twitter.com/a2wkcawpgN
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) April 9, 2017
https://twitter.com/Mokhtar_Awad/status/852804264330010624
One of the Muslim Brotherhood’s most senior leaders has openly indulged in conspiracies involving the Coptic church bombings:
Muslim Brotherhood-led 'parl in exile' repeat ugly conspiracy theory that Sisi & "foreign conspiracies" planned yesterday's church attacks: pic.twitter.com/Lbcnc7NHOg
— Eric Trager (@EricTrager18) April 10, 2017
It’s worth noting this same Muslim Brotherhood leader was warmly received at the State Department in January 2015:
FLASH: Muslim Brotherhood-Aligned Leaders Hosted at State Department http://t.co/KK5SQFtiYS via @Kredo0 pic.twitter.com/Y4RGpbnzlD
— Free Beacon (@FreeBeacon) January 28, 2015
Yet the incitement continues:
A systematic push by Muslim Brotherhood to persecute Copts in Egypt, accusing them of armament, same was done prior to #ArmenianGenocide pic.twitter.com/U3d5p29RU0
— Bassem (@BBassem7) January 23, 2017
3 examples of the Brotherhood anti- Copt rhetoric: 1- https://t.co/DMsQ9zdtUN
2- https://t.co/lrhIPGJNL9
3- https://t.co/rF2eROEdmz#Egypt— Nervana Mahmoud (@Nervana_1) May 26, 2014
Leading some to take the overwhelming evidence of the Muslim Brotherhood incitement to violence to its logical conclusion:
Recognize Muslim Brotherhood for the hate group it is – The Hill op-ed by Rabbis Marvin Hier and Abraham Cooper http://t.co/3XTZjmCuUs
— SimonWiesenthalCntr (@simonwiesenthal) August 5, 2013
Join the conversation as a VIP Member