Would Kyle Rittenhouse Really Have Been Convicted if He Were Black?

Sean Krajacic/The Kenosha News via AP, Pool

If Kyle Rittenhouse were black, would he be in prison today after being convicted of murder? Or would he never even have faced trial, because he would have been killed by police on that fateful night in Kenosha when he was attacked by Antifa thugs? Many people are claiming that his acquittal proves that there is a double standard in the American justice system. Once again, however, reality differs from the Leftist narrative: on the same day that Kyle Rittenhouse was acquitted, a black man named Andrew Coffee IV was also acquitted of murder charges on the grounds of self-defense.


After Rittenhouse was acquitted Friday, the Leftist line quickly coalesced into claims that the verdict showed the power of white supremacy in the United States, even though everyone involved in the Rittenhouse case was white. NASCAR driver Bubba Wallace, who was widely reported as being the victim of a hate crime last year when a noose was discovered in his garage (the FBI determined that it was a garage-door puller), tweeted: “Ha, let the boy be black and it would’ve been life…hell he would’ve had his life taken before the bullshit trial.. sad.” Ohio congressional candidate Nina Turner agreed: “If Kyle Rittenhouse were Black, he would’ve been killed for holding that weapon. What’s a justice system without justice?!?!” Keith Boykin, author of Race Against Time: The Politics of a Darkening America, added: “I knew it. Kyle Rittenhouse is proof that white people can still break the law, carry illegal weapons, shoot and kill people, and get away with it in America by shedding tears and claiming self-defense.” Fox News’ featured Leftist Juan Williams had the same point of view: “If this had been a black teenager who had done this, wow, I think the laws might have treated him a little differently.”

White actress Sophia Bush was also enraged: “The miscarriage of justice today is enraging. This is white supremacy in action. This is hideous. He murdered people, bragged about it while throwing white power signs in a bar, and then manufactured tears to claim that despite his AR-15 HE was in danger. And he got off. Unreal.” Creepy storyteller Stephen King asked: “So…the white guy goes free. Is that the message?”


Well, no, that’s not the message. Proof of that came Thursday with the verdict in the case of Andrew Coffee IV in Vero Beach, Florida. According to ABC affiliate WPBF News, Coffee, a black man, “was found not guilty on all counts of murder and attempted first degree murder Friday.” Not only was Coffee acquitted, but the circumstances of his case made it a much less clear-cut case of self-defense than the Rittenhouse case was. Coffee was accused of shooting at deputies from the Indian River County Sheriff’s department as they were carrying out a drug raid at his home. Coffee’s girlfriend, Alteria Woods, was caught in the crossfire and killed. After a grand jury cleared two officers of responsibility for her death, Coffee was charged with her murder.

Related: ‘Where Is Your God Now?’ Portland Cops Do NOTHING as Antifa Attacks Prayer Event Led by Persecuted Christian Pastor

Coffee disputed the grand jury’s findings, taking the stand during his trial to blame the deputies for Woods’ death. His defense attorneys argued that he had been asleep, was startled awake by the raid, and fired at the officers because “he thought he was under attack.” Coffee explained: “I was trying to protect me and Alteria and I thought I was doing that, but I feel I didn’t protect her. I can’t sleep with that … they killed her.”


Coffee was found not guilty for the murder of Alteria Woods. Indian River County Sheriff Eric Flowers had this response to the verdict: “It’s disappointing that this jury did not see the tragic death of Alteria Woods occurred as a direct result of the actions of Andrew Coffee IV. Our hearts go out to the Woods family as they still suffer from a loss of their daughter, but we stand by a statement that she would still be here had Coffee simply complied with law enforcement.”

If the Left’s version of reality remotely corresponded to the real thing, Andrew Coffee IV would not have been acquitted, simply because he is black. In fact, he would likely have been killed by Indian River County Sheriff’s deputies during the drug raid in which Woods was killed. His acquittal is proof that the paranoid race-baiting fantasies of Bubba Wallace, Stephen King and the rest are not just false, but are irresponsible and incendiary attempts to make a volatile situation even more explosive. If the Left riots over the Rittenhouse verdict and innocent people are killed, the blood will be on the hands of those who are claiming that the verdict in the Rittenhouse case represents a great injustice. But as usual, they will not be called to account. They enjoy the real privilege in America today: Leftist privilege.




Trending on PJ Media Videos

Join the conversation as a VIP Member