America hasn't been this divided since the Civil War. But does that mean that if the election doesn't go the way that either party wants, another civil war will break out?
According to a poll taken by The Times, about a quarter of the U.S. population fears that civil war may break out after the election.
Barbara Walter, a noted Civil War historian, wrote a 2022 bestseller, "How Civil Wars Start and How to Stop Them." She said that measured against a checklist of the factors that could lead to civil war, “the United States … has entered very dangerous territory.” She added that “we are closer to civil war than any of us would like to believe because of "political extremism, cultural tribalism, the embrace of conspiracy theories, proliferation of guns and militias and the erosion of faith in government and democracy."
Only the final item on her checklist matters. Neither the right nor the left has faith in our institutions to govern us. The right doesn't trust the vote-counting process while the left thinks Trump will "destroy democracy" if he wins. It's an incendiary mix that doesn't bode well for the post-election period.
Fears that an eruption of violence is very or somewhat likely are shared across the political divide by 27 per cent of American adults, including 30 per cent of women and 24 per cent of men, YouGov found in a survey of 1,266 registered voters on October 18-21.
Twelve per cent of respondents said they knew someone who might take up arms if they thought Donald Trump was cheated out of victory in under two weeks’ time. Five per cent said they knew someone who might do the same if they thought Kamala Harris was cheated.
Does this really point to a "civil war" where there are two identifiable sides fighting for control of the government? If there is going to be violence after the election, it will be in the form of riots more than a military campaign.
Rebellions take planning and organization. The glorified brawl that took place on Jan. 6, 2021, was not a rebellion, no matter how the left wants to describe it. No court has ever said it was a rebellion. No insurrection charges were ever filed against any of the 1,200 defendants.
Related: Early Voting Breaks With the Past, Favors Republicans in Nevada
Whatever happens after the election, any violence will serve only to divide America further.
Concern over Trump’s response to losing again on November 5 was shown elsewhere in The Times-YouGov poll, with 66 per cent of voters saying the former president would not accept a narrow loss, compared with 27 per cent who said the same about Harris.
Among Harris supporters, 5 per cent said she would not accept a narrow loss and 90 per cent said the same about Trump; among Trump supporters, 50 per cent said Harris would not accept a narrow loss and 39 per cent said the same about Trump.
Trump is just as likely to accept the results of the election if he loses as not. Trump has a habit of doing exactly the opposite of what his enemies say he's going to do, so anything is possible.
What's not possible is Trump openly calling for armed resistance to the results. And without that, a large-scale revolt is not possible.
Not many respondents believed that Kamala Harris would offer armed resistance if she lost. Far more likely is an avalanche of legal filings challenging the results in several states.
But don't ever refer to her as an "election denier."
Join the conversation as a VIP Member