The PJ Tatler

Arizona GOP Censures McCain for Being a Liberal

The Arizona Republican Party passed a resolution of censure against Senator John Mccain, citing his support for issues “associated with liberal Democrats.”


What’s the latest litmus test? Immigration reform and funding Obamacare. Of course, McCain is not alone in his guilt. Half the Republican Party in Congress could be censured as well.

The real question is whether McCain is conservative enough for Arizona. Apparently not.

The Associated Press reports:

The resolution to censure McCain was approved by a voice-vote during a meeting of state committee members in Tempe, state party spokesman Tim Sifert said. It needed signatures from at least 20 percent of state committee members to reach the floor for debate.

Sifert said no further action was expected.

McCain spokesman Brian Rogers declined to comment on the censure. But former three-term Sen. Jon Kyl told The Arizona Republic ( ) that the move was “wacky.”

“I’ve gone to dozens of these meetings and every now and then some wacky resolution gets passed,” Kyl told the newspaper on Saturday. “But most people realize it does not represent the majority of the vast numbers of Republicans.”

Kyl also said McCain’s voting record was “very conservative.”

McCain isn’t up for re-election until 2016, when will turn 80. He announced in October that he was considering running for a sixth term.

According to the resolution, the 2008 Republican presidential nominee has campaigned as a conservative but has lent his support to issues “associated with liberal Democrats,” such as immigration reform and funding the federal health care law.

Several Republican county committees recently censured McCain.

Timothy Schwartz, the Legislative District 30 Republican chairman who helped write the resolution, said the censure showed that McCain was losing support from his own party.

“We would gladly embrace Sen. McCain if he stood behind us and represented us,” Schwartz said.

Fred DuVal, a Democrat who plans to run for Arizona governor, called the censure an “outrageous response to the good work Sen. McCain did crafting a reasonable solution to fix our broken immigration system.”

McCain has been dogged by conservatives objecting to his views on immigration and campaign finance, among other issues, since he first ran for Congress in 1982. Republican activists were also turned off by his moderate stances in the 2000 presidential race.


Today’s GOP is far too orthodox to tolerate supposed apostates like John McCain. But on almost all issues, McCain is a straight, down-the-line, solid conservative. His positions and votes on abortion, taxes, spending, energy, education, and free enterprise are a mirror to, or closely follow, those of the conservative majority. That’s the reality.

But in today’s GOP, reality is trumped by perception. His old-fashioned notions of compromise and working with the opposition to accomplish a legislative goal are now rejected by a majority of his party. Such outdated thinking is seen as betrayal and mushy-headed moderation. In short, it’s not McCain’s positions on the issues that are driving opposition to him; it’s his attitude and demeanor that rub right wingers the wrong way and feed the perception that he’s a traitor.

The simple truth is that the Republican Party has left John McCain behind. And he would do well to think seriously about retiring after his term ends.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member