Belmont Club

When the World Wears a Wire

The text exchanges between FBI agent Peter Strzok and his associate Lisa Page have recently been in the news.  Most of the coverage has focused on its politically controversial content.  What they say about Hillary, Trump and Obama.  Relatively less has been written about how the texts were “lost” and then “recovered” by the DOJ in the first place.  That is a perhaps a more important story in itself, but one no one is anxious to talk about. There are three known ways the text messages could have been recovered after they were deleted.

  1. From the device itself;
  2. From the retained records of the communications provider;
  3. Pulled from the archives of the National Security Agency or some similar law enforcement organization.

The phones themselves would be the easiest place to start.  If investigators could obtain them, a number of forensic tools can be used to pull “deleted” messages from the hardware. “Smartphone forensics experts can retrieve just about anything from any phone. Police will often seize and analyze phones for evidence of things such as indecent photos and videos, what calls were placed when and to whom, browser history, calendar events.”  Since Strzok and Page used FBI phones, it’s possible the text messages were recovered from the Bureau hardware.

Even if hardware cannot be obtained, the messages themselves may be retained by the communications provider for a number of days. “There are only five cellular companies who provide service in the United States. They are: Verizon Wireless, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile, U.S. Cellular.  All of the others that you see commercials for on TV – Cricket, Boost, Virgin Wireless, Jitterbug, Straight Talk, Tracfone, Family Mobile – and so on, lease their service from one (or more) of the five carriers listed above. From an investigative standpoint, it makes it simpler that we only have five potential sources where that data could be kept.”

While European countries order providers to keep SMS data for six months or more, American data retention periods are much shorter, too short in fact to have been probable sources of the Strzok-Page recovery.

There is however a third way the data could have been preserved.  The Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA) requires that all providers have wiretap facilities built into their equipment.  Not only the information on the outside of the messages (so called metadata equivalent to the information outside a paper envelope) is read, but the contents of the messages themselves can be scanned through a process of deep packet inspection.

There are two levels of CALEA wiretap. The first level only allows that the “meta data” about a call be sent. That is the parties to the call, the time of the call and for cell phones, the cell tower being used by the target phone. For text message, the same information is sent but the content is not sent. This level is called “Trap an Trace”. The next level of CALEA wiretap, when permitted actually sends the voice and content of text messages. This is called “Title III” wiretap.

The deep packet inspector mirrors the stream going through the provider and looks inside it.  The probe “examines the data part (and possibly also the header) of a packet as it passes an inspection point, searching for protocol non-compliance, viruses, spam, intrusions, or defined criteria to decide whether the packet may pass or if it needs to be routed to a different destination.”  If the probe sees something interesting it re-routes it, possibly to the NSA or some other law enforcement organization.

Prior to April, 2017 the NSA could sweep up any messages that mentioned or referred to foreign entities in the message body.  After that date the practice stopped. “Domestic emails that discuss foreign targets will no longer be swept up en masse, The New York Times reports.”  The rules were subsequently tightened. Wired described the change in procedure.

The charter of the National Security Agency limits its powerful surveillance to the rest of the world, not US citizens. But one controversial carve-out in NSA rules has for years allowed it to vacuum up communications that aren’t “to” or “from” a foreign target, but merely “about” one—no matter who sends or receives it. Now the NSA says it will end that practice. And in doing so, it concedes a significant win to the privacy advocates who have fought it for years.

The loophole the NSA is closing, as first reported by the New York Times, falls under the 702 provision of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. The NSA’s interpretation of FISA allowed it to search the vast firehose of internet data that passed through its wiretaps of fiberoptic cables for certain “selectors,” or search terms, and collect that data if any part of the communication passed outside the US—even if one or both people communicating were in fact Americans.

But prior to that date, if Strzok and Page had mentioned “Russia” or any sensitive keyword it might conceivably have triggered the deep packet inspector and caused the texts to be retained in an archive.  In fact the two were acutely aware of the possibility their messages were being recorded and warned each other against indiscretion. (Emphasis mine)

On March 16, 2016, Page texted Strzok: “I can not believe Donald Trump is likely to be an actual, serious candidate for president.” The next month, she texted: “So look, you say we text on that phone when we talk about Hillary because it can’t be traced, you were just venting bc you feel bad that you’re gone so much but it can’t be helped right now.”

The supreme irony of the Trump vs FBI saga is that both sides are using surveillance against each other.  Nobody it seems, not elected presidents nor federal agents, are free from its clutch.  So much data is being collected that the watchers are being watched.  The long term political consequences of pervasive surveillance are just beginning to be felt. Everybody thinks Skynet is working for them. What could go wrong?

Follow Wretchard on Twitter

For a list of books most frequently purchased by readers, visit my homepage.

Support the Belmont Club by purchasing from Amazon through the links below.


The Road Not Taken: Edward Lansdale and the American Tragedy in Vietnam, In this book, bestselling historian Max Boot chronicles the life of legendary CIA operative Edward Lansdale and reframes our understanding of the Vietnam War. Lansdale pioneered a “hearts and minds” diplomacy, first in the Philippines, then in Vietnam, a visionary policy that was ultimately crushed by America’s giant military bureaucracy. With interviews and newly available documents, Boot rescues Lansdale from historical ignominy and suggests that Vietnam could have been different had we only listened.

The Case for Christ: A Journalist’s Personal Investigation of the Evidence for Jesus, Retracing his own spiritual journey from atheism to faith, author Lee Strobel, former legal editor of the Chicago Tribune, cross-examines a dozen experts who are recognized authorities in their own fields. He challenges them with questions like, How reliable is the New Testament? Does evidence for Jesus exist outside the Bible? Is there any reason to believe the resurrection was an actual event? The book reads like a captivating, fast-paced novel but it’s not fiction. It’s a riveting quest for the truth about history’s most compelling figure.

Ghost Soldiers: The Epic Account of World War II’s Greatest Rescue Mission, by Hampton Sides. On January 28, 1945, 121 hand-selected U.S. troops slipped behind enemy lines in the Philippines. Their mission: March 30 rugged miles to rescue 513 POWs languishing in a hellish camp, among them the last survivors of the infamous Bataan Death March. This book vividly re-creates this daring raid, offering a minute-by-minute narration that unfolds alongside intimate portraits of the prisoners and their lives in the camp.

The Square and the Tower: Networks and Power, from the Freemasons to Facebook, by Niall Ferguson. The 21st century has been hailed as the Networked Age. But in this book, Ferguson argues that social networks are nothing new. From the printers and preachers who made the Reformation to the freemasons who led the American Revolution, it was the networkers who disrupted the old order of popes and kings. Far from being novel, our era is the Second Networked Age, with the computer in the role of the printing press. Once we understand this, both the past and the future start to look very different indeed. Ferguson offers a whole new way of imagining the world.

For a list of books most frequently purchased by readers, visit my homepage.

Did you know that you can purchase some of these books and pamphlets by Richard Fernandez and share them with your friends? They will receive a link in their email and it will automatically give them access to a Kindle reader on their smartphone, computer or even as a web-readable document.
The War of the Words, Understanding the crisis of the early 21st century in terms of information corruption in the financial, security and political spheres
Rebranding Christianity, or why the truth shall make you free
The Three Conjectures, reflections on terrorism and the nuclear age
Storming the Castle, why government should get small
No Way In at Amazon Kindle. Fiction. A flight into peril, flashbacks to underground action.
Storm Over the South China Sea, how China is restarting history in the Pacific
Tip Jar or Subscribe or Unsubscribe to the Belmont Club

Join the conversation as a VIP Member