Good Friday Morning!
Thank God it’s Friday, but don’t forget to pray for the families of the 17 dead and many wounded victims of the shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla. Wednesday. Which brings us to…
18 school shootings in 2018?
Many media outlets pushed the statistic that there have been no fewer than 18 school shootings in America this year. Politico, TIME, CNBC, ABC News, WUSA9, the New York Daily News, and HuffPost all reported the statistic.
Many activists also shared the stat, including the president of the LGBT group the Human Rights Campaign.
It's been 19 years since Columbine. 5 years since Newtown. The inaction in the wake of these tragedies has gotten us to 18 school shootings in the last 6 weeks. Kids are dying — we can't tolerate politics as usual anymore.
— Chad Griffin (@ChadHGriffin) February 14, 2018
And Rep. Steve Cohen (D-Tenn.):
Moments of silence have absolutely no effect on the safety of American school children. There have been 18 school shootings this year, moments of silence have done nothing to prevent them.
— Steve Cohen (@RepCohen) February 15, 2018
And MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell:
— MSNBC (@MSNBC) February 15, 2018
The statistic came from the gun control activist group Everytown For Gun Safety. By Friday morning, the group had actually removed one of the entries from its website, because the building where the shooting took place was no longer being used as a school.
Everytown took a rather liberal view on what constitutes a school shooting. Eight of the shootings could be summarized as “Gun fired but no one injured.” Two (including the one that was later removed) involved “attempted or completed suicide, with no intent to injure other person.” One involved a gun being fired unintentionally, wounding two students.
Only seven of the 18 shootings involved an “attack on other person resulting in injury or death.” Even that number proved misleading, however. Three of these incidents involved only one person being wounded by a gun, one of them involved one student being wounded, but not by a gun.
One of these shootings took place at a sorority party, two more in parking lots. One person was fatally wounded in a parking lot fight.
Three could be considered school mass shootings, in a broad sense. On January 22, a student in Italy, Texas opened fire in the high school cafeteria, wounding one student and firing at another student, but missing. On January 23, a student opened fire at Marshall County High School in Benton, Ky., killing two students and injuring more than a dozen others.
In total, all “seventeen” of Everytown’s shootings before the Parkland shooting resulted in a grand total of 5 deaths, two from suicide, one from a fight in a parking lot, and two from a true mass shooting.
Three mass shootings is still too many for a year this young, but it is nothing like the 18 falsely reported. To their credit, PolitiFact and The Washington Post joined conservative outlets such as the Daily Wire, National Review, and The Washington Examiner in correcting the statistic.
A Congressional fail on immigration.
Senators failed to pass a bipartisan bill to resolve the future of Dreamers, and dedicate $25 billion to border security and some other measures. The bill failed to get the 60 votes necessary for a full floor vote. The vote was 54-45. Another plan, supported by President Trump, also failed, 39-60, CNN reported.
Transgender custody battle.
A 17-year-old girl has been removed from her parents’ custody after they refused to give her trans-sex hormones, suggesting they would be bad for her. The girl’s doctors say she will commit suicide if she cannot take the hormones and identify as a male. The judge is expected to rule on the case today.
A Transgender Dilemma:
If gender identity is fixed, it must have a basis in nature and thus it cannot be detached from the scientific reality of biological sex.
If gender identity is not fixed, it shouldn't serve as grounds for irreversible medical procedures.
— James Anderson (@proginosko) February 14, 2018
If the parents lose, this could become an explosive case, perhaps going all the way up to the Supreme Court. Stay tuned. In the meantime, read more about the case here.