CNN’s Scott Jennings was having none of the hand-wringing on Monday’s panel discussion over the Trump administration’s handling of the deportation of MS-13 gang member Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia — the latest cause célèbre of the radical left. While the liberals on the panel tiptoed around legal technicalities and rhetorical posturing, Jennings delivered a blunt reality check that left the rest of the table scrambling.
Anchor Abby Phillip tried to tee up criticism of Trump by focusing on “the optics” of sending “Americans” to El Salvador — even though Abrego Garcia is an illegal immigrant. But Jennings wasn’t distracted. “Yes. He said they were studying the laws. I mean, there wasn’t any definitive statement,” he clarified, before cutting right to the core of the debate: “I think you guys need to understand, for the Trump administration, there’s no version of this man’s life that ends up with him living in the United States.”
Jennings laid out the Trump administration’s reasoning without flinching: “He’s an illegal alien from El Salvador who came to the country illegally, who has a deportation order, who, in their view and in the view of some immigration courts, has an affiliation with MS-13.”
Phillip tried to interject by claiming that Garcia’s affiliation with MS-13 isn't definitive because Abrego Garcia “strongly disputes in court.”
Well, I guess that settles it, right?
“I’m telling you that their view of it is that… it’s an El Salvador citizen who was sent back to El Salvador, who was in the country illegally,” Jennings reiterated. “According to some people in his long process… he has an existing deportation order, [and they] believe he has an affiliation with MS-13.”
Then Jennings repeated his knockout point: “There’s no version of this man’s life where he comes back.”
As the panel continued to push the narrative of unjust exile, Jennings laid out the consequences if Abrego Garcia is returned. “If the president of El Salvador releases him and we do facilitate his return, when he lands in this country, one of two things will happen," Jennings explained. "He’ll either be arrested… or sent to another country that I promise you you don’t want to go to. He’s not going to be allowed to come back and live in this country as though he is a U.S. citizen.”
Harvard Law’s Jay Michaelson jumped in with the melodramatic accusation, “That’s literally the definition of tyranny, right?”
Umm, no? What are they teaching at Harvard Law these days? Seriously.
Michaelson continued, “So, here's what's going to happen: We're going to throw him in jail. No, there's a thing called the rule of law and due process, which has not been followed in this case. And if I have a slightly optimistic take on this; I actually think this is going to come back to bite the Trump administration. Because what's going to happen is the next time this goes up the court system, they have absolutely zero credibility to say, Don't worry, you can file a habeas petition. You can get your person back.”
Related: WATCH: Stephen Miller Just Destroyed the Media Over Deportations
But Jennings coolly reminded the panel, “They have the ability to deport people who have deportation orders.” He added that Garcia “got due process. He has a deportation order.”
Later, he dissected the legal victory Trump’s team got last week. “The reason the administration believes they got a big win at the Supreme Court is because the district court was trying to compel the executive on foreign affairs. The Supreme Court threw that out,” Jennings explained. “The courts have long recognized that they cannot compel the executive on foreign policy matters.”
As for the politics? Jennings didn’t sugarcoat it. “What they also believe is that, politically, the American people want them to be as aggressive as possible… to solve a crisis that has festered for years,” he asserted.
Then he drove the moral argument home with a chilling reminder: “We keep calling this guy 'Maryland man' in the press. Nobody seems to worry about the Maryland mother, Rachel Morin, who was murdered by someone that the previous administration let out of jail.”
🚨🔥Scott Jennings smacks CNN panel furiously demanding return of deported El Salvadoran to the US with stark reality check:
— Western Lensman (@WesternLensman) April 15, 2025
“He's NOT going to be allowed to come back and live in this country as though he is a U.S. citizen. He is not."
They can’t seem to wrap their heads… pic.twitter.com/y0qGMOmvNl
The mainstream media won't tell you the full story about illegal immigration and MS-13—they're too busy spinning narratives about "Maryland men." Get the unfiltered truth about border security and immigration enforcement. Join PJ Media VIP today using code FIGHT for 60% off and support real journalism that isn't afraid to call it like it is.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member