Earlier this year, when Rep. Kevin McCarthy struck a deal with the House Freedom Caucus to secure enough votes to assume the speaker position, a provision was included that would make it easier to remove him from the role. As a result, he may now face removal from the position only a few months after taking office, following his criticism of other party members for failing to produce a budget proposal.
Earlier this week, a New York Times article revealed private discussions between McCarthy and some of his allies in which he expressed doubts about the ability of senior GOP members to present a budget proposal. This is now causing infighting in the House GOP—which the Republican Party doesn’t need right now.
According to the article, McCarthy singled out House Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-LA) and Budget Chairman Jodey Arrington (R-TX), and expressed skepticism that they could successfully complete a budget proposal. Furthermore, McCarthy reportedly characterized Scalise as “ineffective,” and expressed a lack of confidence in Arrington to deliver a budget proposal.
However, several Republicans accused McCarthy of scapegoating Scalise and Arrington to obfuscate his inability to produce a budget proposal, citing the stalled negotiations between the speaker and Joe Biden concerning the debt ceiling.
“Our nation is staring down the barrel of a debt crisis and my budget committee colleagues and I are focused on one thing: passing a budget that will stop this reckless spending and restore fiscal sanity in Washington before it’s too late,” Arrington told Axios in a statement.
Related: A New Hope to Flip an Arizona Senate Seat?
Meanwhile, some in the House GOP are losing confidence in McCarthy and don’t see how he remains speaker.
“The members I’ve spoken with are just stunned by his rebuking of his budget chair, and certainly of our leadership,” a House Republican told Axios. “I can’t imagine [he will last an entire term].”
Rep. Ralph Norman (R-S.C.), who is a member of the Budget Committee and was among McCarthy’s 20 defectors, strongly criticized the infighting within the party and urged McCarthy to assume greater responsibility.
“The agreements made by Speaker McCarthy, among other things, is to begin the ten-year balanced budget NOW and with his initiatives & directives,” Norman said in a statement. “It’s HIS responsibility to get the 218 votes to ensure our nation’s financial security JUST AS HE DID IN SECURING THE 218 votes for speaker.”
One thing is for sure: At a time when House Republicans hold a razor-thin majority, party infighting is the last thing the party needs. The Republican Party needs to maintain a united front to achieve its legislative agenda and avoid losing ground in upcoming elections.
When a party lacks a shared vision and a clear message, it becomes vulnerable to accusations of disarray, which can erode public confidence in its ability to govern effectively. This stands in stark contrast to the unity seen on the Democrat side of the aisle.
The Republican Party risks squandering its opportunity to win back the White House, hold the House, and win back the Senate in 2024 if it can’t remain unified. It must come together and offer a clear and compelling message that resonates with voters.
