The Smuggler’s Moon
It’s a good night for the trade. The tide is high, the air still, the moon sharp and white as a coin newly struck. Out beyond the breakers, two small boats ghost toward shore, their oars muffled in rags, their hulls heavy with casks of West Indian rum and molasses. The shallow-draft sloop that brought them up from Bermuda rides deeper water a mile off, its lanterns shuttered.
On the beach, men wait with covered lanterns and horse-drawn carts. The tide pools glint like molten silver, and from the headland comes the faint jangle of harness metal. Someone coughs. Someone else mutters a curse and spits into the sand. The caves are dry tonight, the storage pits ready. All they need is the signal.
It’s a holiday, King George’s birthday, which means the redcoats stationed at the harbor are either drunk or sleeping off the rum that’s now being hauled ashore by the barrel. The town will wake richer by dawn. The customs man, if he notices at all, will take his cut and look the other way.
This is the New England coast, sometime in the 1760s, and half the men you see here will be patriots soon enough. They will sign declarations, lead militias, and speak of liberty as though it were a sacred flame. Tonight, though, they are smugglers — good citizens by day, lawbreakers by night, bound together by profit and necessity.
Smuggling would pay for the very revolution that made us free. It gave the colonies the wealth to arm themselves and the independence of spirit to defy the crown. But the habit did not stop when the war was won. The new Republic kept the old vice. We had learned how to profit from illegality, and once a nation learns that lesson, it is slow to unlearn it.
Every age in America finds its own way to smuggle, its own border to cross when law grows inconvenient. What once came ashore in barrels now comes across the Rio Grande in tractor-trailers and desert caravans. The goods have changed, but the motive has not. Then, it was molasses and tea; now, it is labor. Then, they called it free trade; now, they call it compassion.
We remain, in spirit if not in name, a smuggler’s republic: a nation that loves its laws in the daylight and breaks them by moonlight, so long as the price is right and the neighbors don’t talk.
The Founding Hypocrisy: Liberty and the Contraband of Conscience
Smuggling was not a fringe trade in the colonies. It was the bloodstream of the coastal economy. By the 1760s, Boston merchants were importing as much as three-quarters of their goods illegally — Dutch tea, French molasses, Spanish silks, all carried in under false manifests and quiet understandings. The customs men were few, the coves were many, and the juries refused to convict their own.
John Hancock, that bold signature on our Declaration, was also one of the most successful smugglers in British America. His ships defied royal tariffs as a matter of course. When one was seized by the crown, riots broke out. The patriot mob cheered not for justice, but for evasion. Liberty, to them, meant the right to cheat the king.
And that liberty was expensive. The contraband wealth that flowed through Boston, Salem, and Newport became the seed money of revolution, buying arms, gunpowder, and the ships that carried dispatches and diplomats across the Atlantic. In that sense, smuggling financed freedom itself.
But when the shooting stopped and the new nation stood on its own, the habit proved harder to shake than the enemy. The same men who had defied royal tariffs now defied federal ones. They built the laws but would not obey them. Smuggling had become a kind of national addiction, a way of life we couldn’t bring ourselves to condemn, because too many people had grown rich from it.
The new Republic depended on customs revenue to survive. Without it, there would be no navy, no courts, no salaries for congressmen or clerks. America had won her freedom and suddenly found herself in desperate need of the taxes she’d been too proud to pay.
Thus began the first great American contradiction: a nation born in rebellion against authority that now needed authority to endure. The Revolution had cleansed the sin of smuggling by changing who was robbed. The crime was not ended, only nationalized.
And if that sounds familiar, it should. For today we play the same moral shell game, only with human cargo instead of barrels of rum.
The Smuggler’s Economy: Profit in the Shadows
Smuggling thrived for the same reason illegal immigration thrives now: because everyone got something out of it. The merchants made money. The farmers and tavern-keepers bought cheaper goods. The customs officers looked away for a price. The juries refused to punish neighbors who filled their towns with contraband. Law became optional when profit was certain.
That’s how corruption always starts in a republic, not from malice, but from shared convenience.
Like those early smugglers, America has learned to moralize the illegal. Our forefathers called it “free trade.” Today’s human traffickers — and those who profit from their labor — call it “opportunity.” The colonists said they were defying tyranny while lining their pockets; today’s political class claims to be defending humanity while doing the same. Both are lies wrapped in sentiment. In truth, certain groups profit, convince everyone else that they’re benefitting too, and then soothe the nation’s conscience with pretty words about kindness and love. But underneath it all, honest workers lose jobs and hope, and the illegal immigrant lives in fear.
When a society rewards lawbreaking because it is lucrative, it doesn’t stay a society for long. It becomes a market, and everything, even virtue, is up for sale.
The Labor Market Parallel
In the eighteenth century, smuggled goods undercut honest merchants and domestic producers. The tailor who paid his tariffs couldn’t compete with the man who slipped untaxed cloth through a side door. The farmer who sold lawful rum lost his market to a neighbor who bought from the smugglers. Law-abiding citizens became the fools of their own republic.
So it is now. The employer who hires legal, tax-paying workers is punished by higher costs, while his competitor down the road profits from under-the-table labor. The construction foreman, the meatpacker, the trucker, the farmer — all feel the pressure to cheat just to survive. And once cheating becomes necessary, honesty becomes a luxury.
The result is a shadow economy, one that drains dignity from labor itself. American workers are driven out of their own industries, their wages depressed, their unions broken, their safety ignored. The illegal worker, trapped by fear of discovery, cannot demand justice. Both are crushed by the same system, which rewards exploitation and punishes virtue.
In the old smuggling towns, that system over time hollowed out the meaning of patriotism. In ours, it hollows out the meaning of citizenship.
The Moral Mechanics of Hypocrisy
America has always had a dangerous talent for self-deception. It blesses what is profitable and calls it good, even when that profit rests on the suffering of others. The smugglers of the eighteenth century hid behind talk of liberty while robbing their own government blind. Their descendants do the same today, cloaking greed in the language of compassion.
There is nothing merciful about breaking the law for money. There is nothing kind about building an economy on fear and silence. Illegal immigration does not lift the poor; it crushes them. It robs honest citizens of their work and dignity, drives families into poverty, and leaves children growing up in the kind of homes where despair turns to violence. I know what that looks like.
Law exists for a reason. It is the line that separates justice from chaos. When people undercut it for profit or political gain, they are not acting in love — they are using the language of love to sanctify exploitation. Our forefathers justly revolted against a distant government that neither represented them nor cared to understand their needs and convictions. Their defiance was rooted in duty and moral clarity. The men and women who once helped slaves escape broke the law to restore justice; today’s political class breaks it to avoid accountability. Those are not the same thing.
A society that chooses lawlessness in the name of virtue is not compassionate. It is corrupt. And corruption, once tolerated, spreads from the border to the boardroom, from the courthouse to the family home, until even the innocent are made to pay.
The Moment of Reckoning
Every era of corruption eventually reaches its breaking point. The early Republic learned that the hard way. When smuggling grew so rampant that it starved the new government of revenue, Congress finally acted. The Revenue Cutter Service, the ancestor of today’s Coast Guard, was founded to chase down the smugglers who had once been heroes. The same towns that had winked at their trade began to call them thieves. Order was restored, not by speeches, but by enforcement.
The United States stands at the same threshold now. For decades, the political class spoke of “border challenges” and “immigration reform” while doing nothing to stop the rot. They called it compassion, but it was cowardice — a refusal to face the price of lawlessness.
That has begun to change. For the first time in a generation, the government is enforcing the border as if it means it. Illegal crossings are being stopped, deportations are real, and the rules that govern work visas are tightening. These actions are not cruel. They are the necessary work of a nation deciding once again that its laws matter.
Real compassion has boundaries. It protects the weak from being used and the honest from being betrayed. Enforcement, done rightly, is not hatred; it is the restoration of justice. The same nation that once had to choose between smuggling and solvency must now choose between order and collapse. If America is to remain a republic at all, it must stop pretending that virtue and law can be separated.
The Deeper Pattern: America’s Cycles of Vice and Renewal
This isn’t the first time the Republic has been forced to reckon with its own appetites. We seem to learn only through exhaustion: sin first, repentance later. The pattern is as old as the nation itself.
Vice becomes profit. Profit becomes habit. Habit becomes crisis. And only then does the country rediscover why law exists at all.
The smuggling age gave way to enforcement and lawful trade. The bootlegging age gave way to regulation and honesty in commerce. Each collapse began with the same excuses: “it helps everyone,” “the government is too harsh,” “it’s just business.” Each collapse ended when ordinary citizens had finally suffered enough to demand order again.
Illegal immigration is only the latest form of that cycle. It dresses itself in new language, but the bones are ancient: greed hiding behind virtue, self-interest disguised as compassion, the powerful growing fat while the poor and the honest pay the price. But if America still has any moral strength left — and I believe it does — the correction has already begun.
This time, the reckoning isn’t just about wages or laws. It’s about truth. Whether a nation that has learned to lie to itself for comfort can relearn how to tell the truth for survival.
Restoring the Honest Republic
The smuggler’s moon still hangs over this country. It changes shape — once it gleamed over barrels of rum, now it glints on tractor trailers and desert dust — but the light is the same: bright enough to see the profit, dim enough to hide the guilt.
That light has led America astray more than once. But we are not doomed to follow it forever. The cure for corruption isn’t cruelty, and it isn’t chaos; it’s courage. The courage to tell the truth even when it costs us something. The courage to enforce the law even when others call it harsh. The courage to call evil by its name, and good by its own.
A republic cannot survive on sentiment and slogans. It lives or dies on whether its people believe that justice still matters. True compassion doesn’t wink at exploitation or reward deceit; it restores order so that every man, woman, and child can live without fear, citizen and immigrant alike.
America has been a smuggler’s republic before, and each time we’ve come back stronger for having faced the truth. The question now is whether we’ll do it again — whether we’ll choose to live as a nation of laws or as a marketplace of excuses.
Because the line between liberty and lawlessness has never been a wall of stone. It’s a line in the soul. And when that line holds, the Republic stands.
The government is still closed, thanks to Chuck Schumer and radical Democrats who put illegals ahead of Americans. Schumer even boasted, “every day gets better for us,” as millions suffer the effects of his shutdown. They own this disaster. Stay informed—join today with promo code POTUS47 for 74% off VIP membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member