Chris Hayes Compares His Employers at NBC to Those Who 'Defended Slavery'
Or, Two NBCs in One!
The connection between slavery and fossil fuels, however, is more than metaphorical. Before the widespread use of fossil fuels, slaves were one of the main sources of energy (if not the main source) for societies stretching back millennia. Prior to the Industrial Revolution, nearly all energy to power societies flowed from the natural ecological cascade of sun and food: the farmhands in the fields, the animals under saddle, the burning of wood or grinding of a mill. A life of ceaseless exertion.
Let me pause here once again to be clear about what the point of this extended historical comparison is and is not. Comparisons to slavery are generally considered rhetorically out of bounds, and for good reason. We are walking on treacherous terrain. The point here is not to associate modern fossil fuel companies with the moral bankruptcy of the slaveholders of yore, or the politicians who defended slavery with those who defend fossil fuels today.
In fact, the parallel I want to highlight is between the opponents of slavery and the opponents of fossil fuels. Because the abolitionists were ultimately successful, it’s all too easy to lose sight of just how radical their demand was at the time: that some of the wealthiest people in the country would have to give up their wealth. That liquidation of private wealth is the only precedent for what today’s climate justice movement is rightly demanding: that trillions of dollars of fossil fuel stay in the ground. It is an audacious demand, and those making it should be clear-eyed about just what they’re asking. They should also recognize that, like the abolitionists of yore, their task may be as much instigation and disruption as it is persuasion. There is no way around conflict with this much money on the line, no available solution that makes everyone happy. No use trying to persuade people otherwise.
— MSNBC talking head Chris Hayes in The Nation today. Link safe; goes to Twitchy, where Twitter users are wondering if Hayes was intoxicated from, presumably, non-petroleum-based spirits, when he wrote the above and Tweeted:
@chrislhayes How drunk are you, seriously?
— Joe Rival (@JerseyJoe74) April 22, 2014
Wait'll Chris discovers how his bosses make their money:
NASCAR has finalized the other half of its next long-term TV contract with NBC and severed future broadcast ties with ESPN and Turner Sports.
NBC and Fox will share rights to the Sprint Cup Series beginning with the 2015 season.
NBC and NASCAR agreed to a contract that runs from 2015-2024, but didn’t release financial terms of the deal.
NBC picks up the last 20 of a scheduled 36 points Sprint Cup races, and they could air Sunday afternoons as a lead-in to Sunday Night Football. Fox and NBC will share TV rights to the Nationwide Series, which has aired on ESPN since 2007 ABC and ESPN began a NASCAR deal in place of NBC.
— “NBC returns to NASCAR in deal that runs through 2024,” USA Today, July 23rd, 2013.
OK Chris, here's your action plan. If indeed there are "parallels between the abolition of slavery and today's climate fight," then your mission is to barge into the NBC boardroom and convince them to drop NASCAR coverage. And the NFL -- all those charter flights to the games, and the Goodyear Blimp circling around overhead at the stadium -- those will have to be dropped from coverage. And no car chases in cop shows, unless it's hot Prius on Prius action. And no stretch limos for NBC, CNBC and MSNBC execs and the on-air talent. No helicopters or jet flights for the news team.
Do all that, have NBC sign off on it, then get back to us. If you're going to accuse your bosses of the moral equivalent of slavery (Because Al Gore took the moral equivalent of the Holocaust decades ago, I guess), you must force them to stop.
Do it for Gaia, man. Do it for Gaia.
On the other hand, somebody else at the Nation has a much better handle on things: "Let This Earth Day Be The Last:"
F*** Earth Day.
No, really. F*** Earth Day. Not the first one, forty-four years ago, the one of sepia-hued nostalgia, but everything the day has since come to be: the darkest, cruelest, most brutally self-satirizing spectacle of the year.
F*** it. Let it end here.
Works for me; as Kathy Shaidle joked when she forward the above link, "Iowahawk, is that you...?"
Related: "Hard. Core."
More: Heh, indeed:
@PJMedia_com @EdDriscoll Well, they're both Democrats. There's that.
— John Hinderaker (@jhinderaker) April 22, 2014
Update: "The message to the carbon industry seems to be: You are surrounded. Give up. Don't make us shoot," Byron York notes at the Washington Examiner, unpacking the violence lurking just underneath what York describes as Hayes' "radical 'climate justice' manifesto."
Which would perfectly square the circle, as it wasn't that long ago that MSNBC was declaring violent metaphoric imagery as racist.