Get PJ Media on your Apple

PJM Lifestyle

Billy Corgan: End Rock ‘n’ Roll’s Crisis Theology

Finally, a trend this Jew can believe in.

Susan L.M. Goldberg


September 13, 2013 - 1:00 pm
Page 1 of 2  Next ->   View as Single Page

Last week Billy Corgan, best known as the sole permanent member of the Gen-X band Smashing Pumpkins, created some Internet buzz when he remarked in a CNN interview:

You’re not supposed to talk about God, even though most of the world believes in God. It’s sort of like “don’t go there.” … I think God is the most unexplored territory in rock and roll music.

That quote prompted the interviewer to ask Corgan for his view on Christian rock, about which Chris Queen so eloquently commented this past Sunday at PJLifestyle. As a Jew I am rather ill-equipped to comment on the state of Christian rock, but another remark Corgan made that didn’t get reprinted multiple times got me thinking:

Most people are living lives of sort of survival. And constantly posing an existential crisis either through your fantasy or oblivion really has been pretty much explored in rock and roll, at least in the Western version of rock and roll. …We’ve sort of, kind of been through all of that.

I can speak to existential crises: Jews do suffering and do it well. But Jews also take action. Seeded in the age-old Rabbinic notion that good deeds get you into God’s good graces, American Jews have been acculturated into avid philanthropy and social activism advocating for a wide-range of well-intentioned causes. As a result, a Jew’s existential crisis never ends: When you aren’t being persecuted you have plenty of time to beat yourself or your fellow people over the head for not being a better Jew. This intrinsic guilt has become a force driving my own Jewish generation into personal success and the pursuit of social justice …and as far away from God (i.e., “judgement”) as humanly possible.

A while ago I observed that the Jewish teaching of the biblical concept of tikkun olam (repairing the world) had been manipulated in the same way 19th century social gospelists manipulated New Testament teachings to serve their socialist political aims. To manipulate scripture you must take God out of the picture, and in a world where no amount of good is ever good enough, social justice becomes enslavement to the notion of an impossible salvation.

Comments are closed.

All Comments   (4)
All Comments   (4)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
I keep a playlist I call the Accidental Hymnal: Songs that sound religious to me. Included:
Simple Minds, "Glittering Prize"
Peter Gabriel, "Solsbury Hill"
Echo & the Bunnymen, "Crystal Days" and "Silver"
David Bowie, "Soul Love" and "Look Back in Anger"
The The, "This Is the Day"
And I could go on all night. (I assume you can now guess my age very accurately.)
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
"And the three men I admire most
The father, son, and the Holy Ghost
They caught the last train for the coast
The day the music died"
Don McLean 1971

"If you're drowning out in the waters and you can't stay afloat
Ask Hashem for mercy and he'll throw you a rope
You're looking for help from God, you say he couldn't be found
Searching up in the sky and looking beneath the ground"
Matisyahu 2004

I don't know, religion still works in music.

1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Beautifully said! And thanks for the shout out... :-)
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
View All