How Not to Promote Immigration Reform
"This CNN story makes it sound like Jose Antonio Vargas worked very hard to get arrested. Which I guess makes sense," Mollie Hemingway tweeted earlier today. Jonathan S. Tobin of Commentary adds that Vargas isn't helping his cause:
Today, America’s most prominent illegal immigrant arrived at the border between Mexico and the United States to demonstrate his solidarity with the tens of thousands of people streaming into the country without permission. But the stunt by which former journalist Jose Antonio Vargas got himself arrested did more to undermine support for immigration reform than to foster sympathy for the illegals.
Vargas became a national figure three years ago when the former Washington Post reporter outed himself in the New York Times as an illegal immigrant. Vargas came to the United States at 12 from the Philippines to live with his grandparents who were naturalized citizens. But he was brought here by a “coyote” without a legal visa and spent the rest of his life lying about his status and using fake documents. After graduating college he consulted an immigration lawyer who told him his only path to citizenship was to return to his home country, wait ten years and then apply to come back with permission. On the cusp of a successful career he refused and continued lying even as he was part of a Post team that won a Pulitzer. Eventually, he tired of the deceit as he continued to rise in mainstream journalism and decided to put himself forward as a symbol of the plight of the so-called “dreamers”—people who were brought to the country illegally as kids and who went on to make a contribution to society.
"Spent the rest of his life lying about his status and using fake documents." Vargas will never make it as a leftwing journalist with those sorts of tactics.
Oh wait -- let me check with Dan Rather, Matt Yglesias, and Touré on that last supposition and get back to you.