Conservatives in the Mist, Yet Again
Sally Kohn explains "What I learned as a liberal talking head on Fox News" to the Christian Science Monitor:
My time at Fox News was marked by meeting and working with some of the kindest, smartest, and most talented people I've had the pleasure of meeting in life. As I said in my TED talk, Sean Hannity is one of the sweetest people you'll ever meet – and even now that I've parted ways with Fox, he remains a good friend and mentor.
For a radical progressive who once harbored negative stereotypes about folks on the right, it was a turning point for me to meet people such as Mr. Hannity, Karl Rove, Monica Crowley, Sarah Palin, and so many others, and see that – though we certainly disagree profoundly on political issues – they're personable and kind and human. Just like me.
It's strange to suggest that a seemingly simple realization such as that is in fact a profound revelation, but in our hyperpartisan era, when we often vilify the other side as being less-than-human, it is.
Which sounds almost exactly like what liberal Fox pundit Kirsten Powers said to Real Clear Politics' Carl Cannon a couple of months ago:
Cannon began by asking Powers how she is treated by her Fox colleagues. He recalled that New York Times’ conservative columnist David Brooks was not well-received when he first started writing for the Times and asked if Powers had encountered a similar experience.
“People are really nice at Fox,” Powers revealed. “It’s been good for because I – before that, I lived in a real liberal bubble.”
“All my friends were liberals and I grew up in a really liberal family,” she continued. “I had a lot of ideas about conservatives and then I got to Fox and just, I was like, ‘Oh, they’re not all evil and stupid.’”
As I noted back then, Kirsten Powers was living out Krauthammer's Law:
I realize she’s speaking glibly and off-the-cuff, but the inference is that on some level, Powers actually did believe that all conservatives are evil, thus butting up against fellow Fox News pundit Charles Krauthammer’s law of politics from over a decade ago. “To understand the workings of American politics, you have to understand this fundamental law: Conservatives think liberals are stupid. Liberals think conservatives are evil,” Krauthammer wrote in 2002.
Similarly, in response to Kohn's article, Warner Todd Huston writes in the comments at Hot Air today:
You DO realize that there is a MAJOR admission in that op ed, right? She is essentially admitting that through most of her adult life she thought conservatives were evil… until, well into her late 30s, she finally MET SOME!
Sally Kohn lived in a liberal bubble for nearly all her life until 2 years ago she finally met some conservatives and discovered *gasp* they aren’t all like little Hitlers.
I'm glad that Kohn and Powers have granted those on the right are, as Kohn notes, "personable and kind and human. Just like me." But why did it take working among them to make the epoch-shattering discovery* that half the country are actual flesh-and-blood humans and not The Other?
The near-identical astonished descriptions of those us on the right from Kohn and Powers remind me of Jonah Goldberg's classic G-File from 2002 on "Conservatives in the Mist:"
[W]henever I read liberals reporting about the goings-on of conservatives I always get the nature-documentary vibe. A liberal reporter puts on his or her Dian Fossey hat in order to attempt to write another installment of Conservatives in the Mist. I've followed this particular brand of reporting for years, it's almost a fetish of mine. Most attempts fail. Of these lesser varieties, there's fear ("Troglodytes!"), mockery ("Irrelevant troglodytes!"), condescension ("I had to explain to them they're troglodytes."), bewilderment ("Why don't they understand they're troglodytes?"), astonishment (Dear God, they're not all troglodytes!"), and a few combinations of all the above.
But sometimes they even succeed, to a point. Thus, like the real Dian Fossey, they manage to saunter into the leafy thickets of conservatism, and are welcomed into a band of gorillas. They hold out the equivalent of a banana or maybe a fistful of grubs for long enough and eventually we come sniffing around. We're intrigued by the creature lavishing attention on us. And the reporter eventually begins to feel as though he has been accepted into the band. Eventually, we conservatives grow comfortable enough around them to return to our old patterns. We scratch and fight and do our gorilla things and the chronicler dutifully takes notes. The notes eventually make their way into an article for the New York Times or The New Yorker or Vanity Fair.
"Who knew?" the readers will say over their morning bagels and coffee in Southampton or Fire Island, "I had no idea conservatives were such intelligent creatures. Why they even have the capacity for emotion and even some rudimentary forms of kindness."
In 2002, far left Washington State Senator Patty Murray praised Osama bin Laden for “building schools, building roads, building infrastructure, building day-care facilities, building health-care facilities, and the people are extremely grateful. He’s made their lives better.” In contrast, MSNBC has no qualms about routinely declaring half the country racist. In late 2004 David Westin, the president of ABC News (aka, the House of Stephanopoulos) famously told Tina Brown (now editor of Newsweek successor, the Daily Beast) that -- forget reporting back from Afghanistan -- the legacy media need to send the equivalent of foreign correspondents to those strange, mysterious, alien Red States:
WESTIN: I think we don’t do that enough, and I’m not just talking religious communities. I’m talking all sorts of communities across the country. I think that… You understand this, Tina, living in New York or in Los Angeles, we have busy jobs. We go into the office every day. We tend to socialize with the same people, or the same types of people, and I think it’s terribly important for journalists to get out whether it’s overseas or domestically and try to understand.
Yes, we must “try to understand” that people to our right are “personable and kind and human” and “not all evil and stupid.”
What will it take for those spokespeople for an ideology that routinely tosses around buzzwords such as “tolerance” and “diversity” and “multiculturalism” to allow themselves to view their fellow countrymen in an equally beneficent light?
*I was going to insert a joking "cue 'Also Sprach Zarathustra' from 2001: A Space Odyssey riff" here, but the situation is exactly the reverse. The above incidents are repeated examples of Nietzsche's philosophical descendents -- whether they know it or not -- coming into contact with those who believe that God is Not Dead, and admitting, OK, they're not the Übermensch. But -- unexpectedly! -- they're still mensches after all.