Democrats’ Identity Crisis: Warren, Blumenthal, and the Culture of Deceit

Playing Pretend to Get Ahead

Sen. Elizabeth Warren's histrionics during yesterday's Senate Finance Committee hearing dug up her ties to the pharmaceutical industry, and that made me think of how many Democrats have followed that formula and have successfully lied to succeed.

Two of the most blatant examples of Democrats who have reinvented themselves with falsehoods are Sens. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut. Both invented identities that brought them prestige, sympathy, and opportunity. Neither was content with their own records: They needed the shine and effort of someone else's struggle to elevate their careers.

Warren leaned on family lore that had no foundation in reality. She checked the box as a Native American on official documents, including her 1986 Texas Bar registration card. Harvard Law, an Ivy League school with prestige and history, presented her as a "woman of color." Warren let it stand for years until the evidence caught up with her — those high cheekbones aren't definitive, you know. She waited until her career was firmly entrenched on the back of an identity that wasn't hers before apologizing to Cherokee leaders.

Sen. Blumenthal presents a twin case study to Warren. He gave speeches for years, lying about his Vietnam service. In 2008, he said, "We have learned something important since the days that I served in Vietnam."

There was a problem, though. Blumenthal never set foot in Vietnam; he received five deferments before joining the Marine Reserves in Washington. Like Warren, he bitterly clung to a self-inflating myth that padded his résumé until reporters forced his hand, making him apologize.

When the symptom looks the same, it reveals the disease. When so many democrats start pretending to be something they're not, it plainly illustrates the Democratic Party's addiction to deceit.

A Party Built on Pretending

Identity politics is the cat's meow in the Democratic Party, dividing people into groups, elevating some, diminishing others, and those politicians who appropriate victimhood are rewarded.

When looking at that environment, it makes perfect sense why Warren and Blumenthal did what they did for as long as they did. Being White New Englanders with ordinary backgrounds wasn't going to cut it; they needed the bonus points their fictional stories provided.

It's because of these boneheads' bad character that the American ideal gets corrupted. Our nation has always rewarded honesty and grit. When the Democrats elevate liars posing as something they're not — a Native American and Vietnam vet — they eviscerate trust in institutions that depend on truth: law, academia, and public service.

The Pattern Is Bigger Than Two

Warren and Blumenthal aren't alone in their actions; they've followed the example of trailblazing Democrats who played fast and loose with the truth. They call it résumé inflation, con artistry, but will never admit what it truly is: lying. 

This Democratic club boasts a long roster.

• Joe Biden: The king of embellishment. He plagiarized in law school, plagiarized on the campaign trail, and keeps telling tall tales about being arrested in South Africa or standing at Ground Zero the day after 9/11. Even friendly media had to slap him with a “Bottomless Pinocchio.” The man doesn’t just misremember—he manufactures.
• Bob Menendez: Federal agents didn’t need a microscope to find his corruption; they needed a wheelbarrow. Gold bars in closets. Cash in envelopes. Convicted in 2024, sentenced to 11 years. A U.S. senator living like a mobster.
• Hillary Clinton: Claimed she landed in Bosnia under sniper fire. Turns out, it was more like a photo-op with schoolkids. She lied to look tough, got caught on camera, and shrugged it off like it was nothing. Classic Clinton.
• Adam Schiff: The man who spent years promising “evidence” of Trump-Russia collusion that never existed. He milked the cameras, pushed the lie, and when it all collapsed, he had no receipts. In 2023, the House censured him, long after the damage was done.
• Ilhan Omar: Minnesota nailed her for filing joint tax returns with a man she wasn’t legally married to. Funny how the rules never seem to apply to her, but she’s always ready to preach about accountability.
• Jamaal Bowman: Pulled a fire alarm in the middle of a key vote, swore it was an accident, then pled guilty to setting off a false alarm. That’s not an oops. That’s a stunt. And voters eventually sent him packing.
• Andrew Cuomo: Sold himself as the pandemic hero while his administration was cooking the books. Undercounted nursing home deaths by half. Meanwhile, he cashed in on a book deal and picked up an Emmy. Dead bodies offstage, applause on cue.

This short list isn't the benchwarmers, but senators, governors, presidents, and presidential candidates. Warren and Blumenthal are the supporting cast for the larger production filled with different lies, but they suffer from the same disease.

Why It Matters

There is some validity to the claim that "It's the same for both parties" or that "All politicians exaggerate." But that argument is lazy; there's a difference between rhetorical spin and outright fabricating one's identity.

Warren presented herself as a Cherokee to advance up the academic ladder. Blumenthal wrapped himself in the mantle of a Vietnam veteran to establish his credibility. The choices they made weren't simple slips of the tongue; they reshaped their careers with strategic lies.

When we see people like Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ilhan Omar rise in the Democratic Party, it's hard not to know that they're following the same, proven script written by Biden, Clinton, and the rest.

In their world, pretending brings success and honesty is a handicap. Integrity is for suckers when lying about your bloodline or service wins tenure or a Senate seat.

Related: Shutdowns Are Washington’s Favorite Scam — and the Media Always Blames Republicans

The Contrast

Every single time a Republican slips, stumbles, or exaggerates, they're endlessly blasted by a legacy media that keeps the spotlight on them, holding that light away from Democrats.

In contrast, Democrats like Warren and Blumenthal skate by with nothing but polite apologies and soft coverage. It demonstrates, again, the double standard.

It's a moral failing when President Donald Trump exaggerates the crowd size. Yet when Democrats build entire careers on an encyclopedia of lies, it's spun as "misspeaking" or "misremembering."

The overarching truth of this disease is a straightforward fact: Democrats rely on deceit because there's no chance their agenda passes on merit. It's Democrats like Warren and Blumenthal who need inflated résumés, fake identities, and distorted numbers.

We aren't seeing leadership; we are witnessing theater.

Final Thoughts

Elizabeth Warren and Richard Blumenthal should not be remembered as anomalies. They're the clearest expression of a political party that rewards deceit. Their careers are built on the ability of Democrats to feed off identity politics, how they manipulate sympathy, and their ability to protect their own from any accountability.

Looking beyond Liz and Dick, the pattern that stretches from Biden to Cuomo fills the roster with different names, yet the same rot remains.

As Americans, we deserve leaders who tell the truth, not actors preparing and rehearsing new roles. Until Democrats have a reckoning about their addiction to deceit, the party will keep producing Warrens and Blumenthals.

All the while, trust in public life keeps eroding.

Join the Fight With Us

At PJ Media, we don’t play pretend. We expose it. If you value clear-eyed truth and refuse to accept the lies dressed up as leadership, join our community of readers who want accountability back in American politics. Subscribe here and stand with us in calling out the rot before it spreads further.