I had plans for another take on progressive Christianity this week, but then I stumbled on a handful of musical moments that I couldn’t help but share with you. Many times these columns can leave us sad, angry, or just shaking our heads, but I think we could all use a laugh and an opportunity to ridicule some of these people.
This will be a somewhat shorter column, but I think you’ll still appreciate the craziness. For starters, some songs shouldn’t belong anywhere near a church. One of those songs is John Lennon’s stupid anthem to atheism and communism, “Imagine.”
On this week’s episode of “Faith All Over the Place,” my friend and colleague Stephen Kruiser and I briefly talked about how Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood sang “Imagine” at Jimmy Carter’s funeral. That’s bad enough, but what if you heard that song at a church service?
Christian Pro-tip. Never attend a church that sings John Lennon's excretable song 'Imagine' during the service. pic.twitter.com/qs3Usq2pv5
— Protestia (@Protestia) March 27, 2025
All I can ask is, “WHY?” My friend and boss, PJ Media’s Managing Editor Paula Bolyard, replied:
Heck, I walk out when I hear "Imagine" at a secular event.
— Paula Bolyard (@pbolyard) March 27, 2025
Then again, I’m not sure I want to hear these people sing anything, much less an atheistic anthem, in church.
Related: Faith All Over the Place, Episode 9: Rough Week for Pope Francis Haters
What if you came to church one Sunday and stood up to sing these lyrics?
We are a gentle, angry people, and we are singing, singing for our lives
We are gay and straight together, and we are singing, singing for our lives
I’m not sure where Ichabod Community Church is, but the congregation there “sang” it recently. I put “sang” in quotation marks because these people sound so bad.
Cursed church has cursed hymns, made all the worse by the fact that no one can sing.
— Protestia (@Protestia) March 27, 2025
🎶"We are a gentle, angry people.
and we are singing, singing for our lives
We are gay and straight together
and we are singing, singing for our lives"🎶 pic.twitter.com/gjyANRBBMv
I can’t make out the melody because of the horrid singing, but I can hear the heresy loud and clear.
Related: 'Glitter Blessings' and Women Pastors Who Say 'Queer' a Lot
This one might not quite fit the definition of progressive Christianity, but for those of you who had rapping German Catholic priests on your bingo card, today’s your lucky day! Maybe it’s one thing to have somebody rapping at your church, but to have the priest doing it in full regalia is a whole ‘nother matter. Still, this guy can spuck ein paar Reime aus.
The German Catholic Church lost 321,611 members last year pic.twitter.com/fkaakj6Odj
— Catholic Arena (@CatholicArena) March 27, 2025
In case you’re not up on your German rap, I have the English translation below. Sorry, Scroll didn’t do the line breaks:
And they don't even want to put on a pious front. On the surface, some people just look down their noses. But everyone here in the church is actually quite cheerful. Many are fully committed, not just here to chill. Instead of bling, some live their faith more quietly. But today things are getting loud, and this beat proclaims to everyone: God changes lives, and that should resound loudly.
All of us gathered here today can understand ourselves as a child loved by God. Translated into rapper language, just check it out. The one up in heaven is in a really good mood for you.
That’s… something.
Finally, I’ll leave you with this blasphemy:
There's worship leaders, and then there are "worship leaders" pic.twitter.com/xTijpnLyH2
— Protestia (@Protestia) March 8, 2025
I’m speechless. You probably are, too. Oh well, that’s it for this week; see you next time!
Here at PJ Media, we will always stand up for the truth about Christianity. You can help us in that mission by becoming a PJ Media VIP member.
VIP membership is an investment in our mission, but you get great benefits as well. And it's a great deal when you take advantage of our 60% off sale. Click here to sign up, and your discount will apply at checkout.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member