Get PJ Media on your Apple

The PJ Tatler

Bryan Preston


June 24, 2013 - 7:37 am

The Senate’s members haven’t even read the original 1000-page Rubio-Schumer immigration bill, let alone the 1200-page Corker-Hoeven amendment. But they’re set to pass it today before even finding out what’s in it. The immigration bill is the Son of ObamaCare, and will have an even more transformative effect than its predecessor has already had. ObamaCare fundamentally changed the citizens’ relationship to our government, making us less citizen than subject. The immigration bill waters down the rule of law, while bringing wages down by flooding a weak economy with cheap labor.

Passing the Senate’s bill will hand a scandal-plagued president who is impotent in the eyes of the world a major victory here at home. His party can be expected to focus thug tactics on the House to try to force it to pass the bill. In fact, if the House passes any bill at all it will be a victory for Obama. Whatever the House passes, it will go into the conference process and come out, thanks to Democrat bully tactics and rank cowardice among senators like Rubio, Graham, McCain and Flake, as a package of gifts for Democrats.

Republicans who pass the bill are casting votes to lose 2014 in advance and possibly hand the Democrats majorities for a generation. They believe that not passing any bill kills GOP chances to win over more of the growing Hispanic vote. But voting for this bill will fracture the party base going into next year’s mid-terms, dampen enthusiasm and weaken the party overall. There is no evidence at all that passing the bill will help the GOP attract enough Hispanic voters to replace the base voters that it is guaranteed to lose. None. But passing immigration reform as it stands violates Republicans’ fundamental sense of right and wrong, law and order and basic fairness. It’s an excellent way for the Democrats to kill their political opposition.

Ironically, Republicans who favor passing immigration reform believe that they must pass it or the party dies. They base that both on demographic trends accelerated after the last immigration amnesty, from which they have learned absolutely nothing, and on the results of the 2012 election.

But the Republicans did not lose 2012 because they lost the Hispanic vote. They lost because the Democrats ran a campaign on marginal issues designed to attract low-information voters, Republicans nominated a weak candidate who never truly inspired the base, and because the Obama administration actively suppressed the Tea Party, according to a new academic study. According to the study the Tea Party handed Republicans 3 to 6 million votes and thus victory in 2010, and was poised to attract as many as 8 million votes — victory — in 2012. But the IRS stepped in and blocked for the Democrats.

President Obama’s margin of victory in some of the key swing states was fairly small: a mere 75,000 votes separated the two contenders in Florida, for example. That is less than 25% of our estimate of what the Tea Party’s impact in Florida was in 2010. Looking forward to 2012 in 2010 undermining the Tea Party’s efforts there must have seemed quite appealing indeed.

Unfortunately for Republicans, the IRS slowed Tea Party growth before the 2012 election. In March 2010, the IRS decided to single Tea Party groups out for special treatment when applying for tax-exempt status by flagging organizations with names containing “Tea Party,” “patriot,” or “9/12.” For the next two years, the IRS approved the applications of only four such groups, delaying all others while subjecting the applicants to highly intrusive, intimidating requests for information regarding their activities, membership, contacts, Facebook posts, and private thoughts.

As a consequence, the founders, members, and donors of new Tea Party groups found themselves incapable of exercising their constitutional rights, and the Tea Party’s impact was muted in the 2012 election cycle. As Toby Marie Walker, who runs the Waco Tea Party, which filed for tax-exempt status in 2010 but didn’t receive approval until two months ago, recounted recently: “Our donors dried up. It was intimidating and time-consuming.” The Richmond Tea Party went through a similar ordeal, and was only granted tax-exempt status in December, right after the election–three years after its initial request. Its chairman explained the consequences: the episode cost the Richmond Tea Party $17,000 in legal fees and swallowed time the all-volunteer network would have devoted to voter turnout, outreach in black and Latino neighborhoods and other events to highlight the constitution and “the concept of liberty.”

Too many Republicans have learned the wrong lessons from 2012. The largest lesson they’re failing to learn is that the Democratic Party under Obama is willing to do anything to win, including massive and widespread cheating. The immigration bill must be blocked at least until we have clear answers in the IRS scandal. Did the White House order it, encourage it, or condone it at any level? Was the White House counsel’s office involved in any way? Was the Obama campaign involved? Why did the IRS’ top officers meet at the White House hundreds of times while the targeting was ongoing? What role did the IRS workers union play? What role did Obama’s public rhetoric play in the IRS’ decision to target his opponents?

Shouldn’t we have answers to these questions and many more before handing Obama a huge victory?

Bryan Preston has been a leading conservative blogger and opinionator since founding his first blog in 2001. Bryan is a military veteran, worked for NASA, was a founding blogger and producer at Hot Air, was producer of the Laura Ingraham Show and, most recently before joining PJM, was Communications Director of the Republican Party of Texas.

Comments are closed.

All Comments   (8)
All Comments   (8)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
A patently, bare-faced lie:(31 May 2012) Illegal aliens cost legal residents $113 billion per year, including $84 billion at state and local levels. (Source: 25 May 2012 Liberty News Network)
Is US economy in full contraction???Read On.
The biggest question going forward is how consumers react to the expiration of a Social Security tax cut. Congress and the White House allowed the temporary tax cut to expire in January, but reached a deal to keep income taxes from rising on most Americans.
The tax increase will lower take home pay this year by about 2 percent. That means a household earning $50,000 a year will have about $1,000 less to spend. A household with two high-paid workers will have up to $4,500 less.
Economists say a growth pace in excess of 3 percent would be needed over a sustained period to significantly lower high unemployment. The economy has struggled to hold above a 2 percent growth pace.
For the whole of 2012 the economy grew 2.2 percent.
Government spending tumbled at a 6.6 percent rate, as defense outlays plunged at a 22.2 percent pace, wiping out the previous quarter's gains. Government subtracted 1.33 percentage points form growth. The decline in defense spending was the largest since 1972.
Export weakness also weighed on growth. Exports have been hampered by a recession in Europe, a cooling Chinese economy and storm and strike-related port disruptions. Overall trade cut a quarter of a percentage point from GDP growth. Exports fell for the first time since the first quarter of 2009.
Now there's this:
Dirty Little Secret...guess what? The "revamped, re-visited, re-massaged," Immigration Bill (de facto amnesty) has one sure thing and only one: AMNESTY NOW!
1) E-verify with penalties of $75,000 dollars and/or jail time of 10 years, for employers, is "discretionary" for otherwords never goin' to happen.
2) Criminal background checks: DUI's, and two years search, are "discretionary!" Once again, left up to DHS to decide or not to enforce it....never goin' to happen!
3) Border Security=200,000 "boots on the ground," heightened surveillance equiment and techniques, entry/exit tracking system, etc. etc. etc. "discretionary!" And again, this tidbit of legislation is left up to DHS to decide to implement or not. Since Napolitano, as Governor of Arizona, defied Sheriff Arpaio's enforcement of illegal alien trafficking overrunning Tucson and Phoenix, what's to guarantee BORDER SECURITY is priority numero uno on her list as Secretary of DHS????HUH? HUH?Not goin' to happen.
ALL, EVERY ONE of these amendments are "discretionary!" DHS decides to implement or not. AMNESTY NOW is urgently being steamrolled through the Senate and speedily goin' before the House for a "midnight special!" Wake-up America! Oppose this flim-flammery, smoke-and-mirrrors, kabuki theatre...these are 50 million illegal alien CRIMINAL border jumpers. They're not even "guest workers! " They're illegal, illiterate,uneducated, "campesinos!"
Now, with riots happening in all of Brazil...a USA-Brazilan invasion is in the offing. Pray. Amen. We The Elite People of culture of corruption in ALL of Washington DC have forsaken their Oath of Office. They are out for"1)greed. 2)power (increased voter registrations) and 3)out-and-out corruption on a scale never, ever seen in national politics. Chicago-style thuggery nationalized. Join a Tea Party.
Add "11 million" (wink,wink) newly minted American citizens to this powder keg and what do you get???A really big Watts-type riot. US economy will definitely "contract!"
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Politics is upscale criminality, and it sometimes runs amok. We spend a great deal of time reading and writing about the decay of cities like Detroit, Chicago, and Los Angeles, when we have the most decadent city in the history of history right there in good ol' Washington D. C.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Some Republicans like the Gangsters of 8 need to learn that when the car is about to driver over the cliff, slamming the brakes is indeed progress!

Gridlock is not a bad word.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
To me this is very simple: if the Republicans pass this bill I'm going to stop voting for them. As an adult I recognize that it's often necessary to vote for the lesser evil but with the bill the Republicans won't be able to claim even that much anymore. No, they will become the equally-evil-but-more-stupid party.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
there have been years when i have simply voted against any incumbent. there have been other years when i have taken the approach that the difference between bad and worse is much more significant than the difference between good and better.

currently, i have no idea what to do. staying home in disgust is not the answer. hard not to, though.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
I've made up my mind that I'm going to do what I can to make a third party viable. It will take decades, probably, but all the more reason to get started as soon as possible. But I simply cannot keep rewarding Republicans for acting like Democrats.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
i looked into possibilities, too. it seems to me that the most possible way to viability is a tea party takeover of the republicans. it has to do with ballot access. next would be libertarian party. parties used to come and go. then the repubs and dems started passing finance laws and ballot access laws. plus most of the current politicos are loyal first to party last to electorate.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
I agree. Maybe i ought to Go Galt and just stop contributing to the system too. Welfare seems to be pretty profitable these days and, well, anything that leeches off the leech I consider is a good thing.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
View All