Ed Driscoll

By Ed Driscoll

Bio

Get Updates From Ed Driscoll

Forget “Forward, into the Past.” This is forward into oblivion. But first, let’s flashback to the San Francisco Chronicle, July 6, 2008, on “Throwing less-is-more birthday parties:”

Forget the twisty straws, Tootsie rolls and Dora the Explorer plates with matching cups, hats and tablecloth. There are signs that more parents would like to.

Anxious about the economy, global warming and our national image as people who would rent a limo for a kid’s party while a polar bear’s ice floe melts, many are toning down the trappings of that classic annual ritual, the blowout birthday party. They are saying no to plastic toys and water bottles, paper plates, gift wrap and new toys. There is even a modest backlash against the goody bag, the sack of candy and plastic knickknacks usually thrust into each sticky hand at the end of parties.

Advertisement

* * *

“There is nothing more bacchanalian than a kid’s birthday party,” said Sarah Lane, a founder of Washington state’s Progressive Kid, which has a Web site with suggestions on how to raise kids with good values. “You should see what gets thrown away. It’s disgusting.”

This week’s San Francisco Examiner notes that the city’s residents are now throwing away those disgusting birthday parties entirely — “San Francisco becoming a child-free zone as youth population declines:”

Despite efforts to stem the tide of family flight, the population of children in San Francisco continues to ebb.

Families that remain in The City are bucking the trend that has plagued San Francisco for years as the number of children — defined as people up to 17 years old — has dropped from 181,532 in 1960 to 107,524 today, according to the latest U.S. Census Bureau figures. The 2000 census counted 112,802 youths.

The decrease is disappointing news for city officials, who have attempted to counter the family-flight trend by creating more affordable housing, improving schools and cutting costs, such as a college savings account for kindergarten enrollees.

“It’s definitely not a hopeful sign that we have 5,000 less kids,” said N’Tanya Lee, the executive director of San Francisco-based advocacy group Coleman Advocates for Children and Youth, which lobbies City Hall on budget and housing issues.

Of course, as the Examiner notes, this isn’t exactly a new trend; even AP was noting that “San Francisco has the smallest share of small-fry of any major U.S. city,” back in 2005. And way back in 2000, Harry Stein wrote in, How I Accidentally Joined the Vast Right-Wing Conspiracy (and Found Inner Peace), “Someone’s going on about how fantastic San Francisco is, and it suddenly hits you that’s one place on earth you never want to live.”

All of which makes you wonder: when the next San Francisco far left loony rails on against the dangers of Happy Meals, Junior ROTC, family-friendly SUVs or heck, circumcision, what’s the point of passing these laws when there are fewer and fewer kids left in the city?

(Incidentally, who’s number two, the Avis of the Zero Population Growth set? Why, that would be those fellow hipsters in Seattle.)

Meanwhile, another big blue town continues to have far worse population decline: Detroit’s population dropped 25 percent in the last decade; leading to this hyperbolic Time magazine headline: “Vanishing City: The Story Behind Detroit’s Shocking Population Decline.”

What’s so shocking about it? The model for socialism has always been, if you build it, they will leave. At the Belmont Club this week, Richard Fernandez noted that “Detroit is only one of several cities which have seen heavy population losses.  New Orleans has lost nearly 30% of its population, followed by Detroit itself, and Cleveland, Cincinnati and Pittsburgh.”

Or as Mark Steyn wrote in 2005, “what’s the point of creating a secular utopia if it’s only for one generation?”

PJ Media appreciates your comments that abide by the following guidelines:

1. Avoid profanities or foul language unless it is contained in a necessary quote or is relevant to the comment.

2. Stay on topic.

3. Disagree, but avoid ad hominem attacks.

4. Threats are treated seriously and reported to law enforcement.

5. Spam and advertising are not permitted in the comments area.

These guidelines are very general and cannot cover every possible situation. Please don't assume that PJ Media management agrees with or otherwise endorses any particular comment. We reserve the right to filter or delete comments or to deny posting privileges entirely at our discretion. Please note that comments are reviewed by the editorial staff and may not be posted immediately. If you feel your comment was filtered inappropriately, please email us at story@pjmedia.com.

3 Comments, 3 Threads, 1 Trackbacks

  1. 1. whiskey

    It is not socialism that killed Detroit or New Orleans (I lived in the latter for three years). It is instead the population. Stuttgart, and other Mittelstand factory towns in Germany have plenty of socialism, believe me. But their population throws off enough wealth to support it and family creation. True German birth rates are declining, the more so for natives not Turkish emigres, but Germans still have kids and Germany’s population is declining from a high-water mark of the 1960′s which was likely unsustainable.

    Rather, it is the unfortunate habit Black majority populations have of being unable to crack down on crime by fellow Blacks. New Orleans was and is likely the least socialist city in America, but is one of the most crime-ridden. Crime and the cost of it is the primary reason Houston not New Orleans became the center of the Gulf Oil business. Having moved from a suburban place in SoCal to New Orleans, it was shocking how widespread, constant, and prosperity-eroding crime really was and is in that city. Crime dictates every move of your life. Mayor Morial’s initiative to develop New Orleans Airport as a fresh flower delivery point, and gentrification, all came to nothing before Katrina due to crime. Jury nullification verdicts by all-Black Juries regarding all-Black criminals, victims, and cops meant out-of-control crime.

    New Orleans should have been the Vegas of the South, and a regional rival to Vegas. But crime killed that city.

  2. 2. Valjean

    I didn’t read the Examiner piece, but they might have added that of those 107,524 children, about 107,000 are probably first-generation Asian or Hispanic. I lived around the city for about a quarter century and don’t think I *ever* saw an identifiable local caucasian child.

    I think the heavy immigrant influx is a very good thing in the long-term (as it almost always has been), but it certainly introduces some self-imposed public service challenges in the short. And all those comical nanny-ish bans instituted by the clueless city council will just be ignored by the good parents in the Mission and Marina districts: anyone inquire about the birthday parties of first Chinese sons?

  3. 3. Aarradin

    If only they could legalize Gay Marriage they’d be fine.

One Trackback to “In Search of the Missing Frisco Families”