Kim wakes before dawn to get ready for work. The apartment is still and dim, the kind of silence that hums. In the bathroom mirror, she studies her reflection: beard trimmed neat, skin powdered smooth, a trace of pink across her cheeks. It takes longer than most people would guess to look authentically herself.
By the time she’s behind the counter at the coffee shop, the sky outside is rinsed gray. The espresso machine hisses like a small dragon. Kim smiles at the regulars, the man with the newspaper, the nurse just off night shift, the quiet woman with her oat-milk cappuccino, but the smiles don’t seem to land. They see her, but not really.
During a lull, she props her phone against a jar of biscotti and records a TikTok about self-expression and courage. The ring light glows against the espresso machine’s chrome, scattering her face into a dozen tiny reflections. When she replays the clip, her voice sounds careful, as if she’s imitating sincerity. Still, she posts it. The algorithm likes consistency.
Then a man steps up to the counter, distracted, phone at his ear.
“Name for the order?” she asks.
“Elon,” he says.
The word hits like a slap. She thinks he’s mocking her, and something inside her cracks, the fragile line between self and show. The outburst costs her the job. An hour later, she’s sitting on the curb with her apron and phone charger in a cardboard box, scrolling for validation that doesn’t come.
In the coffee shop window, her reflection stares back, contour, glitter, tear tracks. She can’t tell whether she’s looking at herself or at the performance she’s built to survive.
When the Self Becomes a Stage
Kim’s story isn’t unusual. It’s what happens when the self becomes a stage and life becomes an audition.
This is the promise of performative individualism: that if you curate yourself carefully enough, if you can make others see you, then you will finally be you. It sounds empowering. But in practice, it’s a treadmill that never stops. Every expression must be justified, every opinion pre-approved, every moment of sincerity turned outward for validation. You no longer live a self; you perform one.
The culture tells Kim that identity is a product of choice: that meaning can be manufactured like content. But choice without truth is weightless. Without something real outside the self, like a family, a faith, a standard of beauty or goodness not invented by the performer, the performance collapses inward. The result is what we see everywhere now: brittle people who seem perpetually on display, terrified of being unseen, yet equally terrified of being known.
The Collapse of Common Meaning
It would be easy to mock Kim’s confusion, but she didn’t invent it. She’s only living out what the culture has taught her: that self-creation is the highest virtue and that belonging is weakness.
The roots of this go deep. For centuries, the Western world has preached a gospel of liberation: liberation from kings, from priests, from custom, from constraint. Most of it was noble. It gave rise to science, enterprise, and the dignity of conscience. It built the world we live in today, filled with opportunity and possibility. But every freedom carries its shadow.
It worked while we still lived within the scaffolding of common meaning, the shared national stories, faith, family, strong communities, and a belief in fixed moral anchors like truth, beauty, and goodness. Those structures kept individuality from collapsing into narcissism; they gave it shape. But now those foundations are crumbling, replaced by a new creed of radical self-definition. Meaning is privatized. Reality is whatever you can convince others to affirm. The collective imagination, once filled with faith, poems, and shared myths, has been replaced by feeds and slogans.
In such a world, every person must become their own storyteller, priest, and god. It sounds liberating, but it is exhausting. The result is the modern self: sovereign, anxious, and perpetually online, a soul trapped in mirrors, trying to believe its own reflection.
The Loneliness of the Mirror
A culture built on self-invention cannot sustain real community. When every person is a universe of one, there is no shared sky. The social fabric unravels quietly at first. Friendships grow thinner, marriages shorter, families smaller, trust rarer. Each person becomes both performer and audience, seeking validation from strangers while fearing true intimacy.
Loneliness becomes the national mood. It’s not the old loneliness of isolation, but the new kind born of constant exposure, being seen by everyone and known by no one. The more we broadcast ourselves, the less real we feel. We trade presence for visibility, conversation for comment threads, and love for affirmation.
Without the grounding of something greater than the self, every disagreement feels like an attack on one’s very being. Political tribes replace faith and family, and identity becomes a battle flag. Outrage becomes communion. The bonds that once joined us — shared labor, worship, neighborly obligation — are replaced by the thin glue of performance: curated virtue, stylized empathy, performative rage.
Underneath it all is despair. People sense that something vital has gone missing, though they can’t name it. The world has become efficient, comfortable, and sterile. But the soul cannot breathe in sterile air, not for long.
Breaking the Glass
Somewhere in the city, Kim walks home through the late afternoon heat. Her makeup has smudged; her phone battery is dead. She stops at a bus shelter, sits down, and watches a child drop an ice-cream cone, wailing as it melts into the pavement. For once, Kim doesn’t reach for her phone. She just watches the mess, sugar and dirt, ants finding their way to it, the small tragedy swallowed by life’s constant motion.
It’s the first real thing she’s seen all day.
That’s how re-enchantment begins: with confrontation, not comfort. The glass cracks when reality breaks through the performance. For those trapped inside, the light hurts. But someone has to let it in.
If we want to free people like Kim, we have to live the opposite of the performance. Speak plainly. Refuse the euphemisms that protect delusion. Tell the truth even when it makes the air tense. Use real names, true pronouns, accurate words. The first step in breaking a spell is naming things as they are.
Then embody what’s been lost. Don’t argue for truth as an abstraction; live it. Logic and reason rarely save a soul from illusion, but presence, steadiness, and love can. A person lost in mirrors won’t believe in the world again because you explained it; they’ll believe because they felt it. Cook a meal. Invite the lonely. Offer belonging that doesn’t depend on applause. Don't feed their beast. Insist on reality.
Model reverence. The disenchanted world has forgotten how to bow its head, not to power, but to something greater than power. Let those around you see that humility isn’t weakness but peace. When they meet someone who doesn’t need to perform, they’ll sense the difference and hunger for it.
Rebuild the small circles. Culture changes when households change, when families pray together, neighbors know each other, churches teach courage instead of compliance. Each act of honest community is a crack in the mirror.
Saving the self from illusion with logic and reason rarely works. Love does what argument cannot. The spell of performance breaks when reality proves kinder, truer, and more beautiful than the lie.
We cannot drag people out of their reflections, but we can open the door to the living world and let them see that it still exists, unfiltered, uncurated, holy in its dirt and danger.
The world is still full of wonder. What it needs are witnesses brave enough to stop pretending and point to what is real.
Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy PJ Media's conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth. Join PJ Media VIP and use the promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership!
Join the conversation as a VIP Member