Ed Driscoll

Is Harrisburg, Pennsylvania's Nightmare America's Future?

James Carville has been endlessly quoted as saying that “Pennsylvania is Philadelphia and Pittsburgh with Alabama in between.” Though perhaps we should add more than a little touch of Michigan into that mix as well. This new video from Reason.TV makes Harrisburg, the state’s capital, sound very much like Detroit:


The city of Harrisburg is Ground Zero for America’s municipal debt crisis.

Pennsylvania’s capital city has liabilities estimated at $610 million, which is nearly ten times its annual budget. The city is so deep in the red that last year it attempted to file for bankruptcy. Reckless spending did more than ruin Harrisburg’s balance sheet; it crowded out private industry and distracted from the city’s core functions. Today, Harrisburg is a dangerous, poverty-stricken city, with failing schools and a shrinking population.

Harrisburg’s fiscal nightmare may be a harbinger of things to come for American cities. In the mid-90s, local governments embarked on a spending binge, bringing total municipal debt in the United States to more than $2.8 trillion. Along with Harrisburg, Jefferson County, Alabama, Vallejo, California, and Central Falls, Rhode Island have filed for bankruptcy in the past few years. Several more cities are on the brink of default, largely thanks to taxpayer-financed stadiums, museums, housing, commercial complexes, other misconceived economic development projects, and runaway public sector salaries, pensions, and benefit packages.

Is your hometown the next Harrisburg?

Shot, edited, written, and produced by Jim Epstein, who also narrates.


It certainly makes for a bracing double-feature alongside Steven Crowder’s epic late 2009 video on Detroit’s woes for PJTV:

Join the conversation as a VIP Member