Barack Obama’s personal political army, Organizing for Action, sent out the following email this evening.
Friend –
I was brought to this country from Mexico when I was 2 years old.
I am an undocumented immigrant — and I am living proof that our immigration system is broken.
For the first 17 years of my life, I slept on a couch. My mom worked three jobs to support our family.
I worked hard, too. I did my homework, participated in class, and earned the opportunity go to college. But after I enrolled, state law changed and many undocumented immigrants were forced to drop out. Suddenly they could no longer afford the education they were eager to work for.
We started organizing. We’d go up to people on campus, and ask them if they’d heard about the DREAM Act, which would allow hard-working immigrants who grew up in the U.S. to earn a path to citizenship. For those who opposed it, we’d tell them what happened to us.
It was amazing: Just telling our stories would change people’s minds.
This is exactly how we’re going to persuade people across the country to get behind President Obama’s plan for comprehensive immigration reform.
Everyone has a story — I’m sure you do, too. As the President said last week, “Unless you’re one of the first Americans, a Native American, you came from someplace else. Somebody brought you.”
At this critical moment, will you share your immigration story? Organizing for Action will use these stories to move the conversation forward.
Now, almost six years later, I’ve completed law school and was fortunate to receive deferred action. I consider myself an American, and I want to play by the same rules as everyone else. But, as it stands, I can never become a citizen. I can’t adjust my status. For most of my life, I could have been arrested, detained, and deported.
I’m not alone. Millions of undocumented immigrants like me live in fear of being deported permanently to a country we may have never even visited. Our entire lives could be erased.
You might not live under the same shadow. But the best thing about this country is that we are more alike than we are different. We all have a story of a mother, or grandfather, or great-great grandparent who came here to find opportunity or safety.
Through this grassroots movement, we can raise our voices, tell our stories, and make sure Congress and all Americans better understand the ties that bind us. Our stories can drive our organizing. Share your own story today, and help Organizing for Action get the word out on why this matters:
http://my.barackobama.com/Share-Your-Immigration-Story
The majority of Americans agree we need to fix our badly broken system, and we saw major progress last week. But it’s on us to keep up the momentum and make sure it gets done.
Thanks for speaking up.
Jose
Jose Magana
My story is that my family and I abide by the law. My wife is a legal immigrant to this country. We have no standing at all with this administration. We’re suckers for respecting the laws of this country.
Instead, the president whose oath requires him to faithfully execute all of our nation’s laws is using the word of someone whose case is not representative of most illegal aliens, to push for amnesty for millions. That’s what this is.






Dear kid–I would be more sympathetic, if my society had not decided that I will also be a permanent pariah. And I’ve done more for the nation than you.
Having said that, welcome. You are in fact an American. You are in fact considered more of an American than I am, because I am a triple outcast, if not quadruple. So welcome. Be a good custodian to something you did not create, and had no birthrights to.
The first act of custodianship should be to thank your parents for their sacrifice, and agree that they do not get to have rules waived. My proposal is 20 years until citizenship for them. Paying full taxes along the way, no public assistance, no vote, no gun rights, ever (perhaps negotiable). Of course, you won’t agree to that. Meanwhile, I’m sure you will demand full enforcement of the laws do you like. Typical.
Welcome. It’s your nation now, not mine. Try to not make it Mexico.
Incidentally, for the record–the immigration system isn’t “broke”, your parents just didn’t like the results.
It’s like the 49ers saying the rules are broke because they didn’t get what they wanted. The immigration system admits the numbers each year we decide to admit. It is the border enforcement system that does not work. Hence your dilemma.
But I am not a trendy ethnicity, so that opinion doesn’t count. Enjoy your new country, and your new domininance, kid. “Earn this”.
(heh)
Never once did you thank me for following all the rules and laws all my life and working hard and paying taxes to support the system that has given you preference while it denied my children because they aren’t Mexican. My parents followed all the rules and laws all my life, etc., and theirs…you’re a rich lawyer now and get the point, Counsel. You and Obama both received affirmative action. Don’t agree? Challenge Dr. Hanson to a debate in the Central Valley. Why don’t you go back to Mexico as another Juarez or community organizer and bring justice to its oppressed so they won’t have to flee that backward and superstitious country.
I am married to a legal immigrant. His family came over on his dad’s work visa. He applied for citizenship and waited and waited and waited. He paid fees and studied for the citizenship test. After a few years on green card he became naturalized. That is how you do it if you want to be a citizen. America doesn’t owe you anything.
I have often joked with my wife. Why did I pay for the interviews in Frankfurt? The medical tests, all to get her greencard. I could have moved her to the U.S. and had our son (anchor baby) and saved myself several thousand dollars. Germans and their following the rules. My wife is a greencard holder and she will scream to the rooftops illegals need to move along. I try to explain to her that the democrats want more votes and the republicans are too scared of being labeled racist so nothing will happen. The bottom line is F!@#$%& all politicians on immigration. They are either hunting for votes or securing them.
Write an open letter to your parents asking why they and millions of others like them put you in harm’s way and when they’ll stop doing it. It is a form of child abuse they’re trying to put on a cold and cruel U.S.
Not buying what you’re selling.
Should have just been Obama asking readers to consider his illegal friend Jose who like O’s aunts and uncles…
Then signed -bo
Dear Jose,
I realize you had no choice in being brought here as a child, but now that you’re an adult, the simple solution to your terrible dilemma is to return to your homeland, and make it everything you wish America could be. Please continue to write and keep me posted on your progress.
Sincerely,
A. Taxpayer
I just have to say that most of you are being incredibly narrow minded. I’m a legal immigrant that followed all of the rules, and I’m now a citizen. But, I was one of the lucky ones. When the country I was born in went into turmoil, I was lucky to get out legally. My grandfather was important enough to persuade the government to give me a visa. Then I had enough money to get a lawyer to help me with my residency application. I was lucky. Many people aren’t so lucky. They don’t have influential grandfathers or money for lawyers. They want a better life for themselves, but because of circumstances beyond their control, they are stuck in a pit of poverty or war. The only way out is coming to America, the Promise Land. Since they can’t get here legally because of all the loops an hoops of a broken system, they take the couragous decision to come her illegally.
Most of you are angry that they broke the law and are getting rewarded for it, that they are not getting punished. One of you even compared it to someone robbing a bank. It’s not like that. It is more like someone refusing to give up their seat on a bus to a white person in the time of segregation. Rosa parks stood up against unfair laws, not to make a statement but because she was just fed up with it. It’s the same with most immigrants that decided to come here illegally. They aren’t making a statement, but are just fed up with laws and regulations that are unfair. They are taking destiny into their own hands.
Others of you are saying that undocumented immigrants are taking away jobs from real Americans. They aren’t. Most are doing jobs no real American would do. And the affirmative action, that is repayment of all the suffering white people have caused to all the other races. It’s balancing the scales. Whites, especially males, have always had the advantage in life. That’s a fact. Affirmative action is just lessening the size of that advantage.
Remember that in life we all come from different places and ways of living, don’t judge people you have never met. Just think about what I have said. Don’t be so narrow minded. Open your mind.
About proposed Immigration, Illegal Aliens, and Immigration reform.
Immigration reform is an oxymoron. Why? because Ronald Reagan granted amnesty to some supposedly 2 million illegal aliens already in the USA. This balloned to 4 million, a few years later…sure did backfire!
Here’s an education course on current Immigration statistics in Feb 2013.
https://egov.uscis.gov/cris/processingTimesDisplay.do;jsessionid=bacQTNNeHtxgl6AeqI1Yt
This shows 16 different catagories any Legal Alien MAY APPLY for LPR Status and future citizenship. May take upwards of 15 years.
There are four processing centers in the USA: Vermont, Nebraska, Texas and California. There are more than 50 USCIS Immigration field offices across the USA.
The most numerous case number is the I-129 and I-129F catagories. The next highest is the I-539. Total posssible case catagories = 51 This doesn’t include “adjustment of status” cases.
There are countless millions of applicants already LEGALLY awaiting patiently their adjudications for each of their petitions….millions, upon millions, upon millions.
Question!! Why should, illegal alien border jumpers (illegally in the USA) receive special treatment (move to the front of the lines) when there are already countless millions of Legal Aliens, filing proper documentation for LPR status and future citizenship either here in the USA or in their countries of origin????HUH???? Where’s the “Rule of Law?” Why even consider amnesty for illegal aliens? Why not amnesty for Legal Aliens already in line awaiting their adjudications????Pray. Amen!!!