Get PJ Media on your Apple

PJM Lifestyle

by
P. David Hornik

Bio

August 4, 2013 - 9:00 am

PJ-Light-1a

One of the most arresting passages in the Torah (the Five Books of Moses) occurs in the 23rd chapter of the Book of Numbers.

The stage is set in Numbers 22. The Israelites, on their way to the Promised Land, have camped out in the plains of Moab—in what is now Jordan, just across the Jordan River from what is now Israel. They’re a vast multitude, and Balak, king of Moab, sees them and is deathly afraid.

So Balak summons a Moabite prophet, Balaam, and asks him to “curse me this people; for they are too mighty for me….” Balaam eventually agrees, but with the proviso that “the word that God putteth in my mouth, that I shall speak.”

In Numbers 23:9, referring to the people of Israel both in the singular and the plural, Balaam pronounces:

For from the top of the rocks I see him, and from the hills I behold him: lo, the people shall dwell alone, and shall not be reckoned among the nations.

This, then, is not a “curse” but something God has put in Balaam’s mouth. Yet it seems to imply some sort of splendid isolation, a separate and unique fate.

Yet other, no less resonant statements in the Bible suggest that Israel’s destiny is very much connected to that of other peoples. In Isaiah 42:6 and 49:6, God says Israel’s mission is to be “a light unto the nations”; and in Isaiah 60:3: “And unto your light, nations shall walk, and kings unto the brightness of your rising.” In Genesis, God tells Abraham three times, and Isaac once, that “In thee shall all nations [or 'families'] of the earth be blessed.”

That theme—or contradiction?—of splendid isolation while having much to offer other peoples runs throughout Jewish history, and is very much present in Israel today.

PJ-Light-2

Is Israel an isolated country? Many think so. The Israeli left regularly warns that, if Israel doesn’t somehow “make peace” and clear out of the West Bank (Judea and Samaria), its isolation will only worsen until it truly becomes a leper.

Recently Efraim Inbar, head of the Begin-Sadat Center think tank at Israel’s Bar-Ilan University, published an article challenging that view. Inbar begins by acknowledging that:

The bad news is clear. Israel’s right to exist is questioned by many, and its ancient and present capital, Jerusalem, is unrecognized by all but a few states. Israeli leaders are sometimes compared to leaders of Nazi Germany, and Israeli actions against the Palestinians are described as Nazi-like policies…. Opponents and critics portray the Jewish state as the world’s worst violator of human rights, United Nations resolutions, and international law.

And with Jews “historically conditioned to sense isolation and delegitimization,” it all has a clear effect on Israelis:

An August 2010 poll showed that 56 percent of Jewish Israelis subscribed to the view that the “whole world is against us.” Even a larger majority, 77 percent, thought that it made no difference what the Israeli government did and how far it might go on the Palestinian issue: The world would continue to be critical regardless of the facts.

And yet, says Inbar, the situation on the ground has actually changed dramatically for the better.

Since 1991, Israel’s international status has greatly improved as many states decided to upgrade or to establish diplomatic relations with the Jewish state, partly due to the emergence of [Israel’s foremost ally] the United States as a hegemonic global power…. [A]ll former states of the Soviet bloc and most Afro-Asian states have opted for diplomatic relations and have maintained them ever since.

Inbar also cites

a high level of friendly relations toward Israel and the Jewish people within the two most populous and dynamic states on the world scene: India and China, rising powers in every sense of the word. Both are old civilizations that have not been burdened by anti-Semitic baggage as has Europe.

PJ-Light-3

As for Europe, Inbar allows that it is “an entirely different matter.” Its pacifism, anti-Americanism, and “latent, traditional anti-Semitism that singles out the Jews as responsible for the problems of the world” all dispose it against Israel. Indeed, “a large portion of the European intelligentsia is anti-Israeli and even denies Israel’s right to exist.”

Yet, at the same time, Israel’s relations with all three of Europe’s power centers—France, Italy, and Germany—are flourishing. And “in 2011, the EU was Israel’s largest trading partner with annual trade amounting to 29.4 billion euros—an increase of 45 percent from 2009; and this came in the midst of an unprecedented financial crisis in Europe.”

Along with the post-Cold War hegemony of Israel’s ally, the U.S., Inbar attributes the change to the fact that Israel has more and more to offer—in intelligence, counterterrorism, military equipment, high-tech, agriculture, medicine. “All of these accomplishments have created international admiration and keen interest in bilateral exchanges and trade relations.”

Or, one might say that the nations of the world find themselves blessed by Israel’s cutting-edge prowess, inventions, and innovations.

.

And yet…

Israelis love to go on foreign junkets. Ben-Gurion International Airport tends to be jam-packed with long lines for outgoing flights, especially in summer—and this at a time of protests over the high cost of living and the economic strains faced by middle-class families.

A glance at Israel’s immediate environment helps explain this urge to escape and take a breather. Gaza and the Arab-populated areas of the West Bank—even as “peace” is supposedly being negotiated—are hotbeds of anti-Israeli hatred. Although Israel has signed peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan, few Israelis go to these countries because of that same problem. As for the other immediate neighbors, Syria and Lebanon, they remain hostile states in every regard.

The statistics bear this out. A Pew poll in 2009 found 97% in the Palestinian territories, 97% of Jordanians, 98% of Lebanese, and 95% of Egyptians “express[ing] an unfavorable opinion of Jews.”

Where to go, then, in leapfrogging this depressing encirclement of animosity? Turkey was once a popular destination—but not in recent years as hatred has risen under Prime Minister Erdogan’s Islamist government. An alternative is Greece—if Israelis want to overlook the facts that last year the neo-Nazi Golden Dawn party won 7% of the vote, and that Greek media tend to be fiercely anti-Israeli with sprinklings of anti-Semitism.

So Israelis mostly go to Europe. But that too is complicated; some Israeli families, once disembarked in France or Belgium or Holland, cease speaking Hebrew for fear of prompting the dangerous hostility of Arab and Muslim immigrants there—or even terror attacks or kidnapping attempts.

And it’s not only those immigrant populations. In Europe, Israelis “vacation” in a continent where high percentages of the population overall—including 48% in Germany—believe Israelis are essentially Nazis waging “a war of extermination” against the Palestinians.

Also worth mentioning is a global opinion poll last year where Israel came in with Iran, Pakistan, and North Korea as the four most unpopular countries. Anti-Israeli ratings were particularly high in Spain (74%), Germany (69%), Britain (68%), and France (56%). Even in China and India, which Inbar described as Israel-friendly countries lacking an anti-Semitic tradition, Israel scored poorly.

If you can put together the money for the trip, it’s better in the U.S., which—along with Nigeria and Kenya—was one of only three countries in that poll registering a favorable view of Israel. But the overall effect is that the “people that dwells alone” feeling gets into your bones.

PJ-Light-5a

How Israelis feel toward the “dwelling alone” paradigm has political implications. The more they’re to the left, the more they’re likely to insist that Israel brings the animosity upon itself—by perversely refusing to end its “occupation” of the West Bank and perversely rejecting an Arab hand that they always perceive as, somehow, outstretched in peace.

That isn’t, of course, my view. Even if the charges were justified, it would hardly explain how Israel—a vibrant democracy and member of the world’s leading democracies-only club, the OECD—could be ranked with Iran, Pakistan, and North Korea by most of the world’s peoples. And to hear Nazi analogies you have to go far out to Israel’s loony-left fringe.

So the mainstream-Israeli perception of an irrationally inimical world, which can’t really be swayed by supposedly improved Israeli behavior, has a real basis. It may jibe with traditional notions about Israel and the nations, but it is not simply produced by them.

Dwelling alone, but radiating light. Perhaps, after all, something about this fate is deeply inscribed on reality.

Also read: Israel: Leper or Light Unto the Nations? Part 2: That Bird Could Be a Mossad Agent!

P. David Hornik is a freelance writer and translator living in Beersheva and author of the new book Choosing Life in Israel. He blogs at http://pdavidhornik.typepad.com/

Comments are closed.

Top Rated Comments   
One aspect of life in Israel you omitted was the amount of integration of Israeli Arabs into Israeli society. I believe the driving force towards integration has been the relative prosperity in Israel. Go to any hospital and you will find a completely integrated staff. Shopping centers and recreational areas you will find Jews and Arabs. You may have trouble getting into some of the Arab villages because of the Jewish shoppers clogging the roads trying to to do their shopping there. There are some areas such as high tech where there too is a start towards integration. The media doesnt report any of this since it doesnt fit their agenda.
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
All Comments   (10)
All Comments   (10)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
Elise. even though Todd`s st0rry is super... last tuesday I bought Buick from making $5572 this last month and-also, ten-k this past munth. this is really the nicest-work I've ever done. I actually started five months/ago and almost straight away started making a nice more than $79 per/hr. I use this website, http://www.wep6.com
Go to website and click Home tab for more details.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
Western ethics are the modern manifestation of the ancient moral prescriptions originally recorded in the Torah. Is it really a coincidence if those most in rebellion against these ancient moral prescriptions are precisely those who hate the people who managed to convey them all the way into the present?

The modern state of Israel as a miracle in our time. If we take history as a guide, should we expect miracles to be universally recognized, let alone celebrated? Let's be realistic, and recognize the hard facts: Just as an example, the Saudi monarchy is so afraid of the Bible, it has banned it in its land! This is the kind of reality we live in. The nation of Israel is doing a darn good job of dealing with it, but the hate is ultimately the haters' problem.
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
I support Israel 100% as an ally and pretty much sole rational actor in an irrational, dangerous part of the world. I am not so naive to not believe that ultimately Israel acts in Israel's own self-perceived best interests. Articles that portray that "Real Politic" in self-referencing religiosity make me more than a little nervous. The differnce one might suppose in Americas' "Manifest Destiny" to ultimately expand to the Pacific as opposed to a "Divine Destiny" used to justify it. The former represents geographic rationality, the latter more on the order of mystic moralization.
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
As an American Jew all I can say is when 89% of Republicans, 78% of independents and 63% of Democrats support Israel, Israel will never have to worry, We are hear to back you up, no matter what Obama does. And Canada also has high support for Israel and lately has been Israels best friend in the UN, so our norther neighbors are on your side too and 75% of columbians support Israel, so you have some support in central america and many of the pacific island nations back you up too.

Israel, you've got friends. God be with the only democracy in the region with no state religion and guaranteed religious freedoms for all, free speech and equality for all
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
One aspect of life in Israel you omitted was the amount of integration of Israeli Arabs into Israeli society. I believe the driving force towards integration has been the relative prosperity in Israel. Go to any hospital and you will find a completely integrated staff. Shopping centers and recreational areas you will find Jews and Arabs. You may have trouble getting into some of the Arab villages because of the Jewish shoppers clogging the roads trying to to do their shopping there. There are some areas such as high tech where there too is a start towards integration. The media doesnt report any of this since it doesnt fit their agenda.
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
to 99.9% of the MSM, facts are such inconvenient things! Thanks for posting this important information.
35 weeks ago
35 weeks ago Link To Comment
Really wonderful article. I had of course been aware of the "light onto the nations" phrase, but not the "dwelling alone." It brings a certain solace to know that the Torah foresaw this (in some broad way).

An original and insightful piece. Very well done.
36 weeks ago
36 weeks ago Link To Comment
The kind words are much appreciated.
36 weeks ago
36 weeks ago Link To Comment
You write as a man of immense integrity. Beautiful article; sobering, but beautiful. Thank you.
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
And thank you very much.
37 weeks ago
37 weeks ago Link To Comment
View All