MSNBC’s latest feature on Operation Midway Blitz begins with a blue sweater and ends with crocodile tears.
Start the sad violins and lamenting choir. Fade to downtown Chicago.
A mother leaving home for groceries finds herself suddenly and violently surrounded by Border Patrol agents. As cameras roll, the wind and string instruments swell with sappy feelings. Meanwhile, in the background, the man and his announcer voice declare, "President Donald Trump, a single man transforming America into a country that highlights evil."
Fade to black.
Over a five-day span in greater Chicago, MSNBC received dozens of reports from families and neighbors alleging that their loved ones had been taken by immigration officials, seemingly without any reason other than being undocumented.
On Wednesday — the day after the detentions in Cicero and Berwyn — two sisters were stopped and dragged out of their vehicle in front of a school in Chicago’s Little Italy neighborhood by at least 10 agents, some of them wearing face coverings. Video obtained and verified by MSNBC shows one of the women pinned to the ground as she pleaded for help.
“They don’t have a warrant. They forcefully opened the door of the truck. It was locked, it was locked,” the woman repeated. MSNBC confirmed both women were later released.
“When Donald Trump campaigned, he said he was going after criminals, rapists and drug dealers,” said Humberto Fuentes, a resident who said he witnessed the women being detained. “Now, they’re assaulting women, deporting children, mothers and fathers — not criminals. And if they’re criminals, he needs to prove it. We haven’t seen that evidence yet.”
That’s the main argument being made by legal observers and state and local officials, including Gov. JB Pritzker.
Usually, journalism doesn't play soundtracks; it's supposed to check the script at the door. If we look for the truth behind MSNBC's sympathetic framing, we see a different story; the violent crime rate in Chicago has dropped by more than 30% this year. DHS confirmed that more than 1,500 illegal aliens have been arrested since early September, many of whom had prior convictions for assault, robbery, and sexual abuse.
Despite these horrific numbers, the network decided to focus its spotlight on anecdotes rather than the aggregate.
MSNBC is demanding that you feel, not know.
Selective Sympathy
The woman referenced in the column, Maricela Rosales Castillo, wearing the blue sweater in the video, is introduced as a mother with "...no apparent criminal record," a phrase signaling editorial spin.
What MSNBC conveniently omits is the same thing that DHS officials confirmed: Rosales admitted to being in the United States illegally, a federal offense under Title 8 U.S.C. § 1325.
This wasn't a random arrest, just a legal one.
Still, the paint brushes MSNBC is using to paint the image showing her to be a gentle matriarch who was yanked from her kitchen FOR DARING to make meatball stew.
What's missing in this picture? Any curiosity about her immigration status, prior orders, or appeals, where facts dissolve into feelings, and a tearful daughter is quoted verbatim, yet there's no verification of the government's data.
The writers nailed her humanity, but MSNBC's version lacks any semblance of honesty.
Numbers vs. Narratives
Operation Midway Blitz targeted "the worst of the worst criminal illegal aliens" when DHS launched the effort.
Over 800 arrests occurred in the first week, according to federal updates.
CBS Chicago reported that by early October, there were over 1,500 detainees, including offenders convicted of violent assault and child abuse.
However, MSNBC focused on the claim that only about 1% of those arrests involved men with criminal records, presenting that number as proof that the operation is nothing but a farce without verifying it through FOIA requests, court filings, or ICE data.
What we're seeing isn't journalism, it's narrative curation.
The Chicago Context
The crime statistics for 2025 in Chicago are publicly available, with the city reporting that violent crime is down 21.6%, homicides down 32.3%, and shootings down 37.4%.
Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson told Congress that 2024 marked the city's lowest homicide rate in five years.
These points lead me to ask: How does a city experiencing its safest stretch in fifty years fit MSNBC's portrayals of a chaotic crackdown?
It doesn't.
MSNBC avoids that contradiction, leading viewers to think that Chicago is under siege when, statistically speaking, it's under repair.
Melodrama Over Measurement
With each subsequent scene, MSNBC replaces evidence with emotion: hovering helicopters, masked agents, crying mothers surrounded by men, described as "good people" by friends.
More questions: where are the dockets, court dates, and prior deportation records?
A review of ICE logs reveals several arrestees with previous removals, yet MSNBC pretends enforcement is persecution.
Paraphrasing, Thomas Sowell warned that moral crusades often replaced logic with imagery. MSNBC easily demonstrates it: Every photo becomes an argument and every tear a verdict.
MSNBC's "reporting" never asks why DHS used such forceful tactics, whether those detained included repeat offenders who reentered after prior convictions.
It just sells pity.
A Network Addicted to Victimhood
MSNBC's story isn't about immigration at its heart; it's about affirmation, flattering audiences when it reinforced the belief that compassion and policy are opposites.
Framing its coverage, MSNBC presents federal agents as aggressors and illegal immigrants as victims, by default: No middle ground, moral complexity, or acknowledgment that law enforcement is both firm and humane.
That's when we see the tragedy of modern media: Not arrests, but the laziness.
Final Thoughts
At its core, real journalism doesn't need a string section; it requires verification. Operation Midway Blitz deserves deeper scrutiny. Name one government program that doesn't. However, the melodrama MSNBC uses in its storytelling blurs truth into theater; a network weeping on cue isn't uncovering facts; it's running auditions for empathy.
The blue sweater on that illegal immigrant makes for a striking visual, but no matter what MSNBC left out three things: context, balance, and courage.
Legacy media no longer reports; it performs. They cue the music, dim the lights, and call it journalism. Facts? Optional. Accountability? Canceled.
Our culture once valued truth-telling, even when it hurt. But somewhere between hashtags and headlines, that instinct died. The burned hand teaches best — yet MSNBC keeps reaching for the stove.
Before the curtain falls, (click) on the cue, (click) on the tears, (SLAP!) on the facts; use promo code POTUS47 to get 74% off your VIP membership. Join us at PJ Media, where truth doesn’t need a soundtrack.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member