PJ Media encourages you to read our updated PRIVACY POLICY and COOKIE POLICY.

July 11, 2018

I’M VERY DISAPPOINTED IN PHILIP ZIMMERMAN, WHO’S QUOTED IN THIS ARTICLE distinguishing his Pretty Good Privacy encryption program from Cody Wilson’s 3D-gun-printing program:

Zimmermann takes issue with the analogy—on ethical if not legal grounds. This time, he points out, the First Amendment–protected data that was legally treated as a weapon actually is a weapon. “Encryption is a defense technology with humanitarian uses,” Zimmermann says. “Guns are only used for killing.”

That’s objectively false, of course: Guns are used for lots of things. None of my guns has ever been used for killing. And it’s also perilously close to — by which I mean functionally indistinguishable from — the kinds of things people said about PGP: “Only criminals and terrorists need encryption.”

Very disappointing indeed. (Bumped).