Get PJ Media on your Apple

The PJ Tatler

Bryan Preston


April 30, 2013 - 9:23 am

News broke Monday that the Tsarnaev family has received about $100,000 in welfare payments since coming to the US in 2002. For a decade, until last year, the family drew government payments month in and month out. The benefits included cash, food stamps and Section 8 housing.

“The breadth of the benefits the family was receiving was stunning,” said a person with knowledge of documents handed over to a legislative committee today.

The state has handed over more than 500 documents to the 11-member House Post Audit and Oversight Committee, which today met for the first time and plans to call in officials from the Department of Transitional Assistance to testify.

Massachusetts officials, Democrat and Republican alike, are pledging to investigate. While they’re at it, they should take a look at the possibility that welfare actually fosters terrorism.

Ever since the Boston bombing, liberals have been casting about for a cause other than radical Islam to explain it. Maybe it was brain injury from Tamerlan Tsarnaev’s boxing (even though Dzhokhar was not a boxer). Or maybe the Golden Glove and “anti-immigrant” policy caused it.

Well, how about welfare?

Back in 2001 Mickey Kaus made a then comprehensive list of accused terrorists who had been on welfare. It was astounding.

The point isn’t simply that many terrorists take advantage of Western welfare states, the same way they take advantage of Western freedoms and Western technology. The point is that extreme anti-social terrorist ideologies (radical Islam, in particular) seem to breed in “oppositional” cultures supported by various government welfare benefits.

This is particularly evident in France, where—as this Los Angeles Times piece describes—unemployed and alienated North African Arab immigrants in subsidized public housing projects turn to crime and violence in a vicious cycle familiar to students of the African-American “underclass.” Except that in France, in the “violent neighborhoods, the housing projects where the young men can be recruited” into terrorism, an “ironic thing” happens, according to a French intelligence officer quoted by the Times‘ Sebastian Rotella:

“When the extremists take control, violence goes down. Islam brings discipline. But then we have to watch that neighborhood for a different reason.”


Now let’s look at the Tsarnaevs. The family arrived in the US and nearly immediately went on welfare. Zubeidat Tsarnaev ran afoul of the law at least once, and is accused of shoplifting in 2011. She allegely stole $1600 worth of designer dresses. If she travels to the US to visit her surviving jihadist son, she could face arrest and felony charges on that rap. News broke today that Katherine Tsarnaev, wife of the late Tamerlan, was also busted for shoplifting, in 2007. She confessed to stealing $67 from an Old Navy store. Oddly, the then 18-year-old who had not yet met the Tsarnaevs claimed she was married.

Petty crime. Welfare. Terrorism. They’re all anti-social and contemptuous behaviors. The Tsarnaevs exhibit all three.

What role did going on welfare play in the Boston bombing? Liberals won’t ask that question because increasing dependence on welfare is a cherished liberal policy. Increasing the welfare rolls has proven key to the Democrats’ stranglehold on urban voting, and helped Barack Obama win re-election.

Bryan Preston has been a leading conservative blogger and opinionator since founding his first blog in 2001. Bryan is a military veteran, worked for NASA, was a founding blogger and producer at Hot Air, was producer of the Laura Ingraham Show and, most recently before joining PJM, was Communications Director of the Republican Party of Texas.

Comments are closed.

All Comments   (3)
All Comments   (3)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
HAHAH! This is small potatoes! Ever tuned in to a Hispanic Radio station? 24/7 diatribe, detailing specifically how to "game-the-system! See, the "Illegal Alien" huddled masses don't know how to:1)read, 2)write or 3)speak their own idioms.
So, any utterances must be repeated ad infinitum in order for the listening Hispanic community to form lines, marching (en masse) to their EBT, WICS, Sec(8), welfare stations for application and registry in every government handout
progrdam this administration has authorized...and Janet Napoltiano has facilitated. Pray. Amen.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
"While they’re at it, they should take a look at the possibility that welfare actually fosters terrorism."

While we can't be sure, we do need to eliminate welfare. If it saves just one life. . .
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
If welfare causes terrorism then we have a heck of a lot of terrorists in this country. More likely, people that turn to welfare have no particular affinity for their country. Let's face it, the average citizen is embarrassed to take handouts. Most of us feel that we have a duty, not only to ourselves and our families, but also to our country to be self-reliant. A person dependent on welfare has a slave/master relationship with their country and it doesn't surprise me at all that the relationship breeds resentment. Eliminate the welfare and eventually the resentment will fade away.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
View All

One Trackback to “Does Welfare Foster Terrorism?”