REDUCTIO AD SOMALIA: “This post by Michael O’Hare is an example of the sort of rhetoric that seems appealing–nay, irrefutable!–when you are crafting it over drinks with like-minded friends, and that falls entirely flat when you deploy it against people who don’t share your priors.”

We see a lot of those — surprisingly from the people who claim to possess a keen awareness of nuance, and who charge others with “epistemic closure.”