Why Not Set Up Refugee Kiosks in Honduras? Can We Consider Any Idea from Obama, McCain?

A plan to evaluate refugee status for Hondurans in Honduras currently makes the rounds in D.C. -- apparently backed by some in the Obama administration, it resembles a recent bill from Senators John McCain and Jeff Flake of Arizona. The idea is to protect people, especially youth and children, from a dangerous trek across coyote-infested lands.

No one knows the details of this plan to set up, in effect, refugee immigration kiosks in Honduras, and the White House says no decision has been made, but already there's pushback. This raises the question: Do Republicans, conservatives and libertarians need to shoot it down immediately because...

1) It might increase immigration from Honduras, and

2) might spread to other countries, and/or

2) it's backed by McCain and Obama?

After all, we're talking about facilitating legal immigration, and this might keep potential immigrants from piling up in U.S. border towns, jeopardizing public health and straining social services.

Regardless of the eventual shape of this plan, it's time for folks on the Right to take the moral high ground on immigration. Oddly enough, if we're serious about that, we'll find that the issue isn't immigration at all.

I know that even in whispering this, I may run afoul of my friends who think that it is the tide of immigrants -- some unwilling to assimilate -- that's destroying our country. They're stealing American jobs, or bearing contagions, including radical Islam. Seal the border.

Before our knees jerk in opposition to the latest proposal, we need to ask: Will the tide stop anytime soon under any plan which can actually pass Congress, and be implemented efficaciously?

No. The tide will stop when America stops being the beacon of liberty. I contend that one who wishes to stem the tide of immigration, inadvertently wishes American demise.

The New Colossus, by Emma Lazarus