Veepstakes: Should Romney Stay Away from Someone Too 2008?

There's been plenty of back and forth about whether Rubio would be Romney's Palin -- with the same results. But Romney may be willing to take that chance if his team believes the star power will help more than hurt.

Washington "insider" or "outsider"?

Palin has urged Romney to "go rogue" and nominate Rep. Allen West (R-Fla.). That would automatically bring criticism that the freshman congressman is too inexperienced, but many on the right would hail the selection of a Tea Party favorite as embracing a Washington outsider for the job.

The list of Romney's VP potentials contains more than a few senators -- Rubio, Rob Portman (R-Ohio), Kelly Ayotte (R-N.H.), Pat Toomey (R-Pa.), John Thune (R-S.D.), Jim DeMint (R-S.C.), even the retiring Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.) -- and Congress members, such as Ryan and Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-Wash.). Cue the cries of whether someone is a "Washington insider" or an outsider deemed to be more in touch with the people.

It's actually a pretty moot argument. Leading a state still means you served in politics, with all of the Washington backstabbing and deal-making on a smaller scale. Even many of the governors mentioned, such as Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels and Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, have Washington experience.

What's important is how well you did on that political playing field -- and if it will help you successfully navigate and conquer deadlocked legislators and some especially screwy government agencies.

A "war on women" warrior?

In this "war on women not really" year, there's a crop of female potentials from which Romney can choose -- McMorris Rodgers, Ayotte, Condoleezza Rice, New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez, retiring Texas Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison, South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley. And if he chooses a woman, it's immediately going to draw comparisons to the McCain-Palin ticket, warranted or not.

The fact is that more women have given up looking for work now than since 1993 (only 57.6 percent of women are now in the labor force), and it would be powerful for a woman on the VP campaign trail to get up and tell voters, as a working woman who has climbed up the political ladder, that this is a travesty and the administration sending women's progress backward.

With the women's vote up for grabs and the Obama campaign ready to whip out Lilly Ledbetter and birth control at every stop, it's worth more than a thought for the Romney campaign.

Swing-state homeboys

Of course, you've gotta think strategy when selecting a veep. Yeah, you have to govern with this guy for the next four years should you win, but what can he or she do to help you win?

This, of course, blends with the other categories: Rubio and Florida, Portman and Ohio, Gov. Bob McDonnell and Virginia.

Portman is a good guy, but then you'd have two campaign wives on the same ticket trying to convince the populace that their husbands are really wild and crazy guys. So here comes the Star Power vs. Old Reliable category, and his years in Washington as OMB director, U.S. trade representative and congressman bring up the "Washington insider" consideration.

Nobody's perfect when it comes trying to find to a truly Teflon vice president. The deliberative process will weigh the pros and cons of the candidates against these and other considerations.

One thing's for sure about Romney's selection: we're probably not going to have to wait until the convention to hear it. If it's the right person, the campaign would obviously want him or her out on the trail ASAP.

But the reality is that there's a "pretty significant group of people," in Romney's words, being plowed through by his selection team. Romney has said that he'd "want to take a very careful look" at the potentials -- vet vet vet -- and he wants "to select someone who has the capacity to become president if that were necessary."

It will be interesting to see if that person has tried to be president in the not-so-distant past.