The Quiet Revolution: A Religious Revival in America

Orthodox Jews

I have often mentioned the special role that religion, in the form of Biblical morality, plays in the history of the American political experiment. The Founding Fathers, under the influence of the British Enlightenment of the 18th century, understood the state and its nature to be the natural outgrowth of the nation as a whole. A generation or so before the climactic events of the last quarter of the 18th century, a Protestant religious revival, the Great Awakening, had swept through the 13 British colonies, and had a profound effect on the thinking of the people who confronted the tyranny which King George III and his officials sought to impose on them.

No less a constitutional authority than John Adams, first vice president and second president of the United States, put it this way: “Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.” The reason should be obvious: only a self-disciplined, self-restrained, self-reliant people can function with the relatively minimalist government, one whose processes are deliberately slowed and frustrated by checks and balances to maximize personal liberty, as the United States Constitution seeks to do.

It follows, therefore, that a form of religious revival is precisely what is necessary to restore the health of the American civil society, which has been under such relentless assault in recent decades from the Left, if we would wish to save the constitutional order. To that end, recent surveys showing a marked decline in religious observance in the general American population have made depressing reading for people of a conservative mind.

But there is a bright corner, a quiet religious revival which has been underway for the past 40 years or so, spearheaded by a tiny group of visionaries who began building for it as long ago as the 1930s. I am speaking of the American Orthodox Jewish population.

Recently, Pew Research Center put out a report looking more deeply into the implications of a survey taken in 2013 of the American Jewish community. Walking through some of the statistics in the survey should provide some welcome news for people with conservative views of all religious persuasions.

To show just how conservative this segment of the Jewish population is, the Pew report notes that in many ways they most closely resemble white Christian evangelical Protestants, rather than any other group (certainly including secular Jews). For example, 83% of Orthodox Jews and 86% of evangelicals say that religion is very important in their lives (only 20% of heterodox Jews do); 74% of Orthodox Jews and 75% of evangelicals report regular attendance at worship services (at least once a month); and 84% of Orthodox Jews and 82% of evangelicals believe that the Holy Land was given to the Jewish people by G-d (only 35% of heterodox Jews do). Also, 89% of Orthodox Jews and 93% of evangelicals say that they believe in G-d with absolute certainty.

Furthermore (as of mid-2013), 57% of Orthodox Jews identified with the Republican Party or leaned toward the party (vs. 66% of white evangelicals) and 54% call themselves politically conservative (vs. 62% of white evangelicals). Orthodox Jews are far more likely to have similar views to evangelicals on issues such as abortion, homosexuality and same-sex unions, and limited government (58% in both of the latter cases). The Orthodox Jewish community itself is divided into camps: Pew found that 62% of self-identified Orthodox Jews identify as “Charedim” (the most seriously observant segment of the population; the term is derived from Isaiah LXVI,2: Shim‘u dëvar Ha-Shem hacharédim el dëvaro – “Hear the word of Ha-Shem, those who tremble at His word”), while 31% identify as “modern Orthodox”; what the rest call themselves is not quantified.

Next: The most exciting part of the Pew report...