Election 2009: The Strange Case of NY-23
chat
comments
Read the entire piece here.
https://pjmedia.com/blog/election-2009-the-strange-case-of-ny-23/
![]({"FeaturedImage":[{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-940x350xt.jpg","width":940,"height":350,"name":"article_home_banner_desktop","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_desktop","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"","width":750,"height":486,"name":"article_home_banner_phone_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"true","cropBoxLeft":"476.62003569834894"},{"url":"","width":740,"height":592,"name":"article_grid_desktop_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_desktop_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"true","cropBoxLeft":"375.5"},{"url":"","width":1540,"height":830,"name":"article_banner_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_banner_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"true","cropBoxLeft":"351.7168674698795"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-375x243x402x42x368x239.jpg","width":375,"height":243,"name":"article_home_banner_phone","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"true","cropBoxLeft":"476.62003569834894"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-370x296x302x16x415x332.jpg","width":370,"height":296,"name":"article_grid_desktop","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_desktop","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"true","cropBoxLeft":"375.5"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-80x80xtr.jpg","width":80,"height":80,"name":"article_popular_now","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_popular_now","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"","width":710,"height":568,"name":"article_grid_tablet_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_tablet_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":null,"cropBoxLeft":null},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-724x243xt.jpg","width":724,"height":243,"name":"article_home_banner_tablet","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_tablet","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":null,"cropBoxLeft":null},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-770x415x279x6x492x265.jpg","width":770,"height":415,"name":"article_banner","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_banner","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"true","cropBoxLeft":"351.7168674698795"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-336x269x302x16x415x332.jpg","width":336,"height":269,"name":"article_grid_phone","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":null,"cropBoxLeft":null},{"url":"","width":160,"height":160,"name":"article_popular_now_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_popular_now_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"","width":672,"height":538,"name":"article_grid_phone_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":null,"cropBoxLeft":null},{"url":"","width":1880,"height":700,"name":"article_home_banner_desktop_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_desktop_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/andrewklavan/user-content/26/files/2016/02/klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1.sized-355x284x302x16x415x332.jpg","width":355,"height":284,"name":"article_grid_tablet","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_tablet","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":null,"cropBoxLeft":null},{"url":"","width":1448,"height":486,"name":"article_home_banner_tablet_2x","image":"26-6073","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_tablet_2x","caption":"klavan_amy_lindsay_article_banner_2-12-16-1","alt_text":"","cropper":null,"cropBoxLeft":null}]})
![]({"FeaturedImage":[{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-940x350xc.jpg","width":940,"height":350,"name":"article_home_banner_desktop","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_desktop","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":750,"height":486,"name":"article_home_banner_phone_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":740,"height":592,"name":"article_grid_desktop_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_desktop_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":1540,"height":830,"name":"article_banner_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_banner_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-375x243xc.jpg","width":375,"height":243,"name":"article_home_banner_phone","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-370x296xt.jpg","width":370,"height":296,"name":"article_grid_desktop","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_desktop","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-80x80xt.jpg","width":80,"height":80,"name":"article_popular_now","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_popular_now","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":710,"height":568,"name":"article_grid_tablet_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_tablet_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"","cropBoxLeft":""},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-724x243xc.jpg","width":724,"height":243,"name":"article_home_banner_tablet","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_tablet","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"","cropBoxLeft":""},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-770x415xc.jpg","width":770,"height":415,"name":"article_banner","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_banner","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-336x269xt.jpg","width":336,"height":269,"name":"article_grid_phone","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"","cropBoxLeft":""},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":160,"height":160,"name":"article_popular_now_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"all","fallback":null,"slot":"article_popular_now_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":672,"height":538,"name":"article_grid_phone_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"mobile","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"","cropBoxLeft":""},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":1880,"height":700,"name":"article_home_banner_desktop_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"desktop","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_desktop_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"false","cropBoxLeft":"-1"},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.sized-355x284xt.jpg","width":355,"height":284,"name":"article_grid_tablet","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_grid_tablet","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"","cropBoxLeft":""},{"url":"https://static.pjmedia.com/faith/user-content/52/files/2017/03/Russell_D._Moore_Preaching.jpg","width":1448,"height":486,"name":"article_home_banner_tablet_2x","image":"8125","resolution":"1","breakpoint":"tablet","fallback":null,"slot":"article_home_banner_tablet_2x","caption":"(By Theology147, Own work, CC-by-SA, via Wikimedia Commons)","alt_text":"Russell_Moore","cropper":"","cropBoxLeft":""}]})