Deconstructing the Trayvon Martin Narrative: Nothing Left to Argue?

The prosecution rested in State of Florida versus George Zimmerman on Friday, July 5. Supporters of the prosecution's case believe neighborhood watch volunteer George Zimmerman to be a "wannabe" cop who racially profiled Trayvon Martin, stalked him during a cold and rainy February night, started a fight with him, and then murdered him. Yet detractors of the state's case have much evidence with which to deconstruct those claims following two weeks of the trial.

Claim 1: George Zimmerman profiled Trayvon Martin

Both the prosecution and supporters of their case suggest that George Zimmerman racially profiled Trayvon Martin -- that Zimmerman singled out Martin because of his race. There is potentially some merit to this theory, as many of the calls made by George Zimmerman to the Sanford Police Department did indeed end up involving young black males that matched Trayvon Martin's general description, as noted by one of Zimmerman's neighbors:

"Let's talk about the elephant in the room. I'm black, OK?" the woman said, declining to be identified because she anticipated backlash due to her race. She leaned in to look a reporter directly in the eyes. "There were black boys robbing houses in this neighborhood," she said. "That's why George was suspicious of Trayvon Martin."

However, the phone call George Zimmerman placed to the Sanford Police Department's non-emergency number (NEN) suggests that Zimmerman did not know the race of the person he was calling about as the call was made, and indeed suggests that he was merely calling about suspicious behavior:

We’ve had some break-ins in my neighborhood and there’s a real suspicious guy. It’s Retreat View Circle. The best address I can give you is 111 Retreat View Circle.

This guy looks like he’s up to no good or he’s on drugs or something. It’s raining and he’s just walking around looking about.

This is called behavioral profiling, offender profiling, criminal personality profiling, or other similar terms. This tactic is used extensively by law enforcement to make an educated guess about an individual based upon their behavior.

Only when prompted by the dispatcher did Zimmerman claim of Martin:

He looks black.

Zimmerman later stated that he was only able to confirm Trayvon Martin's race when Martin approached Zimmerman's vehicle with his hand in his waistband.

The available evidence suggests that behavioral profiling, not racial profiling, led to Zimmerman calling police.

Claim 2: Language used in the non-emergency number (NEN) call suggests malice aforethought

The prosecution began their opening statement with prosecutor John Guy angrily repeating one phrase from Zimmerman's NEN call:

F***ing punks, these ass****s always get away.

Brought up later in the trial, the prosecution inflected anger in the statement on multiple occasions. The state claims that the statement showed George Zimmerman was angry and bore "ill will" or "malice aforethought" towards Trayvon Martin. Indeed, the requirement for a second degree murder charge hinges on whether George Zimmerman had this mindset.

Listening to Zimmerman make that statement in the context of his call, in his own voice, reveals that Zimmerman's inflection suggests a man frustrated by the string of burglaries in his neighborhood. At no point during the duration of the NEN call does Zimmerman's voice rise to the level of what most would consider anger. The prosecution makes a subjective argument here in asserting this proves "ill will"or "malice aforethought."

As this is the contention on which a second degree murder conviction hangs, the state has little to no case.

Claim 3: George Zimmerman got out of his truck and followed Trayvon Martin, even though the police told him not to do so

This is a contention made both by the prosecution and the court of public opinion, but this contention is not based on fact or evidence.

George Zimmerman called the police NEN and spoke with dispatcher Sean Noffke. Noffke stated that he did not tell Zimmerman not to follow Martin, as they are trained to not make comments that sound like commands. His exact words:

We don't need you to do that.

Noffke further stated during his testimony that by asking Zimmerman which way Martin was going, Zimmerman could have reasonably interpreted this as being asked to follow Martin.

Claim 4: George Zimmerman stalked Trayvon Martin with a gun

The word "stalked" is a loaded phrase -- and it is also the description of a specific crime, and as such is well-defined.

Nothing George Zimmerman did that night comes close to meeting the legal definition of stalking according to Florida law. Following someone in public at a distance is not a crime.

As for Zimmerman being armed: he regularly carried his Kel-Tec PF9 in an inside-the-waistband (IWB) holster at all times except when he was at work.

There is no evidence suggesting that his gun was anywhere but in his holster up until the moment he drew it and fired one shot.