California Has Enough Laws

Yet another mass murder by a person with a history of mental illness problems – and again, the first solution is “more gun control.”   Unlike some of these other tragedies, where the requirement for “imminent danger” prevented police from taking a mentally ill person into custody before the killings, California actually has sufficient laws on the subject.  But that requires the police to actually use the laws that they have.

In California, a number of medical professionals, as well as any police officer, can take a person into custody for a 72 hour mental health evaluation, under Welfare & Institutions Code § 5150.  If the hospital evaluating that person decides that he is indeed mentally ill, he can be held for an additional fourteen days for “intensive treatment” under § 5250.  It turns out that police had contacted Elliot Rodger because his family had seen his social media posts about “suicide and killing people.”  Why didn’t the police take him into custody under § 5150?  I have seen, firsthand, California police using § 5150 to take people into custody for suicide threats.  Yet they did not do so in this case.

Would it have helped?  Ask Elliott Rodger.  His manifesto says directly: “I would have been thrown in jail, denied of the chance to exact revenge on my enemies. I can't imagine a hell darker than that.”  He might have received the treatment that he needed to recognize the insanity of what he was planning. But even if he came out of the mental hospital as crazy as he went in, this would still have been a win for public safety.  Why?

If a person has been held under either 5150 or 5250, they may not possess a firearm or ammunition for five years.  California has required all handgun purchases or transfers to go through the Dealer's Record of Sale process since Elliott Rodger was in diapers.  There is no exemption for gun shows, or ads in the newspaper.  California requires all new residents to register their firearms.

The police thus have access to registration records for all handguns, at least for people as young as Elliot Rodger, who by all accounts legally purchased his handguns.  Had they taken him into custody under § 5150, they would have had access to a list of all his registered handguns, and would have been authorized to search Rodger’s residence for and take into custody those handguns.  After leaving the mental hospital, Rodger might still have stabbed to death his three roommates, but he would have at least been greatly slowed him down from murdering anyone with a handgun.  (Although, I can’t picture the absence of a gun preventing Rodger from slashing to death blondes in Isla Vista.)