Second Witness Contradicts Leftist Comic Sarah Silverman's Wage Discrimination Video
Chris Murphy says he was there on the night that comic Sarah Silverman said she got $10 for the same work for which a male comic earned $60. Murphy says Silverman's story of sexism, told for a video campaign (see below) that champions equal pay for women, is not accurate. He backs then-New York Comedy Club owner Al Martin's claim that comics -- male or female -- who just drop in and ask to do a set, like Silverman did that night in 2002, don't get paid anything.
Murphy, in a Facebook post Monday afternoon, says even Bill Hicks and Rodney Dangerfield, who were big names back in that day, didn't expect compensation for guest spots at comedy clubs.
"There has been some He said she said things going on about the night in question between her [Silverman] and Al Martin. I feel I’m qualified to write about it since I was there.
I can confirm Sarah was not booked on the show, because I remember being excited she stopped in. Sarah rarely if ever played The New York Comedy Club. It could be because she was under the impression Al never paid comedians.
I gather this because when she came outside after her set she said, “Wow that was a great crowd. The place is packed. Al should be paying comedians”. The hilarious Todd Barry and I informed her he does. She went inside and asked to be paid. The rest is social media history." -- Chris Murphy on Facebook, April 13, 2015
After writing about Silverman's comedically sketchy story last week, I reached out to her. She responded with a direct message on Twitter. Silverman said, "What are you fighting for or against exactly. It's true. He [Al Martin] took advantage of someone he assumed wouldn't say anything. That's the point."
Actually, that's not the point of the "wage gap" video Silverman made for Levo.com, nor is it the reality of events as we've now heard from two other witnesses.
Like many Leftists with a cause, Silverman tries to identify with victims -- in this case, women who purportedly get paid less than men for the same work. But even though she went back 13 years to find a personal example, her victim-tale won't bear scrutiny. She makes it sound like Martin withheld from her the ordinary pay for a comedy set, but ponied up fully for male comic Todd Barry.
Martin maintains that Barry was scheduled for that night, and thus budgeted, but Silverman asked to do a set when she saw the great crowd. When she came back and asked for equal pay because she did the same work as Barry, Martin gave her $10 for cab fare. So, she was actually paid something when the standard expectation for guest spots is $0.
Chris Murphy added...
"I’m not sure why Sarah believed she was taking [sic] advantage of that night because she was a woman. Perhaps she was out of the loop so long she forgot the guest spot policy. Or it could be that in some circles it’s hip to crap on Al Martin."
If Martin and Murphy are right, then Silverman's story is not merely a mis-remembering or misunderstanding. She says she went back into the club after learning Barry got paid, and she asked Martin for $60. Silverman says that he sheepishly said, "O, did you want a $60 spot?" -- as if he were caught in the act of cheating her, ostensibly because she's a woman. She calls his behavior "pretty shitty."
In other words, in the video, Silverman calls out Martin for sex discrimination and deception. I have repeatedly attempted to ask Silverman about these challenges to her narrative, but have heard nothing in response since her direct message on Twitter. At this writing, that video has been viewed more than 162,000 times, but apparently many viewers aren't buying her story either. Check out the lopsidedly negative thumbs up-to-thumbs down ratio: 379-to-4,828.
If equal pay for women is a real problem, why can't celebrity Leftists tell a real, true story about it? If there are real victims, these fake stories can do nothing but harm them.