The publication of the mini-manifesto set off a revelatory (and occasionally hilarious) barrage of comments from members of the multifarious West Coast anarchist factions, exposing some of the ideological and practical rifts and conflicts that are literally tearing the scene apart. Here’s a sampling:
Lierre Keith pied with hot pepper not cream
The pies used to attack Lierre Keith were heavily laced with hot pepper and effectively she was pepper sprayed in the eyes, etc. This post claims PM Press & Bound Together have “crammed” Lierre “down our throats” — which I think goes a long way toward showing the bizarre and warped mind set of the middle-class toxic fetuses responsible for this attack. This apparently was carried out by a group of young people of privilege who have never had to deal with much hardship of any kind, and who have had to opportunity to sit around and dream up theories about the earth and universe that they desperately can’t abide any challenge to, from any quarter, no matter how well meaning. They remind me of some super politically correct counter-culture friends I used to have back in the 60′s. I could never measure up their ideas of what was “right” and they were fairly brutal to those who could not measure up. Every one of them crashed and burnt in some bizarre way.
She was pied, get over it. Big deal, even IF it was a spicy pie. Somebody call the waaaambulance for this loser. This action was both hilarious & totally appropriate. Anarchist resources should not be for posers just promoting the status quo. Her very presence there was very inappropriate.
This is pretty much what I expect from fascist vegan fundamentalist assholes. Heaven forbid that someone disagree with you and point out errors in the half-assed emotionality that you mistake for thinking! May your teeth all rot out (most vegans’ teeth do) and you suffer from the myriad deficiency related diseases for your sins of stupidity. Meanwhile, leave the rest of us alone to pursue our health and happiness!
She called the cops
No one has mentioned yet that the first thing she said after being pied was “Call the cops.” Sure enough, twenty minutes or so after she had cleaned off, many people saw her surrounded by a small group of supporters filing a police report, right in front of the bookfair.
to anyone who justifies this . . .
She was violently assaulted . . . of course she called the fucking cops.
You people (whoever did it, whoever posted the original message above, and whoever justifies or celebrates this attack on Lierre) are pathetic, cowardly, sadistic assholes.
Perhaps filing a police report wasn’t the best response. But how every so-called “anarchist” present stood by, idly, while 3 young men attacked a women without giving them a boot party is beyond me. You people aren’t anarchists, you’re Stalinists with a black flag.
Sorry, “anarchists”, you’re wrong.
To those who pied Lierre Keith: Your “self-congratulatory” note of ASSAULTING an ALLY was… fucked up, and flat-out wrong. Sorry, but you lose this argument. If you were part of my community, I’d vote you leave (banished) for highly abusive behavior.
Let me remind you, this was THREE (young) MEN assaulting a 45 YEAR OLD WOMAN! This is MISOGYNY and disgusting behavior. I am very anti-police, but anyone who demonizes someone for calling the police for a MAN ON WOMAN attack, seriously has their priorities fucked up, and is without a doubt anti-woman. Let’s not let the police oppress, but goddamn it, if they can be utilized to SOMETHING/ANYTHING useful (like preventing very REAL, very TRAUMATIZING abuse), then so be it.
Stop being so immature. We’re supposed to be allies (and diet, like others have said, is not revolutionary – actually fighting power is, not shooting yourself in the foot), but now I have less faith than ever in the people involved in the “movement”.
What? Nobody intervened? Nobody grabbed the perps? A room full of so called anarchists lets a woman be assulted by 3 men and nobody stands up to it? I’m disgusted. Lierre’s book is well reasoned, well researched and balanced and it’s a call for a compassionate way of living. To the Anarchist’s who did this it’s called dialogue you had an opportunity at a public event to question, cross examine Keith’s book and you took the lowest possible road exposing your own pathology.
To the perps: This is no movement… you are members of a lifestyle cult. Oh, how I wish I could join your elitist, pain free, cruelty-free club. Do you sense the irony in all of this?! You attacked a defenseless 45-year-old woman at the very moment she was speaking out AGAINST factory farming. Were you listening? Did you even read Lierre’s book?
Thank goodness these brave guys had the courage to assault this woman. More so, thank goodness they had the good sense and honesty to do so anonymously.
If we keep letting her discuss her issues openly, allowing her arguments to stand for themselves, then people might actually change their minds.
We can’t have that.
No! It’s time to mobilize, to silence dissenting voices, and to humiliate people who, through years of personal suffering, are motivated to share their personal revelations with others.
Thank goodness there were three of these men. Strength in numbers is always essential when you attack women with degenerative spine diseases.
This behavior is insane, and not surprising. I don’t understand why people are all like, “don’t call the cops”. What other accountability is there? Are there anarchists who will hunt down these three assholes and beat the fuck out of them? I didn’t think so. As much as I wish I could beat the fuck out of people who harass women (and men) like this, I’d end up going to jail when they called the cops on me. That’s sort of the joke of anyone saying “don’t call the cops”. It comes from a privileged position of not being the one who got fucked with. Let’s fuck with you and see what choices you have. It’s easier to bitch at someone for calling the cops then it is to come up with a different choice that brings balance and justice. Not that cops do that, but it’s the only choice we have cultural support for.
Interestingly, the pie-ing incident is not the only evidence of a Bay Area anarchist meltdown. Elsewhere on IndyBay (http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2010/02/26/18638853.php), for example, is this listing for a Bookfair afterparty which reveals that half of the anarchists have banned the other half from their clubhouse:
“Banned in Berkeley” A Bookfair Afterparty
For the ever growing list of individuals who have been ostracized by the Insane Banning Posse at Berkeley’s Long Haul Infoshop, there will be an alternative Anarchist Bookfair afterparty in Berkeley at Kip’s
…. There’s no reason why sane, rational radicals in the east bay cannot get together after the annual anarchist bookfair for a chat and a brew.
And there’s more. Though most of the Bay Area anarchist groups have an extreme far-left anti-American anti-capitalist tendency, the recent emergence of some far-right “National Anarchists” — as I captured on film at an anti-Israel event in San Francisco last year — has caused yet another massive conflagration of anarchist infighting, as the youngsters try to reconcile the irreconcilable conflict between the “total freedom” of political anarchy and the need to violently suppress all dissenting viewpoints.
And so it goes. Over the last 100 years, the various manifestations of radicalism have repeatedly self-imploded once confronted with the non-viability of their beliefs. It’s almost pathetic to watch these incredibly ignorant political buffoons destroy themselves. Let’s hope the rot spreads to other areas of the radical scene, so we can all sit back and enjoy the show.