The Quiet Californians
Empty States within a State
The Coast Ranges and the vast Sierra — outside a Yosemite or Tahoe — are as empty as Alaska. For all the Sierra Club protestations, few Marin County lawyers visit the upper San Joaquin River. They just wish no one else would as well. Although the mountain beauty is within an hour of greater Fresno’s million, apparently the Hondas and Camrys of the deprived poor can’t make up the grade, so the Sierra remains a haven for the quietist. In fact, one can drive to Cayucos on the coast, or Florence Lake in the High Sierra, or anywhere above Sacramento, and see almost no one. And to prevent insanity, the quietist keeps reminding himself, “Is such beauty, such weather, such solitude not worth a 12% premium on your income, or an hour a night to teach your child what she did not learn in school, or a little vigilance to mostly avoid what Los Angeles has become?” I am currently computing the cost of losing copper wire in all my pumps versus seeing the sun all of October. In California, one comes at the expense of the other.
The quiet Californian assumes that each year a new regulation, a new tax, a new something will seek him out. I read the “State Franchise Tax Board” print as I do the hate letters or emails I receive — incoherent, threatening. This year I got a letter from the state explaining that based on my income they “estimated” that I must have used the Internet to buy x-amount of things and therefore did not pay state sales taxes. Thus, they suggested that I should pay them around, say, $600.
Another such letter came from the Ministry of Revenue yesterday. The state says I have a house in the mountains and therefore may some day require auxiliary state fire protection and therefore should send them, say, $150 — or else!
Note that I pay local taxes to fund county and municipal police and fire. I give generously to the local volunteer fire department. (Would the state send someone in East L.A. some such letter, saying that because they live in an area that often requires the intervention of state law enforcement and SWAT teams, they should send in $150 protection money?) There is never any contract, warning, law — only a need for cash that justifies such confiscation.
So quietist Californians expect about every six months a new fee, dreamed up by a government employee who is paranoid that the state retirement system is broke, and with it his pension. The state employee is now entrepreneurial: without a certain number of traffic tickets written, without a certain number of new fees dreamed up, salaries and benefits dry up. I touch my rural mailbox as I do metal after skidding on a new carpet — a sort of static feeling of anxiety about what new state directive is inside.
I pick up the local paper: it has become a litany of rapes, murders, gang shootings, and molestations, peppered with drunk-driving fatalities and the uninsured and unlicensed who maim and kill routinely. The lurid tales of crime seem almost as if they come from a Sao Paulo suburb or the outskirts of Johannesburg. Yet the more violence, the more worry about insensitivity. So there is a general rule: the name of the driver, the killer, the robber, or the rapist arrested is rarely initially disclosed, much less his biography or photo — as if these are just random stats that can offer no higher wisdom. No worry — there is an answer to our world of Mad Max. Governor Brown will borrow $200 million for high-speed rail.
I note that an exception in California is the marquee universities.
A Stanford, for example, is home to elites and therefore it must be crime-free, so they often send out life-saving “alerts” that pop up in your email when a male has groped, attacked, or threatened a co-ed on campus. Oddly, the descriptions are graphically explicit: even though we are dealing with suspects — not the arrested. And so the appearance, size, and ethnic profile of the supposed attacker are provided in great, politically incorrect detail. One thing about liberalism: it takes care of its own.
Quietists of the State, Unite!
The quietist assumes that his vote for president does not matter and won’t in the state for the next century. He assumes that whom he votes against for governor will win, and that his legislator will either be opposed to everything he believes or, if he is not, will be equally as irrelevant — and yet in homage to the state, he keeps voting religiously and laughing about it with other quietists.
Quietists have become bystanders, now marginalized to be sure, but also convinced that the relevant ones are, in history’s cruel calculus, quite unhinged. I have a confession: I like the quietists of California. I see them every day. They keep chugging away — and their spirits keep me going.







It pains me to ask but, are you too, one the “quietists” that looks away?
I don’t think so soft, and there is clear evidence I am right. He takes one of the actions at which he is among the best. He describes accurately the problem and implies solutions.
Fred, I think you’re right. It’s just a depressing thought that the Golden State of my youth has become so tarnished. It’s ironic but just the other day I suggested to my twin brother that he might want to read the Professor. He really does take me back to another time. Thanks for bucking me up.
Higher taxes fixes nothing, Spending is the problem, and if Cali falls, other states will follow. Domino effect.
Agreed, except for Texas. We’re still desperately clinging to our oil, guns and religion, and we’re not quiet about it either. We’ve got a lot of liberal transplants trying to screw up our state too, but we tell them, hey, if your ideals were working so great for you, what the hell did you come here for? Why didn’t you STAY?
Fuzzy, They came to spread the poverty game.
Complicit in the death of many individuals and their society are the quiet ones who see the death of ethics and law but refuse to stop the slaughter…
They can’t, because they are the quiet minority. Or would you rather they protested with pitchforks in hand, be arrested an add to the already substantial California prison population? That’s Prof. Hansen’s point.
Dr. Hansen is not living, he is existing. If he is contect, so be it. However, life is a gift and worth living; I feel sorry for those who just exist as they have not tasted life’s potentials.
Dr. Hansen is not living, he is existing.
Boloney. Like the monks and philosophers who rode out the aftermath of the Roman empire, he’s providing incisive, real-time historical records of the slow-motion collapse of California under mindless leftism. He lives for us.
Those of us in other states who comment under defensive handles are taking our own baby steps towards anonymous quietism. Item: being a participant in certain of the arts, I see daily from my artistic Facebook ‘friends’ many savage declarations of hatred and derision for people and ideas whom I trust and admire – he is human slime being an example.
These are supposed intellectuals talking, if by ‘talk’ you mean sloganize, curse, express hatred, all with no supporting rationale nor data. It is not a debate, it is an incipient lynch mob. Yet those intellectuals would not question their support for human rights and diversity. One can practically infer the pressure building for a second civil war.
I disagree that Mr. Hanson is merely existing. He is a brave watcher and reporter, much like the American ambassador in “Fail Safe”, bravely watching and reporting the destruction around him as we listen horrified for the microphone in his telephone to melt. The screeching of said microphone warning the rest of us about our own possible impending doom.
California is a lost cause and only valuable as a cautionary tale about the excesses of the unchecked left, much like Michigan, D.C. and the other worker’s paradises around the world.
California should be used as a cudgel to beat liberalism/socialism into quiescence for it can never be killed. Not as long as envy is abroad in the world. Sorry for the rant.
Amen. The Quietists are selfish COWARDS.
I was in dowton LA on the day of the Rodney King Riots. One year to the day from that event my family lived in another western state. I am doing everything I can to make sure that this state does not become the next California. I am involved politically as well as in the community. My son went on to be an Eagle Scout and joined the Navy, my daughter has studied ballet in Europe, she speaks 5 languages now, and has graduated from college & found a great job. My bride of 30 years and I are still married. I’m not bragging. I’m saying leaving that place to its tragic destiny was the best thing I ever did, for me, for my family.
Dr. Hansen has fought the good fight. God bless him for it because he has done much more than most of the kalifornians, including many of my family, who simply are existing as long as they can until it is their turn to be today’s rape, murder, or car-jacking victim, while the state slowly robs them of their money for the mere pleasure of that pityful existence. He is a beacon of sanity in a vast land of unjustified tolerance and terminal mediocrity. May the angels protect him and his family.
There is no dis-honor in leaving the modern soddom & Gomorrah. I couldn’t change California so I left, like the refugees who fled Germany in the 1930′s, taking my very productive profession with me. I am making a difference here in my new home.
All I can say is it is okay to save yourselves and let California burn. If Dr. Hansen chooses to fight to the end then I feel sad for him, but so be it.
-LB
To your comments – I live in Minnesota and can honestly say I have hated California for almost 40 years….initially due to the 5 lanes of traffic and the appalling class distinctions.. rich vs poor… but now even more for what it has become. Good luck and don’t forget to turn out the lights.
The Tea Party Patriots and other Tea Party organizations are trying. What are YOU doing?
Once again Dr. Hanson is spot on. I am born and bred Californian with adult kids. It so saddens me to see the degrading of my state. We once had ronald Reagan leading this state, it was a place of promise and prosperity. Then we began to indulge in self destruction with Moombeam Brown the first time. He signed the bill allowing public unions to form. Unions own California now. We allowed liberalism, unchecked immigration, generous welfare state. It was the national joke that when they had undesirables in other states they bought a bus ticket for California. When we citizens voted that only citizens could attend our free schools , the judge just said too bad and we citizens lost. Every time we vote it ends up in court and we lose again. That is why we don’t have any faith voting, California crazy judges just void our vote. We spend 1.5 billion on illegals in California. We tax paying Californians provide free educations,health care, welfare, food stamps, snap, even advertising in Mexico how to get on food stamp programs all for non citizens. Now Brown signed that they can get drivers license. Next they will get to vote. The courts have cancelled out Californian votes, now we don’t matter and we know it. We are the host body, taxes are our blood sucking lice to pay Unions and non citizens. I am telling my sons to move out of California. It is Mexifornia without the charm.
Then we have the environmentalists, no oil drilling, no water for central valley,
See the state as a horse. It was vibrant and strong in its youth: performed good work and was loyal while you fed and cared for it properly. Then it got older, and was less capable of fulfilling the demands placed on it. But instead of getting a replacement, you kept up the demand on its services, so it aged even faster. When its work load got too great, you just let some things go undone; what had been maintained before now is in disarray. Then it died. No work was performed, and deterioration rapidly ensued. At this point, the only beneficiaries of the horse are the millions of maggots that eat out what is left of the carcass. This the the current state of affairs in California.
California: Eaten by the Hogs…
So I’m sitting here wondering: what did you do about the demands for moar munee that arrived in the mail? And if you refuse to cough it up, will they attach that amount against your property as a lien (acquiring interest and penalties)?
We’re all protesting the “fire fee” by sending in official complaints. of course we have to pay the tax or we’ll wind up fined and harassed. Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Assoc is on the case!
The names, and descriptions, are I am sure redacted in large part because the identities might cause uncharitable souls to conclude that maybe wide open borders to the south had consequences.
Dr. Hanson, I do not know if you will stay or go. I hope that you at least have a bug-out plan and somewhere to go to here in America. Likely within a couple of months [regardless of what happens with a presidential election] there will be civil violence; and almost certainly within a year. If things start looking tense, do not be in a major city, because they will be deathtraps.
Subotai Bahadur
That is one of the reasons why I have recently become a Quietist myself, having left Stockton (one of the greatest examples of the degradation of our beautiful state which VDH describes) to live in the Sierra foothills.
Hopefully, it won’t come to that.
I will continue to donate my money to those causes which seek to overturn the status quo which is destroying our state. I will continue to cast my vote, and continue to counsel those who would listen on the virtues of individual responsibility and self-reliance as the antidote to government dependency. I may not like the way it is governed, but I love my state.
As a co-refugee from urban (suurbia is a misnomer here) California, I commend you on your decision. The only solution I see is to split the state into at least two new ones. Not north and south, but east and west. The coastal areas are the problem; they should be allowed to go their own way. We should be called California, they could become Pacifica, the utopia on the edge of the continent.
In some ways you are spot on, but more than “the coastal areas” create insurmountable problems. Unless you consider Southern California coastal. Devolving into at least FOUR states would make the most sense, but will never happen. But we can dream.
Spot on! An East West split is the way to fix this.
Jeff (Subotai),
You give yourself away.
California is my home, and it is a fantastic place. California is bereft, not because of Californians, but because of legions of leftist whackos from our nation who’ve come here in droves and set up shop here. The much maligned 9th circuit court – nearly all of the justices are not from California. Nancy Pelosi – an Illinois transplant.
There are 53 counties in California and 53 electoral votes.
35 of the counties in California are solid red staters.
Look at the inane comments from Lake Wobegone Wisconsin… 5 lane freeways?! Class warfare?!
If you had a California on the east coast it would stretch from Jacksonville, FL to Boston, MA. Wrap your head around that. At it’s widest point it’s 770 miles wide. Wider than most states by nearly double. So what?
My point is that California is not made up of a like minded homogeneous people akin to the Borg. Neither is the Eastern Sea Board or the North along with the Deep South.
To fix California we need to divide it. Right now the leftists that flock to our coasts from every liberal berg in the country hold all the keys to the kingdom. They hold every hard working red blooded American living inland hostage. If we split the state, I reckon there’d be some 35 electoral votes up for grabs, a number equal to the state of Texas, all voting Red.
It’s easier for the rest of country to lump all Californians into a big pot and give up on the 35 electoral votes that automatically go to the popular communist scum bag on the ballot each year.
My life has always been more than the ambient temperature.
I live in Merced. I still have a scar from working in Selma.
What is your point?
Selma living can be fraught with peril, probably. Why are you so dense?
You’re welcome in Nebraska anytime. We have the worst weather in the country, which I infer from your essay may be inversely related to quality of life. As my very un-PC soils professor used to say, “Hard country makes hard men.”
You shouldn’t post that. You’ll have half the women of America rushing to Omaha and Lincoln.
I’m pretty sure he didn’t mean it that way. In any case, I live in Ord.
@JohnO…I’ve been to Ord and enjoy windsurfing Lake Calamus occasionally — small world, eh?
BTW: Nebraska has 2nd lowest unemployment in the nation at 4%, right behind North Dakota’s 3% while my home state of South Dakota checks in at 4.5%. Compared to California (49th @ 10.6%) we “Prairie Drifters” live recession-free.
Those who saw the writing on the wall left California long ago.
The remainder is Sodom on the Pacific. It will be the first state to burn and go under. It will not be the last.
And that is exactly why I’m getting out to a red state as soon as humanly possible.
When leaving means abandoning a 94 year-old mother or a 7 year-old granddaughter, the decision becomes more emotional than rational. CA is a hopeless mess, but there is a strange–perverse?–fascination in watching it unravel. The pain that will come will be exquisite to watch. It will be…liberating.
There are millions of us who are unwilling to leave because we have families here..elderly relatives and even some of us have jobs still. We vote in every election with little hope that those we put our faith in will be able to win and overturn the debacle that is now California. We HATE what happened to our home state; for many of us the only home we have ever known. It disgusts me, angers me and saddens me on a daily basis.
You are not alone. There are more of us than they think. Some day……….
The joke about Detroit is that those that could read, read the writing on the wall and left.
I left in the 1990′s. I blame baby boomers. Maybe I’ll come back after their stupid house of cards has imploded to help rebuild.
There are boomers in every State, so how do you justify your statement. The problem in CA is liberalism, plain and simple. And, it will crumble in the near future because even the rich will stop giving sometime.
The very rich, and the very poor will be the future. The middle class has been run out on a rail, there are no jobs, everything costs too much because of the sales tax, special gas, and a bunch of liberal clowns.
Someday, someday, we remnants of the middle class may stand and fight rather than flee.
A clear and prescient assessment of California and its future by and obviously tired and saddened Dr. Hansen. And I think his term “quietist” perfectly sums up the “lives of quiet desperation” of many Californians. But its been a long time in the making. I ran a company in the bay area in the early 1980′s and saw the beginnings of it then. I think it will not end well.
Great article, Dr. Hanson. California and the US are being run into the rabbit hole both financially and culturally, and the cocktail party crowd praises themselves for their generosity. Really?
For most of my life, I believed rational people wanted to know what is going on. I know now this isn’t true. My experience is many “rational people” prefer to stay inside their poorly informed comfort zones.
For example, I had an opportunity to throw in a question on the sixteen trillion dollar debt at my senior card group. (I am a retired accountant and calculated the average monthly “new debt” in the current and past five Congresses, really, because I wanted to KNOW). The calculations turned up alarming numbers.
So, I said to a northeastern liberal Catholic, Do you know how much money Washington is borrowing every month? She said no, Don’t tell me, and laughed and walked away. I am a mid-western Catholic, brought up frugal, and was raised to value financial security for those I loved, including my country. What is wrong with this lady?
Dr. Pat Santy has written an excellent article (Oct 2, 2012) about psychological coping in the fantasyland created by modern leftism. She is especially qualifed to write about leftists, as she is an expert on narcissism, particularly malignant narcissism. Here is her article:
THE VINDICTIVE TRUTH http://drsanity.blogspot.com/
This article raises the question of what people or cultures actually DO when their beliefs don’t match results. In my parents home, if a kid caused damage, he accepted responsibility. We did not go into a rage and blame some “other” for our mistakes. Dr. Santy fears that will happen when leftist policies tank the US.
Quietism may be the way to survive leftist rage after their policies fail.
Source: US Treasury Debt to the Penny, a web site operated by the Bureau of the Public Debt.
Here is how fast Washington is adding NEW US debt.
**** NEW DEBT ****
$103 Billion – Average PER MONTH, 112th Congress
$143 Billion – Average PER MONTH, 111th Congress
$63 Billion – Average PER MONTH, 110th Congress
$45 Billion – Average PER MONTH, 109th Congress
$48 Billion – Average PER MONTH, 108th Congress
$23 Billion – Average PER MONTH, 107th Congress
The US debt just passed $16 trillion. It was $8 trillion 6 years ago.
A retired accountant made a video which tries to answer the question: Why Can’t Washington balance the budget”. I recommend it. I checked the URLs. All accurate.
Google Hal Mason Youtube debt
Quietism may be the way to survive leftist rage after their policies fail.
No the only way to surive will be to have lots of food water and ammo. When the “policies” of the left fail there will be nothing short of a complete melt down of society and law.
Keep your powder dry.
You got that right!
140 million murdered (not in war), butchered, by failed policies of the looters from Lenin to Mao to Pol Pot. Quietism is no more than the silence of the lambs.
Go Galt now.
Go Galt now.”
Aleady working on it.
– live in Galt, California.
“Go Galt now”
and even that may not be enough. Think about “This year I got a letter from the state explaining that based on my income they “estimated” that I must have used the Internet to buy x-amount of things and therefore did not pay state sales taxes. Thus, they suggested that I should pay them around, say, $600.”
“suggested” is merely a euphemism for “or else” and there in is the rub. They have the legal ability to use force.
As they institute more and more fees, ‘estimations’ and taxes they will get less and less revenue and more and more desperate.
The right gets upset over the Cloward–Piven strategy (overload the welfare system to precipitate a crisis) but “going Galt” also overloads’ the welfare system to precipitate a crisis, but on our terms. I think this is the unstated reason that so many on the right are becoming “preppers”. They not only expect the system to fail dramatically, but are also positioning themselves to survive the failure in a way that the looters are not.
Creating their own ‘Galt’s Gulch’ as best they can.
The next 5 years will be interesting times.
In 2010 I received notice from California State Franchise Tax Board that if I didn’t pay my vehicle registration from 2008 and 2009 they were going to put a lien on my property in Arizona. Here’s the rub I had registered my vehicle in Sept 2007 in Arizona when I moved there. I sent proper notice to the DMV in California in Sept 2007. They acknowledged they had received the notice but tried the tough sh*t approach. I warned them that approach wouldn’t work as the next contact would be via an attorney. I had the attorney write them a nasty letter and they backed down.
“So, I said to a northeastern liberal Catholic, Do you know how much money Washington is borrowing every month? She said no, Don’t tell me, and laughed and walked away. I am a mid-western Catholic, brought up frugal, and was raised to value financial security for those I loved, including my country. What is wrong with this lady?”
They don’t take it seriously because it hasn’t affected them deeply . . . yet. These are not responsible adults. I wouldn’t even call them adults. They’re the Children of the Left, constantly in denial, because they don’t care to admit that the ideology they’ve built their life on is seriously flawed and ruinous, and will require lots of re-working. Oh, well, it’ll all be fine . . . somehow.
That DrSanity link was WELL worth the read for me, thanks. The discussion of ‘involuntary’ denial vrs ‘voluntary’ was educational. Thanks BRU
Californians who want to have someone else bail them out and want to avoid reality HAVE to vote for Obama. They think Obama can bail them out in the short term and avoid the painful realities of their decisions. I’m skeptical about this in general, but it’s fairly obvious that Romney would let them deal with the fiscal reality that is rapidly approaching.
@JohnO – definitely the worst weather in the country. The town where I grew up had a record high temperature of 113 and a record low of -41. The variance from summer to winter is enough to get rid of anyone who isn’t tough enough to deal with it.
I’m from California but I have lived in Nevada for over 40 years. California is done. Silicon valley should move to Texas. Maybe that would wake up the morons ruining things in California.
God no! Most of the employees of those companies are Liberals and aren’t capable of making the connection between their liberalism and the destruction of CA. We sure as heck don’t need them leaving CA and setting anther state on a path to ruin. CA voters shouldn’t be allowed to vote for 5 years if they relocate to a Red state.
I am with both of you. I moved to Nevada last year. Vowed I would not vote for anybody who mentioned Cali except as a “cuss word”. Visited my son in Austin and “smelled” the makings of a little Cali in the heart of Texas. Watch out Lone Star.
You are right about Austin! Unfortunately, Austin is Texas’ DC. But, so far, there is more of us than there is of them………and we are watching them to see how well our new Texas transplants fit into Texas culture!
Texas is 75% minority youth. Its a screwed as California in the long run.
You’re right, Houston’s gone to the dogs. The people that keep Houston alive mostly live in the neighboring counties, and vote a solid republican ticket. Houston would be in the crapper without us.
Amen!
I moved from California to Las Vegas (NV) in 2005, and it wasn’t long before I started noticing that a lot of the Californians I was moving away from had come along and brought their leftist ideas with them. First warning was a ballot proposition forcing all restaurants to be completely non-smoking.
Good idea. I moved from California (I’m a 3rd generation native) in 95. Live 4 years in Oklahoma where I met people with this crazy thing called common sense. I didn’t vote once. Then I moved to Virginia in 99 and voted for Gore (I know – I’m sorry, but Bush didn’t really sell himself well). So, 5 years is about right. My conversion to hard-core rightwing extrimist was complete after Bush’s election, though (the lefties went insane at his victory and quit them then and there – BEFORE 911).
And I’m proud to say that I’ve just convinced my mother to leave California and come live with me. This makes me very happy and at EASE! I’m going house hunting in the Shenedoah Valley this weekend!
California voters are getting exactly what they asked for (and deserve) – good and hard. As long as they never get a penny of Federal bailout money, I don’t care.
Well, some of us voters didn’t vote for this mess. We tried, but all the lefty transplants that have infested California since the 1960s have taken over.
The people who voted for this are now leaving the state and settling in other Western states – where they then vote for the same d@mn policies and types of Lefty politicians that destroyed California.
It would be nice to think that pariah states like CA and IL would be left on their own to recover. But the federal government, run by Lefties sympathetic to “the cause,” would undoubtedly bail them out for the sake of the “common good.” But there will never be enough money to satisfy their demands, and the cancer will spread, taking more and more states with it. As long as it’s “fair” . . . .
Victor, I say this in all sincerity: you need to buy a 5-10 acre farm near Moscow, put in some grapes, and teach occasional classes at the University of Idaho. You’d be happier, and safer, and the politics of the state wouldn’t make you crazy.
What you suggest is probably true but I never encourage anyone to leave California for fear they will migrate to my state and set about reinventing Ca.. Stay put Californians. You are getting what you deserve – even the quietists. Now we all wait for California to request a bail out from the rest of us. Redistributing the wealth mentality has assured a second term for Obama with California leading the way. Sorry Doc.
Sad thing for yours and every other state is that people with good values and strong work ethic still send their children to public school where they spend thousands of hours learning to be good socialists, looking to government to solve their problems and supporting leftist ideals. So while you laugh at the mess of California your inattention to the education of your youth means your state is on the same road to hell. You’re simply a few miles back.
You got that right. I live in California, but I’m raising my kids to be part of the solution, not part of the problem… by removing them from the public indoctrination system and doing it myself.
Should we in the heartland treat the deep blue extremities of our Republic as gangrenous limbs to be amputated?
YES.
Great article Dr. Hanson. As happens often, you articulate things I am feeling. I wonder, what is the final outcome of this cultural and political madness…
The end is near. I still remember a few years back when Californians were treated to the electrical power grid meltdown; rolling brownouts, no AC, etc. I was a bit perplexed by the ensuing bitching and moaning engendered by Californias non-existent energy startegy. One would have thought that the true eco believers would have celebrated the impending collapse of their electricity providers by getting on their bicycles, pedaling down to the coast and watching the whales copulate. Well, California is a nice place to fly over on the way to the Far East.
As I read Dr. Hanson’s essays about life in his liberal paradise I think back to my own experience. As a young man I decided to spend most of my life living in a reasonably well-managed and economically sound upper-Midwest small and rural town. This fall and early winter there will pictures in the local paper of the largest bucks taken as the deer season progresses. I hope to contribute. Late this summer the paper carried pictures of the various 4-H livestock class winners at the county fair. “How exciting!”, you say. In 2008 Obama received 29% of the local vote. He won’t do nearly so well this election. Who would want to live in such an “unenlightened” backwater? I am no sheltered “rube”. I have been in places in this world that most have not. I’ll stick with early decision and my hick-town in rural America. But please Californians, when the your entire mess collapses don’t come to the rest of us with a tin cup.
Sounds like paradise to me. I note that the lead guitarist for the original Jefferson Airplane, Jorma Kaukonen, now lives in Meigs County, Ohio, not far from the Ohio River, and has for 20 or so years. I grew in California, graduated from UC Berkeley with a “C” average (when C’s really meant something). There is not enough money to get me to move back.
I could almost see the glorious vistas in my mind. Just like the copper wire thievery and the attitude that these university systems exist to provide adult employment for those of a like mind. And with the anticipated Qualifications Frameworks acting as a gateway to future jobs, the university administrators believe they have a permanent annuity from a population needing the magic credential each time they wish to change jobs.
http://www.invisibleserfscollar.com/self-efficacy-cultural-proficiency-training-critical-reflection-and-change-agency-development/ is based on a California Tomorrow report from 2010 on what an equity vision for K-12 education looks like in practice.
Between this and gutting the nature of college work being pushed by this Administration’s Crucible Moment Report from January, the accreditation standards that gut the transmission of knowledge, and the Lumina Foundation’s Diploma Qualifications Profile that Arne Duncan is pushing, we are using an expensive K-16 process to create expectations without marketable knowledge and skills. That’s not just a California problem though. The education fiasco vision is both national and global through the UN.
And our window for catching on is narrow and brief. It is helpful though that VDH writes so well of the dream that was and the eminent nightmare without a course transformation.
Your secret can be found in those histories which you so dearly love. Pity our children are not directed to read them when young and impressionable.
What an age of narcissism we have before us!
So true, RJ. But rather than relinquish the education of our children to the state we should be directing it ourselves either through private school or home schooling. It is not enough to be educated citizens ourselves, we must educate our children as well and this includes protecting them from the statist indoctrinatio they receive in public schools.
My dear cyberhero, VDH…your essay reminds me of the question asked to the Valley Girl:
“Which is closer, Fresno or the Moon?”
“Tsk, duh, I can SEE the Moon!”
For the victim/entitlement class they can SEE the “free stuff”, not the torrent of destruction that the slacker lifestyle creates. The patronage system of Chicago on steroids in California has cities going bankrupt, the state collapsing in a heap. Union kickbacks through sweetheart deals that choke the economy, an entertainment industry openly in love with radical extreme leftism including murderous dictators, and an indoctrination system of education from cradle to the jobs graveyard.
An open secret of an underground society, illegal and often a breeding ground for an army of violent criminals.
Your “quiet” person, I see in a bunker mentality. The radical extremists will slander them as an Archie Bunker mentality…so, they hide and hope that they can get by unnoticed. They don’t make waves. They don’t resist. They don’t fight City Hall. They just want to be left alone and live their lives not bothering anyone.
Self-reliant, self-protective, self-preservation being their strongest motivation. The most they will do…is take on a handle…and comment on a “Resistance Blog”. And, on some days…they feel like a coward for not doing more.
“Coward” good man? No. Please. Those of us for whom life’s horizon draws nearer know the truths underlying these words:
” God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
The courage to change the things I can,
And the wisdom to know the difference.”
And you must know that your participation in this comment section comforts others who feel and think as you do. It helps that we quietest know that we are not so alone.
Catherine, we are not alone, there are untold millions of us. But until we “organize’ we are simply individuals, afraid of the mob and intimidated by the gangster government that dotes on the mob.
‘ . . . But until we “organize” . . . ‘
Yes, Common Tater.
We will form countless legions . . . at the polls . . . on November 6.
Changing your name to “Hanson-Sanchez” looks like the only answer, if you insist on sticking it out.
JohnO #7
I had a friend who said, reference living in Grand Forks ND: “40 below keeps the riff-raff out.”
I work in a vanishing CA industry: aerospace. Almost without exception, folks I interact with day-to-day are “quietists”, and have a dim view of “community organizers”, unless they are little league coaches, troop leaders, etc.
“What’cha gonna to do when the well runs dry?
You’re gonna sit right down and cry.
What you gonna do when I say bye-bye
All you gonna do is dry your eye
I’m walkin” Fats Domino
Well, the California well isn’t QUITE dry, yet, but the trend is NOT our friend—maybe Mexifornia is about to resemble raisins.
I’ve been contemplating moving back to the much better weather, as in my retirement the deteriorating body extremities get colder in more months than before. Why, I almost decided to go to Brownsville, Texas, due to its semitropical weather—until I checked the hurricane records for that area.
Clearlake, California is beaconing mightily. I bet there are still a few places where retirees can go, and be mostly unaffected by the leaches in Sacramento.
San Diego, where I lived from 1997-2000, would be the best, but it’s so expensive.
I checked out Riverside and San Bernardino, but there’s still the fact that it’s where smog flows, and almost half the population is already Hispanic.
The rich liberals on the coast and in university areas like Stanford tend to be liberal. My guess is that the people who leave California are mostly Caucasian and those entering are Hispanic. And, we all know the latter are heavy Democratic Party voters. Hence, the hammer lock of the jackass vote.
Also, there’s the hoary “problem” of size. Why, even in Oregon, there was a movement to separate the south from the north and make two states. And, the Golden “state”?
How many Rhode Islands could it make? Federalism is the answer—de facto or de jure, breaking up is the way to go. It’s turtles, all the way down—and up.
There are, indeed, MANY Californias!
It’s the weather, stupid!
Maybe I’m biased, but it sure seems to me that California, like Florida, and other warm places, will always be attractive to retirees.
California, here I come!
“AND THEY’RE OUT THERE HAVING FUN, IN THE WARM CALIFORNIA SUN.”
Old rock n roll song
I’m retired. I moved to CA 2-3 years ago and just love it. I say to myself: “I wish I had done this years and years ago.” Yet I know, if I had, I would’ve lost 50-60% of the value of any condo I bought before 2008. As you can imagine, I especially like the fact that CA property taxes are based on selling price. In NYC, property taxes have tripled since 2001 and have no basis in reality.
I believe one of the best decisions my wife and I ever made was in the early 1990′s when we had good job offers to return to California (from the East) with our kids, and instead we accepted positions in Texas. Twenty years later I thank my lucky stars I’m in Texas.
Realizing there are still millions of good people left in California, I nonetheless have a huge future concern for my own children.
There is a bigger problem with California than just California.
I’ve watched a once friendly and fiscally sound Colorado turned into a cesspool of liberal thought by the “migrants” of California looking for the better life, never recognizing their bringing their failed California ideas with them. It was tolerable when it was Boulder. Now, the stench has permeated the state.
I suspect the same thing has happened in Nevada, New Mexico and Montana.
And California is big enough that it could screw up a lot of states, guaranteeing an Obama for President for a hundred years.
they’re their…
The propositions this November will set our course for the next decade.
If the people vote in higher income taxes for the “rich” many of them will leave, and the deficit will grow.
If the people allow unions to continue taking money from unwilling union members in the state’s bureaucracies, it will be lights out. Jerry Brown signed into law 25 years ago the bill that allowed this legal money laundering, and now he is presiding over the one-party-ruined state the law enabled.
Just as I tire of hearing someone complain of being sick but won’t get his rear end off the couch to go to the doctor, so too do I have little sympathy for the ‘quietists’ who complain but won’t take the steps necessary to remove themselves from the people who are making them complain. They can leave, but they choose to stay. And by doing so, they’re making a statement that, for all of their complaining, life in California really isn’t that bad.
Steve – you are aware that many of us are too broke to leave, or have family that we are unwilling to abandon here – because they don’t have the money, or are too old ect.
Don’t judge us until you’ve walked in our shoes.
We live in a very rural, sparsely populated and off the beaten track part of California. Fortunately we are also out of the Road Warrior culture’s beaten track. If it weren’t for the fact that our business is tied to the land and our client’s properties (wells and water systems) and our ages (no spring chickens here) we have remarked that we would sell everything in a heartbeat and move out into a state of sanity. Texas, Nevada anywhere but California. The weather just isn’t worth it anymore.
In the meantime we will be the quiet ones. Keeping our heads below the foxhole, do our business, water our fruit trees and take care of the garden.
Any young person or young family that has the opportunity to get out….do it and do it NOW. California isn’t the “Golden State” anymore. It is just burnt toast.
Friday as I was driving north from Del Mar on the Coast Highway, I told myself, “Enjoy those vistas. It’s just about all you have left.” I almost wept when I read this, Dr.Hanson. I’ve called myself a cocooner, but I guess I’m a quietist.
The 2010 census was the first one in eight decades which California did not gain a seat. California has been losing middle class voters for some time now. In the mid 90s I read an item about the moving van companies have a problem with balancing their loads as far more customers were using them to leave California than were moving in. U-Haul, on the other hand, had the opposite problem. Now poorer Americans are staying out, too. Indeed the people from other parts of America who still move to California are mostly from the urban centers of other deep blue states. In the meantime many from northern California have moved to Washington state and Idaho while those from Southern California have headed for Nevada and Texas. Note that three of those states do not have an individual income tax.
The problem is the current operating system, the Evil Media Empire.
If Romney wins, the Evil Media Empire will disfunctionalize everything he thinks, says and does.
On the other hand, if Obama wins a second term, the Evil Media Empire will glorify everything he thinks, says & does.
Perhaps the only solution is to let Obama win, then the world will have large, uncontrollable conflagrations: War, inflation, sovereign debt crises, poverty, etc. More of the same, except exponentially bigger and more bad.
The question is: Will the last four years of pre-Armageddon under Obama, and the likely next four years of wakey-waky-Armageddon-come-now … get rid of the Evil Media Empire’s current operating system? (And shepherd light!)
How many times do you have to flush, to flush down the drain this Evil Media Empire?
What good, or more likely bad events… can unscrew the media brains in NYC, DC and LA that are screwing everybody?
I was going to write a long post about my experiences in what used to be one of the Ag-Industrial capitols of California but I think I’d rather go for a walk. I’ll just say as I have many times,
“People get the government they deserve.”
And I don’t care. Well into my 70′s. Home paid for, Last safe neighborhood in town. No grandchildren. One kid out of state. One here voting for the pols who create the problems. Both successful. It’s not really a question of quiet acceptance, I just don’t care what happens to the folks who did this.
Dr. Hanson has indicated that he doesn’t like Hegel, but his quietism is the very epitome of the Stoic self-consciousness described in The Phenomenology of Spirit, a consciousness capable of and retreating into abstract thinking while living under a crushing tyranny as a slave with no hope of liberation. The sad truth is that, at this moment of history, such quietism may be the only rational response for anyone who is not willing to risk his life in open rebellion.
Or, perhaps, Epicurus would be better. While he was a retreating wallflower, his followers were not. It’s an aggresive, demanding philosophy.
Dr. Hanson doesn’t strike me as a man who regards pleasure, even refined pleasure, as the highest good. I haven’t noticed him applying a hedonic calculus to persons, things, or events. Military virtue, family tradition, a sense of propriety: these he has praised. Now he is demoralized because too many of his countrymen have abandoned them, preferring instead a dole of bread and circuses. They may not be seeking pleasure as Epicurus understood it, but they merit the pejorative derived from his name.
A good try, but you know little of Epicurus.
Or, to put in another way, the “pleasure” you speak of, is self-defined. Would it “pleasure” you, to restore America? To restore the Republic?
How about property rights?
Family values are not “pleasurable”?
Remember, Epicurism, was the geatest obstacle to the emerging Christianity. They didn’t give a crap what anybody thought.
Watching the tone and tenor of Hanson’s articles over time has me convinced he either eagerly awaits California’s Cloward-Piven event or will eventually have to become an emigrent. Today he marks time like I imagine the majority of German citizens did during the war, a quietist, disapproving.
To begin at the good Doctor’s beginning:
Democracy is a process, not a condition.
True the label is often applied to the conditions necessary and sufficient for the process, but the process remains what it is.
The conditions resultant from the process are determined, and vary, by the nature of the social order in which the process occurs.
The nature of the social order derives from the forces which formed and maintain it and from the human interactions within it that are changing it.
The good Doctor’s recitals of the effects of those human interactions over the years provides us with insights into the conditions the process generated, historically and currently, where that process has occurred.
In a few years the problem will solve itself. One by one CA cities are going bankrupt and dumping their union contracts. (LA will, just after Villagarosa leaves office.) Then the new GOP Congress will pass a bill enabling states to go bankrupt, and CA will do so, since the GOP Congress isn’t going to vote a bailout. Those union employees can say sayonara to their gold plated retirements, the affirmative action crowd can be laid off, and the Mexican-American majority can start demanding that their kids be actually taught something.
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.
Edmund Burke
People crushed by laws, have no hope but to evade power. If the laws are their enemies, they will be enemies to the law; and those who have most to hope and nothing to lose will always be dangerous.
Edmund Burke
Great, but sad, article. As a native Californian who grew up in a, thankfully, conservative enclave (La Mirada) and who lived in the state a second time as a pastor in a not-so-conservative city (Oxnard), I marvel at the self-destruction. As a Christian I see it this way: no state has been more blessed by God than California–with natural beauty and weather–but no state has been so cursed by man. Californians should be first in line to praise God for his blessings; instead they throw away moral laws and decency.
I believe so-called reasonable Californians to be self-indulgent cowards. Wacko Socialists and Communists have taken over their beautiful state and they do nothing. They seem to think nothing of their children growing up in slavery, not to mention their affect on the nation and my personal freedom here in Florida.
There is nothing so sad as a slave who believes he is free. The apathy of the non-wackos in California have caused the state to run out of control. I say let them burn.
When I moved to Santa Clara Valley in late 1969, there was not yet a Silicon Valley. After 10 years of suffering the knowitall VC wannabees, I moved my firm to CO and got immediate funding. Unfortunately, CO has had such an influx of escaping Californicators it’s now a Blue state, and I’ve retired to FL.
In 2000, there were over 12,000 venture capital firms. Now, fewer than 800.
These guys were the stewards of the margin.
This is the Curly effect. The government becomes so obnoxiously leftist that conservatives flee the state leaving even more leftist to vote themselves more power and goodies. We need to reverse the trend and have people move back in. And we need to mock the California dumbos every chance we get.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111903480904576510794280560566.html
I live on the edge of the coastal enclaves, and life is good. Restaurants are full, people are buying new cars. If you leave the house with a window open facing the street, nothing is likely to happen.
Why are our taxes so high? Mismanagement at the state level, and the unsustainable burden of educating and providing healthcare for millions of immigrants. They were not wanted when they came – you don’t need 10 million amigos to pick tomatoes and grapes, and our Republican officials were just as complicit in letting them in as were their Democratic counterparts.
Taxes are high here, too, because California taxpayers send out maybe $1.20 in federal income taxes for every $1 the feds spend here. The difference goes to subsidize red states like Mississippi, helping them overcome child poverty, since they can’t all be Honey Boo Boo.
Dream on…you’re a magnet for an oncoming fiasco. You just don’t see how near it is, yet.
Typical Californian too. No wonder it’s 49th in education.
1. Moon-beam is not “progressive”. The last thing he want’s is progress, and he’s doing whatever he can think to do to impair progress.
2. They’re not “liberal”. They died in the wool leftists, which is to say
3. they’re REDs; not blue, red.
BTW – the comparison of CA 12% income tax as higher than Hawaii and Oregon understates California’s true rank: Oregon has a high income tax but NO sales tax. (I don’t know about Hawaii.)
When I left Hawaii in 2004, the sales tax was 4.1%. However, everything was taxed. All food, services, doctor and lawyer fees–everything. I figured that the actual sales tax was closer to 9%. Schools ranked 49th or 50th. I’m back in my native CA now, for better or worse. It’s still a beautiful state. What’s killing us is the inordinate number of illegals. Since there’s no voter ID law here, I blame them in large part for the liberal, left-wing government and high unemployment we’re stuck with.
You’ll be happy to know that the Gov. just signed a same day registration for voting law. I won’t live long enough to ever see a true conservative govenor.
Leave? And where would I go? Is Phillip II still ruling Spain? What others do not realize is that California is not just some inherently “soft” place. As strange as it sounds, the Los Angeles area is my family’s quasi ancestral home – we’ve been here that long. It was a desert. Now it is an obnoxious sprawl full of pigs. Oh, and the north? Ha Ha. Same pigs – with twice the condescension and half the looks. We have lived nowhere else for over 300 years – and it is soo bad that when I saw the movie “2012″ and watched LA collapse into the ocean ….i was glad.
I’m a PhD student at a marquee university in California. I’m getting out of this state ASAP.
Dr. Hanson,
If you’re looking at Silicon Valley and seeing it ‘booming’, a little perspective is in order:
Ignore the singular exception of Apple for a moment, and drive thru the industrial parks in Santa Clara, San Jose, Fremont and Milpitas. You will see nearly endless stretches of ‘for lease’ signs in front of long deserted office buildings.
This is because Silicon Valley has become the 21st century equivalent of the old Ohio-Pennsylvania-Indiana Rust Belt of the 1970′s, when steel mills, glass works and other heavy industry enterprises that built America in the first half of the 20th century went bust, their futures buried under an avalanche of regulation, costs, unionization, and utterly inept & craven management. Today, if you’re in the microchip business, you’re quietly transferring your facilities to Shanghai and Bangalore. The manufacturing and testing plants left in the 80′s and 90′s to go to the Phillipines, Taiwan and Malaysia; now it’s being followed by all the engineering departments, including design engineering. What’s left in America (and that will be gone in the next decade as well) is executive management, marketing, sales and finance. And you can forget about chip startups that created the likes of Intel, Broadcom, Marvell, Xilinx and LSI; any new startup activity is now overseas. Even Apple will be taken down by this – they don’t manufacture a thing, but design their fabulous gadgets and have Chinese manufacturing services companies build it for them. However, without manufacturing know-how, you lose your ability to design properly for performance, cost and quality because the feedback loop is interrupted and distorted. Hence, you get Foxconn now making Apple knockoffs at much lower prices and selling them overseas. You even get outright theft, as Huawei has risen to challenge Cisco in Networking servers and routers by outright stealing their HW and SW technology en masse.
The only ‘tech’ growth has been in the Facebook/Google/Groupon etc firms which make web pages that attract people to their posted ads. Despite what the morons in the media say, that’s not ‘high tech’, but the new media and advertising companies of the 21st century. They don’t hire engineers – they hire marketeers from Procter and Gamble, Quaker Oats or Clorox, and advertisers from Dentsu, Omnicon or Saatchi.
In short – the technology future of the nation has been exported. We’re not going back to the moon, and we’re not going to invent the successor to silicon that will drive microchip technology into the 22nd century.
It’s over. All we’ll have for our grandchildren are stories, like those that the quietists in 1st century BC Athens had about Achilles, Theseus, Hercules, and even Themistocles and Leonidas. Memories of greatness and achievement, fading away in the growing distance and gathering dusk, while the grandchildren get bored hearing these stories and spend their energies avoiding math and science like the plague, twitting each other on their gadgets, and dreaming that one day they’ll be a music star or famous actor.
Interesting comments, Stallion.
Are you familiar with Bill Whittle and his video posts “Stratosphere Lounge”?
Whittle is in the process of attempting to make a movie wherein a “bottle with a message”, i.e. Western Civilization… is thrown into space… while the Earth devolves into Progressive Chaos and Endless Decline.
Funny thing is, he is such a cheerleader for the private space industry (moving from Mojave to Texas and other havens) that he hopes his movie-making funds the actual thing. Aurora is the name of the idea/movie.
And it could happen, under the radar of Our Stupid Media Prog/Frogs/Drones.
Thanks, RWB :-)
I am a huge fan of Bill Whittle and have been for the better part of a decade. I need to look up his Stratosphere Lounge stuff on Youtube, just haven’t taken the time to do it.
I’d agree unreservedly with Whittle on his support for private efforts to get into space (Rutan and Branson pop to mind first thing) and am certain that if the MSM does observe any major successes in that sector, they’ll want to see it suppressed, lest the spirit of free enterprise and freedom in general infect any of today’s youth and serve as a source of ‘incorrect thought’ that interferes with the full, mindless acceptance of and acquiesence to progressive theology……..
Great analysis. What you left out were the people telling their grandchildren about how they barely made it out alive when the collapse of civilization occurred.
Thanks for the analysis and update, Stallion. I was also curious about why Silicon Valley would be booming under such onerous California taxes and regulations. One explanation that I heard which makes some sense is that state and local taxes are deductible under federal taxes. In effect, federal taxes partly subsidize high state and local taxes, all over the country, making it easier for Progressive-dominated states to inflict punishment on their citizens.
Stallion’s observations about the business climate in Silicon Valley is correct based on my eyes. I working within walking distance of San Jose’s airport and our cluster of Class A office buildings are about half empty. Our firm was able to double its footage at half the rent recently.
Yes, the raw industrial and business muscle has weakened in Silicon Valley. Partially, that’s due to the basic IT and microchip businesses being played out. The marginal return on investments in IT and the like has shrunk. Does anyone NEED a new computer program or better computer to make more money for their business? Every application that our corporate IT people try to distribute is not worth the effort to learn and use. Would a doubling of the MIPS on a chip do you any good?
Just like the steel industry started as a boom and ended in the Rust Belt, all technologies have a cycle. Silicon Valley’s best days are behind it.
I respectfully disagree. True, bulk CMOS has run its course and is about to hit the ‘last node’ – if I were to guess, it will be 10nm. However, there are ways to get vastly more computing power by moving beyond stacked bulk CMOS into vertically stacked transistors, and getting further astounding improvements from things like carbon nanotubes and, eventually, quantum level computing. And one doesn’t need to simply drive for speed, density and lower power: plastic transistors hold incredible promise. In fact, this is the key: expanding applications beyond the current consumer electronics dead end (and it is indeed a dead end – the human eye and ear can handle only so much information, and we’ve pretty much reached that with today’s HDTV’s and set top boxes, so there’s nothing left with those systems except to reduce cost and perhaps cannibalize each other, as well as the home gateways.) All the above mentioned technologies need to be taken out of the lab and experimented with in applied research for medical, textile, industrial, automotive, sensor and other applications. The trick is to make all that experimentation CHEAP, so that failure isn’t so crippling. And there are ways to do that – except with all the engineering activity moving to China and India and the manufacturing base already in the Far East, it will be THERE that the new inventions and applications happen.
I am less quiet now, having joined a federal court lawsuit against our local sheriff who does not believe otherwise quiet citizens should be able to have a license to carry a gun…
A quietist here. Another brilliant essay that captures it perfectly. Leaving California has been a dream of mine for some time but it isn’t so easy. Gotta house, kids, family in the area, etc.
Quietist is a perfect word for it, a mere mention of my LIbertarian leanings or a dislike/distrust of Obamanation and I’m shouted down, ostracized and pushed out. I once had to leave a job because it became impossible to get work done with the overwhelmingly Liberal team with which I worked.
During the run-up to the election of ’04, one fellow was asked by HR to remove a Bush/Cheney button from his cubicle because it was controversial and incendiary. No mention of the dozens of cubes littered with Kerry/Edwards shite. Insane.
I’m always tempted not to vote because as the good Doctor states, its depressing to lose every time in every race or proposition. I would LOVE to live amongst folks that share my values but thats a good time off yet.
Geez, that’s horrible. I hate to tell ya’that I live in one of the reddest counties in one of the reddest states (SC). Moved here from NM–another red state gone blue thanks to Californians and massive immigration.
You do know that Sun Microsystems was acquired by Oracle in 2010.
–
A nice, sad elegiac article. It is the mood of our times.
I am one of your quietists.
The turning point came ten, twenty years ago. The first sign was the legislature freezing solid, unable to act. Now that has moved to the Federal level, California always shows the way.
But the next move is as history shows, they will act, to make things worse.
I can carry on at great length with my own private analysis of things, but it still nets out to what it does, a close-up view of the collapse of an empire, much of it long since written in the collapse of previous empires.
How often to we hear that the crazed killer was such a quiet person? The pendulum will swing back, as it always has, and a lot of very angry quiet folks will be taking out their frustrations in very unacceptable ways. Think of the Michael Douglas movie, “Falling Down,” on a state wide scale.
#7 JohnO
Never going to live in California, and I’m trying to convince my daughter to move back from California to this country. But I will never move to Nebraska, or set foot in there again. Because I was not a White Anglo-Saxon Protestant or Catholic I had to carry a gun in high school Hastings, Nebraska. For comparison, I’ve been in southern Mississippi and Florida and had no anti-Asian hostility directed at me.
#15 Ceteris Paribus
Yes.
#37 Laurent
That is the optimistic scenario, and depends on successfully removing Obama from office. All money bills, constitutionally, arise in the House. The Republicans, but not Conservatives, control the House. Despite that, we have not had a constitutional budget for 4 years, the last two under a Republican Speaker. And this regime has shown no reluctance to rule by Executive Order or to go outside the law, especially to bail out supporters with taxpayer money.
If Obama is defeated in the election, and actually leaves office, a Romney presidency may not bail out California; but it will take the full force of the Conservatives in Congress to overcome the pressure to do so from the Democrats and Institutional Republicans.
But that is our only chance.
Something that may be possible to limit the future options of the Left in California would be Glenn Reynolds’ suggestion to require the movie/TV [and by extension news] industry to conform to normal corporate tax rules and accounting procedures. After all, why should they avoid paying their “fair share”. Remove their special tax preferences. If they go TANGO UNIFORM, so much the better.
Yeah, they would scream bloody murder. But they cannot be any more active enemies of the country than they are now, or enemies of any non-Leftist governing institution. And by putting them on an even financial footing with the rest of the country would reduce their immunity to the consequences of their past choices, would reduce their ability to fund anti-American initiatives, and would reduce their undue influence on the governance of California.
Subotai Bahadur
I guess I’m a quietist, although before reading this article I didn’t think of myself that way. My plan is to relocate from California to a rural area in another state among mostly white folks (unfortunately Liberal/Leftist but cowardly dumb jerks) which should be somewhat safer than US cities with its minorities encouraged by the entitlement culture to go on the prowl against, what else, whites. The media is trying to hide the escalating race war (the fact of it is there if you look for it) while at the same time encouraging it in every way they can.
So I’ve given up; don’t vote; my friends here are all leftist jerks. California, like the US, like the rest of the West, is on its death march, and I’m retiring to watch the great spectacle, the collapse of the West, the great debt super cycle collapse. Those that remain will get what they voted for, what they deserve – they asked for it. Many that we know will lose everything before this drama has run its course near the end of this decade.
I am told to be a good member of society, to try to help, get involved, campaign, vote. But you can’t help a people determined to be stupid, to make every possible mistake, that hate themselves, that support by their actions their enemies and self-destruction. They can have it, and I will not be their victim.
Can I step out of character for a moment and act a bit…uncivilized? Jerry Brown and Darrell Steinberg have their heads up their a$$e$!!! They are living in a socialist utopian fantasyworld and bringing the whole State of CA down with them. This is why democracy is dangerous, it allows the citizenry to vote away their liberty.
I like the quietists of California. I see them every day. They keep chugging away — and their spirits keep me going.
I wouldn’t count on their their numbers remaining stable. A person can only take so much before they finally throw in the towel.
Coming from a childhood in Southern California, I remember KNX… the L.A. radio news station; and the three main TV stations: CBS, ABC and NBC along with the PBS broadcasts.
All of them cheerleaders for the hidden Progressive Way of Enslavement. All of them responsible (along with the loathed L.A. Times) for mind enslavement of 30 some million souls.
All of them boasting that no matter how many times the Titanic backs up and rams into the iceberg of reality at full speed, no lives will be lost, the ship of state will not sink and curses upon the passengers who dare leave early.
The powers that be into mind control will not reward early-warners, only stone them as heretics of the worst kind. Antebellum Southern Aristocrats have nothing on their modern-day equivalents in the editorial halls of the L.A. Times, CBS, MSNBC, ABC, PBS. The Earth has never seen such mass enslavement, nor probably ever will again… as the lockdown slavery-of-mind California elites have on their state, their nation and much of the world.
What kind of Civil War shall end this slavery of thought?
The only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.
Edmund Burke
When everything goes broke, and the cities are no longer viable due to shortages of food/water/heat, then there will be an exodus. All the assorted varieties of marginally viable humans will pour out of the steel and glass mausoleum and invade the countryside.
You better have lots of ammo.
We saw this unfold in Houston after Hurricane Katrina. The scum fled New Orleans and brought their gangs, drugs, and other sundries with them. Fortunately, they now think twice about looting and home invasions here, after finding out the hard way that a lot of Texans are gun owners.
After Katrina and the gracious people of Texas decided to take in a large number of the “refugees”…( which I’m sure they’ll never make that offer again! )
I saw the same thing in Houston. Looking around for a hotel room, I passed by Marriotts, Hiltons and other High end normally wonderful hotels.
Windows all open, clothes, laundry, bath towels all hanging out of the windows flapping in the breeze….the “residents” hanging out of the windows, howling and throwing things down to their buds on the ground….the lobbies were over run with screaming, shouting and the “residents” running around like uncaged buffalo just tearing the place up.
You can be a Conservative based on your beliefs.
You are only a Patriot however, based on your _actions_.
What actions have you taken, this year, to be a Patriot?
Consider the gauntlet thrown down.
FINANCIAL SUPPORT in 2012
$10 monthly donation to Capitol Resource Institute (California Family Value political watchdog) – CHECK
$10 monthly donation to NumbersUSA – CHECK
$5 monthly subscription to PJTV – CHECK
$10 monthly contribution to Declaration Entertainment
$10 monthly donation to Tea Party Patriots – CHECK
$25 to James O’Keefe / Project Veritas for every great undercover journalism operation – CHECK
$20 to Elizabeth Emken (running against Diane Feinstein)
$20 to Nick Popaditch (USMC Gunny running against Susan Davis – (D) CA)
$103 to Mitt Romney
$500 to TruetheVote
$500 to Tea Party Patriots
ONLINE ACTIVISM
PJMedia posts – CHECK
Facebook posts – CHECK, including selective challenges to a few Democratic friends/family.
Twitter activism – various notes
NumbersUSA email/fax action to elected officials – CHECK
REAL LIFE ACTIVISM
Tea Party Rally attendance – CHECK
Local Tea Party Rally booth manning – CHECK
Local Tea Party planning meetings – CHECK
- Engaging in lots of conversations in day to day life.
- Encouraging every one to do more than they have in the past, whatever their level.
- Political/conservative bumper stickers on my car. Signs in my yard.
Next weekend I am getting on a bus and spending my entire weekend walking precincts for Mitt Romney in another (battleground) state. I hope to devote two more weekends prior to the election.
Everything I have mentioned here, with the exception of a few one time donations, and a few signs in my yard in 2008, are brand new for me since 2010. I admit to having been asleep for decades, and I am trying to make up for lost time.
We can’t sit and lament that “someone needs to do something”. WE are the someones. WE get to be the persons doing something. In that process we become real live Patriots.
I don’t have many good things to say about the left, but I will begrudge them this. They worked hard. They didn’t just sit around and whine about not having tyrannical power to dictate to us how we should run our lives. They went out and fought for it, tooth and nail, at every school board meeting, every newspaper column, every snarky and self-congratulatory personal conversation, every election, every bumper sticker, every sneaky insertion into school curriculums, every self-loathing Hollywood movie, every stolen vote and fraudulent registration, every corrupt back-door deal union arrangement, and every compromised MSM journalist. They are tireless, and they won’t back down simply because we shine a light on them and say “I see you, and I know you are doing unethical things!” They have to be stopped, they have to actually be prevented from having power over us. They will not give it up simply because we have made our concerns apparent. Our best course of action is to wake up our fellow citizens who are asleep (people like I was), and get them to vote at a minimum, and even better get them involved too.
I’m not quite as involved as you, but I donate, challenge stupidity, write letters to the editors, etc. As a result, I’ve lost friends and treasury but I do not plan on going down quietly. I am a Californian.
Nomination for “Post of the Year”! Early contender for “Post of the decade.”
Listen folks! We have to give either time, talent or treasure. You can’t give time, then give treasure or talent or vice versa. Or give all three. I doesn’t have to be much but just get started.
If you are already working, kudos to you. If not, join us, it has many rewards and you can make a difference.
I recommend donating to Senator Jim DeMint’s Senate Conservatives Fund. I have been donating for 3 years. In 2010 he supported 5 conservative candidates who won. Now he is supporting 9 conservative senate candidates in this election. 100% of your donation will go to the candidate(s) you select.
“The state employee is now entrepreneurial: without a certain number of traffic tickets written, without a certain number of new fees dreamed up, salaries and benefits dry up.”
I am greatly uplifted when I finally see that an influential person from the center/right is finally saying this out loud. Thank you, Perfesser, and don’t stop now, but pour it to them.
It’s time to take the gloves off and cast aside the niceties. These government workers are doing exactly what you describe, not just in CA but in a lot of other states as well. Regulations are being passed which do nothing for the public or for the employees of businesses but which guarantee income for state workers and plugged-in rent seeking “private” businesses which sell goods and services for regulatory compliance.
Romney was dead-on correct with his comments about the 47%. More than anything else this election is about the public sector declaring war on the private sector – acting, at last, their intention to enslave the productive private sector using the full force of the police power of the state and acting to make permanent their unassailable income stream security by whatever means are necessary. They are about to become what they have desired since the 1930′s – a permanent, condescending clerisy using the police, the courts, and threats of economic destruction to individuals and families to extract the wealth necessary to keep the guaranteed government checks a’comin, damn the consequences to the rest of the nation.
For a long time now the government worker has told himself that he is our ruler and not our servant. If Obama is reelected that will likely become permanent.
I was gratified to see that revelation as well.
It has seemed to me that cities, counties, etc. have begun to use traffic enforcement as a revenue generating tool, rather than for any purpose of public safety.
Witnessed a highway patrol officer calmly writing a traffic ticket to a motorist, while on the other side of the median, a young father stood with his wife and two children watching their family car go up in smoke. I guess there was no financial motive in helping them out.
Quietism is the handmaiden of Fascism. Nothing to be respected in that.
Easy to say when it isn’t your property getting damaged, your car getting keyed or your job on the line.
I find I can do quite a bit, without subjecting myself to abuse, primarily through donating to candidates and the Tea Party and attending rallies. But engaging in arguments with the liberal haters that live here? It’s like arguing with a 2 year old.
I will say this, in ’08 this area of 5 million plus was littered with Obama signs and stickers. Hardly any this go around. That’s something at least.
This is, quite simply, a wonderful article, even given Prof. Hanson’s exemplary standards. I may print it and frame it.
Thanks, Prof!
People need to realize that, at some point, the system will collapse. What’s happening now is the same thing that was happening in Rome around 450 AD and the Soviet Union in the late 1980′s.
One of the clearest indications of our decline is that the flying public tolerates theft of their property and molestation of their children by the TSA at the nation’s airports.
When things finally do implode, it’s going to get very, very ugly.
This article hits home. I few years ago we thought of moving to Carson City, Nevada. The people are nice and it is close to home. But we started thinking about the whole picture. The track the country is on points to high energy costs with regular energy/water shortages and hyperinflation. So where do we want to fight the lack of heat and high prices? We decided on the foothills of California. We have moderate weather and a long growing season. We own our home and have friends and family nearby. I am not a quietest because I am hoping to slow down the disaster I see coming. But this disaster is not just my beautiful State but my entire Country.
Every time I read VDH on this subject I grow very saddened by descriptions of the central valley. Although I grew up in Illinois, one of my Aunts taught for 32 years very near him in the little town of Dinuba, Tulare Co. I spent much time in the area in the summers of the 50/60s and know the area well–the towns of Reedley, (where I used to play tennis at the Reedley CC next door in Hanson’s Fresno Co.) Tulare, Orosi, etc, (well for that time, that is..) As I am now bi-costal retired and spend time split between New Orleans (fall, winter) and Marina del Rey spring, summer) TRUST ME, I see first hand–and live with daily–the sickening results of political dysfunction. Luckily for us we are (relatively) financially immune from the depredations of government save for crime (no small thing) and having one’s axle destroyed by the tank-traps otherwise known as pot-holes in the deteriorating roads in both places–N.O. especially. We console ourselves by enjoying the food, scenery and mis-en-scene in both places, but I am reminded of the final days of ancient Rome when the well-to-do had to hire armed guards with torches to accompany them home at night from dinner at friends homes. When I was an undergrad in the 60s (Class of ’66) at LSU in B.R there was not the darkest street in the back of the French Quarter that I wasn’t afraid to stumble along alone drunk at 4 AM..now? It goes w.o. saying such things are to think the unthinkable..
We’re about the same age I’d wager. ( Class of ’66 too ). My wife and I used to make the NO trip about once a month out of Miami on Pan Am’s every hour on the hour to MSY.
We loved the place. Jackson Square, anywhere in the vieux carre…the baguettes, the coffee, Jumbayala, prawns, oysters and yes good God….Cajun ( and Jazz ) music screaming from just about ever gin joint and bar on Royal Street.
We’d walk anywhere and never feared anyone. Not even Katrina again could ever clean it out now. I remember the cop cars with the “NOPD” on the doors….that’s right…NO Police Department in New Orleans!
Thirty years ago living in Detroit Michigan I came upon Michigan twenty five years beyond its golden age. Locusts and plagues, and the various ungodly perturbations that precursor god and mans wrath towards all men, were just about to gather that inner momentum that was going to accelerate Detroit into a death throes that no one thought would rise above 8 Mile Rd. It rose and now the miasma fills the nostrils all the way to the Upper Peninsula. Riding up Interstate 75 all one could do is compare the dystopia we had left behind in SE Michigan and marvel at the forests and sky that accompanied us all the way to Traverse City and beyond. California meet Michigan meet Ohio meet Illinois meet ………?Do not tell me of apple and oranges. All roads lead too Rome.
I left California precisely because I couldn’t bear to be a witness to its destruction but now I long to return. I have visited the state often enough to almost convince myself that I can accept just about anything that they dish out as long as I can live in the ‘postcard’ called California. What prevents me from returning is this: California doesn’t play fair with many of its citizens and I wouldn’t be in the game, so to speak. My personal and financial security could not withstand the destructive mobs at the gate and I am too practical to put at risk my personal welfare for a California dream. I understand why the quietists have stayed and how they have survived – so far. For folks like me, once I left there was no going back. I shall always live with a longing for this place I once called ‘home.’ Now my attention is focused on my country. The endgame is upon us. Where next?
I am trapped in California. Trapped behind enemy lines – mainly due to my job. I would rather fight than be quiet, as it’s in my nature, as it was in my father’s nature – a true freedom fighter – who fought and then escaped with my mother and me to this great country. I live in the coastal region and am badly outnumbered. I am prepared to fight but have no illusions that it would be anything but a last stand and I would be overwhelmed immediately. This is not what I served my country for. My neighbors have become my enemies.
I envy all of you who live in states where the odds are better. If and when it comes, carry on the fight for those of us here.
AND DON’T EVER BAIL OUT CALIFORNIA. LET IT BURN.
Firstly, “Thank you!” for your service to our country. . . . I am sorry for you , but is there absolutely no way to escape to a friendlier area? We here in SC would welcome you and others like you, especially here in the Upstate.
Thanks for the words of support Rick. It all boils down to timing. My wife and I both will probably lose our jobs this spring – we work in the Defense Industry – and the government announced this year that they want to in-source our work to itself. That’s a hoot. Firstly, the work they do is, to put it bluntly, poor – far below the standard expected of us. There is little accountability for poor performance by them whereas in our case, the response to poor perforamce is a Stop Work Order and loss of contract. Secondly, the taxpayer will pay their retirement costs for the rest of their lives, which is not the case when I retire, my retirement being funded by a private company.
Anyway, we may have no choice but to move then. In which case we will definitely go to a state where patriots are still welcome.
Ad this travisty on top of V.D> Comments courtesy of Heather Mac Donald,”City Journal”
While the UC Regents have been shilling Jerry Brown’s tax initiative to save the system from financial and academic ruin, they found enough money to recruit Linda Greene from the University of Wisconsin-Madison to fill the newly created position of “Vice Chancellor of Diversity” at an annual salary of $250,000.00.
Package also includes “both a relocation allowance of $60,000.00 and 100% reimbursement for moving expenses, a temporary housing allowance of $13,500.00, two fully paid house hunting trips for two to the San Diego area and reimubursement for all business visits to the campus before her start date in January 2013″.
And keep in mind, there is aleady a substantial “diversity” bureaucracy in place on campus. Guaranteeing diveristy at UCSD is estimated to cost around $1,000,000,000 per year not including Ms. Green’s salary.
What a sick joke!
I certainly feel sorry for any state that receives Cali immigrants, as they WANT, what they had, with lower taxes. I retired to Puerto Vallarta, 3 years ago, and even here, Lefties from Wash.St., Oregon, and Cali, expend every effort to re-create what they left,…….as long as the beer is cheap!
I am a quietist.The state is beautiful, and the liberal left has ruined this wonderful state. Everything in this article speaks volumes. The author has hit the proverbial nail on the head. I won’t move, it is a beautiful place to live…at least for now.
Certainly one of the saddest articles I have read in a long time. Made sadder by recognizing my own unspoken feelings directed toward our once great nation. We are no longer building a nation, we are mouldering. We are no longer putting coin in the “bank of liberty” we are spending the great legacy. Perhaps this time around we can slow the descent; is it possible to turn it around? How rapidly are we approaching “one man, one vote, one last time?” I am not a pessimist; I have read the last chapter in the Book and I know who wins. But for my country, I do not know…..
I imagine there were many “quietists” in Germany in the late 30s. . . . how did that work out? Better to die on your feet than live on your knees. . . . . If you are not willing to raise hell and fight, even against overwhelming odds, then you deserve the slavery that is coming- read Mila 18 by Leon Uris. . . . my family has already decided we will not go quietly.. . .
y’all would hate in in NC
no shoes, spittin’ tobacco juice on the sidewalk. place ain’t fit for civilized California folk. well, maybe hippie Asheville.
Seriously, stay the f out.
keep your contagion to yourself
y’all are lepers, accursed by God
Very depressing, but all true. I wish I had a solution. I think there’s another type of Californian – the “despairist”. They are in despair & feel utterly helpless to do anything about the whole mess. Also, for various reasons, they can’t move to another state. I’m one of them, & I live in not-so-bad Laguna Hills.
I was born in California, loved it, and left it when I was 38. I’ve lived in Arizona for twenty years now and it’s really sad to see what the Liberal Experiment with Society has done to my beloved home state. The only good thing about the Obama depression is that fewer liberally indoctrinated California voters have been able to move here. When they do, many of them continue the same Democrat voting patterns that caused them to flee California. When we get the next wave of California refugees I hope they will be more aware of the causes of the state’s problems and not inflict them on Arizona.
shhhhhhhh! you are exposing us.
Am a fan from Texas. Downloaded your recent Sparta book and read others years ago. Always enjoy your articles. Glad to see that at this part of the trail you are joining up with the mainstream American way: “Quietists of the State Unite.” So very enjoyably funny to me.
But you better be careful, or your perspicacity may put you in residential care. Go out and carry water to the laborers building your new high-speed monorail or whatever; that will make you feel better.
The quietists are the Cal Ripkins, the ones who show up for work every day, pay the taxes, and have quietly shrugged off the insanity – until now. I believe a breaking point is about to be reached. For sure, if Obama is reelected.
Do you know that Jerry Brown just signed a law mandating a 3% payment on wages to CALPERS by all private employers with more than 5 employees? And that he also signed a law giving most illegal aliens California Driver Licenses? That’s how you register to vote here. And it is now mandatory to install sprinkler systems in new houses, even mobile homes. They are still debating if the sprinkler systems require a back-up power generating unit to pump from the mandatory water tank you must have for it. They are also starting to put meters on private water wells, if more than two residences use the same well. Of course this is just a foot in the door for metering all wells. In the northern part of the state, century old deeded water rights are being confiscated, leaving ranches without irrigation water.
I could go on endlessly, but then it would sound like Atlas Shrugged! Guess it does anyway.
Thank you for your post. I knew about the bill that sets up a public retirement system for private employees was passed by the legislature but I didn’t know it is now law!!!! Signed by Jerry Brown.
This is insanity! Why won’t businesses just dump their retirement plans now that they pay fees on! The state government gives retirement accounts for free! Way to kill jobs in the private sector (i.e brokers).
Whoever in Wall Street that is liberal better wake up
Ahh, this is so poignant and eloquently written. I too am a Quietest – and a native Californian. It is so sad to witness the ruination of this once beautiful state. Though not familiar with Dr. Hanson’s Central Valley I grew up in the Santa Clara Valley when there were more orchards than people and San Jose was rural and conservative.
Please though, realize that not everyone in the state is a crazy head-in-the-sand leftest. I walked my neighborhood for Prop. 8, drove around providing lawn signs(again and again as they were stolen) and stood on street corners with others holding posters in support of traditional marriage. Not AGAINST anything, but for something. I was amazed at the number of good people I encountered, most of them affiliated with one church or another and I wasn’t surprised later at how the vote went. The election results mirrored what I saw. But even then most people didn’t want their neighbors to know how they felt … intimidation was already a factor. In fact, there was more than one occasion where the person (usually older, usually female) would not tell me how she would vote without knowing first if I supported the proposition. I saw real fear in those eyes. But the effort worked, initially, and Prop. 8 passed, to the great surprise of the media and many elected leaders. (Well, at least until our elected leaders refused to implement the law and the courts got involved.)
My community involvement came to an abrupt halt however when Illness and Death moved into my home and now I find myself in the ranks of those older females who are afraid to have the neighbors know how conservative they really are. It’s easy to speak of courage when in a position of strength, not so simple when there is real vulnerability. I have considered moving, but where to move to when you are a household of just one? My house is paid for, my taxes are low (thank you Prop 13) and right now I can afford to stay here on the pension my husband worked so hard for (we’ll see how long that holds true.) So, now I am Quiet, and careful, and I pray daily for this good country. And I am not alone.
I’m 56, female and alone also. Several of us are considering moving to or around, Kalispell, MT.
Google it and see if you like it. I hail from Whittier, CA- time to get out!
I am originally from the East Coast, I moved around some and have seen a lot of crap go down, but never in my life have I seen anything as bad as California and I relocated here from FL because of a family situation. Big mistake I made let me tell you. Before I knew I’d ever move to California and finally had my chance to move to Portland Oregon which was a goal of mine since I lived in FL and I DID THAT btw but moved back to CA again because I realized it wasn’t better in the NW at all, I wanted to move closer to the city and build my life in the Tampa/St Pete area because I liked it and it was near the water. Sacramento area is the complete reverse..You have mountains nearby but thats the only plus to being in the Sacramento area, but in every way possible, St Petersburg was better and there was more culture and less traffic imo. It was like a San Francisco with way less people to me and cheaper but that was because of the BAD economy there but if you had work and made some money omg, that was the place to live. I miss my many nights traveling down Central Avenue. Far superior to anything I seen in Downtown Sacramento area. Google map it sometime. This hellhole has always been a pitstop for me TO and FROM wherever I was going. It was a pitstop to get to Portland area, and now its a pitstop to get BACK HOME to the Northeast in the MA/NH area. Its pointless for me to be here now and I won’t stay here with other Californians “fighting” something so ridiculous like Illegal immigration when they do nothing but TALK about it anyhow. They are here, theres nothing nobody can do about them since their numbers are huge.. if anything I am for giving this back to Mexico.. I really am.. I mean what good does much of the SW do for White people? Nothing. Many moved here to sell out, they go to LV to gamble.. they move to Hollywood and sell out. The entreprenour types come here to live an individualistic dream. Degeneracy is all over this part of the country. I want good European Americans in a healthier minded place. Like someone said, California was Gods gift and was blessed with TONS of fruit and goodness and the masses helped turned it into a living hell. Many Californians with their individualistic mindsets are going to finally get what they deserve. BTW I don’t want most of yous to come east.. stay there and deal with it. You did it, not me. I am just a passer by on the way back to New England.
Personalitywise, I am inbetween a quietist and an activist. I am not fully one or the other I don’t think as I don’t make it blatantly obvious everywhere I go that I am the way I am, but I do enough to stir up trouble too if you catch my drift. I mean my opinions about illegal immigration and Obama got skinheads mad at me nearby from the rumors I hear. I say what I got to say.. If a libtard or righty doesn’t like it, I could give 2 shits. I have a lot to say and I need to say it! I judge the prepper community too.. I think many of these Doomsday extremists are not gonna make it out either. They will be the hunted actually and increased pressure will be on them to get people the hell away from them. I don’t want that job. No TY.
I’m a native of San Francisco, a veteran, and I saw the writing on the wall back in the 60s.
I migrated to Australia in 1974 and had a productive working life in a place that I have learned to love.
I’m retired now and visit the US every year.
I cannot get over how stuffed California is and yet how productive and positive Americans still are when you get to the heartland. I have visited Ohio, the Carolinas, Georgia, Mississippi, Texas and another handful of states.
I simply cannot understand how real Americans continue to put up with the media, Obama, the educational establishment and bureaucracies gone mad.
It will end noisily, I’m afraid, especially if the Left steals this election with Acorn type tactics.
There may be no other way.
I frequently wore a T-shirt on my last trip a few months ago that said, “The founding fathers would already be shooting”. Indeed.
I grieve for my native country and live half a mile from my front gate on a dead end road with solar power and plenty of water and gardens in my new country.
The disease infecting California is in the American blood system now, headed to all parts of the body.
Proposition 187 on immigration might have saved California. The people (59%) voted for it (despite advice to the contrary from “conservatives” Jack Kemp and Bill Bennett) but the courts wouldn’t allow it. Demography is destiny.
Dr. Hanson, please get out of CA before the socialists destroy it. Don’t go down in flames as a martyr. If you care about CA, save yourself.
Enjoy reading Dr. Hansen’s pieces, especially about California. His experience parallels that of many of us.
Yard debris tossed out on the landscaped easement between a gated community and a residential street. Obviously not one of the homeowners, frustrated with the city’s garbage pickup – more likely, from one of those ubiquitous staked-bed landscape trucks, occupied by 6 non-English speakers. The reason? Too much trouble to haul their load to the landfill. Reducing overhead. Tough economy. And besides, Ramon doesn’t live anywhere that neighborhood and can’t see it from his house anyway. In any case, someone will eventually notice and phone in a complaint to the city, who will send someone out to clean it up.
Burned-out cars, encountered nearly every Monday morning. Not along the side of some obscure county road, but inside a new housing development, just before or after the streets are paved, perimeter wall and “security” notwithstanding. Occasionally discovered with a body inside. Explanation? Hey, the kids have to have something to do on Saturday night; Sabado Gigante is for the Abuelos.
Thefts necessitate the use of security patrols and cameras being installed on construction sites. Highest incidence of stolen items include copper wire and water pipe, A/C units, and water trucks. These are seen as “victimless crimes” by the local PD, and only casually investigated. When apprehended, accused are almost always workers employed by one of the construction companies, illegally in the US, with few English language skills.
Multiple-vehicle accident in the middle lane of a major freeway at Monday morning rush hour. Cause? A sofa (refrigerator, entertainment unit, tree stump, etc.) has been tossed out the back of a pickup truck in the wee hours of the morning. Not someone moving their belongings in the back of a friend’s half-ton to a new apartment, but a deliberate act of mayhem by one or several bad actors for whom English is a second language. ¡Viva la Raza!
Comments section of the online local newspaper is turned off for certain items. Invariably the story involves DUI, a fatality of someone other than the driver (often an innocent in another car), the driver at fault leaving the scene, a police report of a stolen vehicle called in to the Police (within an hour of the accident, involving the car in question). When the DUI driver is eventually caught, the following characteristics are a matter of public record: male, mid-20s, Hispanic surname, speaks little English, no insurance, no driver’s license, fled to Mexico to avoid prosecution, apprehended upon trying to re-enter the US, little experience driving, several previous DUI arrests, several previous deportations.
The comments to VDH articles always amaze me, especially the ones by those with extreme “die-damn-you die” attitudes, which in this case, blame the problem on VDH’s identified “quietists,” rather than on the liberal perps.
It must be nice to be twenty again and to have my head up my a*s, or as I suspect, in the case of those who posted above and who say dumb things like “let California go up in flames,” or “Quietism is the handmaiden of Fascism…” blah, blah, blah, to be beyond the age of thirty and to have both their heads and their hearts up their a*s.
Other than voting, writing, contributing, organizing and getting in people’s faces, indeed, the only alternatives left are to, in fact, move or to literally revolt, which means you-know-what in the streets. And the knee-jerk uber-right fools I described above don’t even permit that solution. And if they do, they are indeed fools at this juncture.
Frankly, not moving away from California is the best choice. Fleeing signifies weakness. Besides, who wants to be in the Midwest near supposed salt-of-the earth citizens who buy mobile homes in tornado alley.
Mike – 100% agreement from San Mateo here.
To all the blog posters above who blame the quietists themselves for California’s ills and who foolishly, innocently, and dare I say stupidly, believe that illegal aliens will actually stay in California — ha, ha, ha, think again: they’re coming to your states as we speak.
Are your drivers tests in other languages? You’re California now.
Are there bilingual classes at night school? You’re California now.
Are there translators in your courts? You’re California now.
Is there a Spanish-speaking radio station on your dial? You’re California now.
Has your neighbor’s daughter birthed a brown baby? You’re California now.
Do even your conservative politicans use words like “diversity,” “multicultural” and “newcomer” ? You’re California now.
Does your local post office have more immigration forms in its stacks or signs for “envios” ? You’re California now.
Do your Mom-and-Pops, 7-Elevens, and liquor stores have Western Union money transfer signs in Spanish in their windows? You’re California now.
Is your hospital emergency room more crowded? You’re California now.
Clearly, the illegals have already arrived in your respective states and are transforming them into California, against your wishes, despite the smug bravado you present here. The blog posters from Texas and Florida especially come to mind.
Hahahahhahaha, hahahahhahaa. You’re ALL quietists, because you likely preach on similar blogspots but don’t practice as such in your momentarily cozy enclaves. All of you are indeed to blame because many of you voted for Reagan, (as we all did) who granted the first amnesty. Jeeze, I’d rather be a California quietist than blind, as many of you here apparently are.
Don’t get too comfortable. The writing is on the wall, and it ain’t in English. If you don’t believe me, how many of your Voter ID laws have been blocked, or are in court? How many of your own anti-illegal laws have been nullified or gutted? Californians all. Welcome to the club, we’ve been waiting for you.
Crime: millions of installed home security systems yet no real security. California families are prisoners in their own homes starting at dusk each evening while the criminals roam unchallenged. Crime. Dirt. Taxes. Taxes. Noise. Perversion. Crime. Traffic and congestion. Legislators codify and promote personal perversions rather than teaching. Yet, some good people do remain and struggle. The California culture is in Roman rot a la Caligula and the “leaders” want it it that way ’cause they believe they will be in power forever.
I have a real short answer for the question… how did this happen?
Social Conservatives. There is no way in Hell we will gain any foothold here whatsoever when SC’s give the Left so much ammunition for their demographic.
If you are one of the 50% of below-average intelligence, gay marriage is the one issue you can understand. Economy? Business climate? Pftt… that’s for those business-y people. And they’re all greedy.
Conservatives already have perilously little to offer stupid people. Here in California Social Conservatives have put the nail in the coffin, representing a different incarnation of Big Government that is an endless gift to the Hippies that run our state.
Heck, its the Dick Armey and Geroge W Bush and RIck Perry not transplants from Orange County or Bakersfield that cause Texas immirgation probelms as well. But Texans always blame it on the leftist from Orange County or Bakersfield for their troubles, they get more conservatives from California from the metro areas mention above except for the Mexican towns or Austin and they complain that neither Armey or Bush or Perry are responable for their immirgation policy. Chuck Devore came from the OC which is to the right of Dallas and HOuston but TExans blame on those more conservative Republicans from Ca and not their Rino’s on immmirgation.
Well, New Mexico is heavily hispanic therfore as mention above more Democratic, Californians are not all liberals people from San Diego are usually to the right of HOuston or El Paso. Colorado is not attracts bobth from north or south and more minorties. As mention above, Texas needs to changed its Mexican population which well bring it to the left not white folks from San Diego, or Orange County which sends people to Texas more than the Bay area. Instead of being anti-white Californian be anti-high hispanic immirgation which has screwed up Cal, Texas, Arizona and Nevada with a time bomb.
Actually, Californians may Pinal more Republican since it mainly had poor whites and hispanics before whites from Orange County and San Diego came there. So, contrary to Arizonians and I live in Pima which is always Democratic, some of the californians made Pima less Democratic.
Better red than dead eh? Time for a revival, to bring God back to stricken kalifornia.
Well, its Republicans like you that wished illegal immirgants on California back in the 1980s’. There were plenty of conservative white people chased out of California by both the left and right. The right wanted cheap labor like it did also in Texas. And the left wanted to make certain that Democratics win. I hope that God also srikes Texas as well since it loves Rick Perry and Company that also loves illegal immirgants to do cheap labor and Texas is going to be a blue state too when the white Republicans die off in the next 10 years.
Anonymous, of course. Rant about Mexican immigrants and blame both left and right for it. The immigrants aren’t the ones that have destroyed California, it’s the liberals. Period.
Michael Kinsley’s quip from the 80s gets truer & truer: Just as youth is wasted on the young, so California is wasted on Californians.
Gov. Brown’s tax increase on the November ballot — Proposition 30 — is not about funding K-12 public schools. I am sure Prof. Hanson is aware of this. Enrollment in K-12 schools has declined one percent in the last 5 years and is expected to decline further.
The Education Fund has loaned the state several billion dollars the last few years to plug the state general fund budget. In that time there have been no statewide layoffs of core teachers (although there has been layoffs of support staff such as bus drivers, aides, etc). So what this means is that California does not need a tax increase for public schools which apparently have been overfunded.
What Gov. Brown’s $8.5 billion tax increase would go to is a $5 billion hole created in the state General Fund budget due to Pres. Obama’s policy of shifting people from unemployment to Social Security Disability, which qualifies them for Medicaid.
However, voters won’t pay for a $5 billion deficit in Medicaid created by Obama’s policy of shifting people to disability programs. So public education is just a poster child used to cover up where the money is going. If the public realized that California is stuck with a $5 billion budget deficit due to Obama’s policies I am not sure it would make a difference. Liberals would continue to call conservatives selfish and stingy.
But California is in a slow downward spiral and throwing money down a hole can’t fix it.
California is a lost cause. Decent people like VDH should move eastwords, and the US should cut California loose like gangrenous tissue. If California wants to become Mexico, let them
Nixon referred to the “silent majority” who sound like your “quiet californians”. Problem both of these roups have is nobody hears them. The drive by media denies their existence and they get outvoted by dead people who are always available to help win close elections.
Alas, 57 years, every one of them spent in Southern California, and it ends in six more days. I worked hard, saved, denied myself luxuries and accumulated a significant nest egg (seven figures x 2). I retired two years ago.
California is probably the state with the most diverse, beautiful landscape in the nation. Until the mid to late 80′s, there was still some hope that we retained some sanity. At least there were several Republican governors elected (Pete Wilson, George Deukmejian), but they weren’t enough to hold off the onslaught of freeloaders and Hollywood liberals that have since destroyed any chance of ever returning to any semblance of a well-run state.
I leave in six days. I leave my children and grandchildren and hope that some day, they too can escape this insane asylum and go somewhere the government isn’t trying to suck the life out of them. Meanwhile, adios California, you get nothing more from me.
Come to Texas. There is beauty here of almost every sort. Some of the same insanupidities and one or two others (e.g., religitics) become bothersome from time to time. But there’s no income tax and people have a sufficient wariness of the political class, both left and right, to keep it on a short leash. Relatively speaking, of course. There are no truly decent governments in America. Such is the legacy of income taxation.
Although I am older than Dr. Hanson, I don’t want to stay and pay. So I am planning my escape this year. When difi refused to debate her opponent Elizabeth Emken, the arrogance hit me. She represents the decrepit rich liberal with no ideas.
I just had one question Dr. Hanson. Why didn’t you drop the pc and say that every time we hear of a murder, child kidnapping, robbery the surname is most likely Spanish. Sorry, but someone needs to say lawlessness breeds contempt for our society.
Californistan will eventually succumb to the mounting debt and idiocy of what the left is constructing.
The shame of it is that the public employees will eventually be the big losers, because eventually the system of ever increasing entitlements will overwhelm the state and take their salaries, benefits and pensions with it. One can already see this occuring in individual cities in the state – the bankruptcies are just beginning.
Then, Californistan will appeal to the Central Committee… errr, government in DC to bail them out, but I doubt it will happen. There is no way they will persuade the other 49 states to support their ridiculous irresponsibility.
Not without Greek like austerity anyway.
And thus the “Golden State” will turn to lead.