Get PJ Media on your Apple

Roger L. Simon

The Arab World’s Heroin Problem Meets the Left’s Racism

June 13th, 2013 - 8:41 am

That is what we have before us at present. And in many ways it seems to be growing worse as Israel progresses. Many parts of the country I visited are now almost indistinct from the Silicon Valley with gleaming Microsoft offices interspersed with high-tech Israeli companies.

Meanwhile, the Arab world is in a breakdown and appears to be plummeting toward the eighth century. Paranoia, always a problem for that culture, runs rampant, today’s example being a supposedly secret conclave in which Egyptian politicians blamed America and Israel for Ethiopia’s desire to build a dam — this after the U. S. just quietly sent Egypt an additional 1.3 billion in aid. We must be schizophrenics.

Well, in truth, maybe we are part of the problem. Perhaps giving aid is the exact wrong way to help bring the Arab world into modernity.

In your own family you don’t continue to give money to your cousin to feed his heroin habit. After awhile, you realize what you are doing is making the habit worse. The best way to help him is to cut him off.

The Arab world has a heroin problem — and the heroin is Western aid. Drop it and, like that cousin, they will have to grow up and do something for themselves. (It would be interesting to see how fast the Palestinian Authority made peace with Israel if they no longer received Western aid. As has already been shown, the countries that advanced most quickly in Africa are the ones who received little or no aid.)

For us to do that, “progressives” (and others, alas) in our culture will have to grow up themselves. Buried not too deeply in their ideology (and born of multi-culturalism and cultural relativism) is a form of racism toward the Third World. The Left consciously/unconsciously assumes folks in the Middle East and Africa are incapable of taking care of themselves — a self-fulling prophecy. In the words of Pirandello, “It is so, if you think so.” Ironically, in a bizarre switch, it is the Left that has taken over the “white man’s burden.”

Those of Richard Falk’s ilk are the guiltiest of this form of patriarchal racism. Falk — the prototypical left-wing Jewish professor who blamed the Boston Bombings on America’s “global domination project” — has been accused of antisemitism.

I think Falk is far guiltier of anti-Arab racism — only he is undoubtedly unconscious of it. He completely infantilizes them. The Arabs are the ones who should really hate him. Jews can at least laugh. We’ve seen this all before.

*****

image courtesy shutterstock / Meg007

<- Prev  Page 2 of 2   View as Single Page

Comments are closed.

Top Rated Comments   
ISLAMISTS DESTROY, THE WEST BUILDS.
At the turn of the last century, countless Jews died of malaria while draining the swampland that was the Hula Valley. They took land that had been neglected for centuries and made it productive. In fact, that's what they did all over Israel. The Jewish state has the knowledge, technology and will to help its neighbors grow. Unfortunately its neighbors, like Egypt, aren't looking to the future. All they can do is revel in the past -- the myth of what was. They don't have the vision to see what a world of peace and mutual friendship can be.


1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
"...Their first reaction would most likely be a form of shame – why can’t we do that?..."

Dead wrong, Roger. Merely your civilized westerner's projection of what you imagine an Arab would feel. Their first reaction--and their last--is that of an Arab brigand named Mohamed greedily eyeing the fabulously wealthy and cultured Jewish city of Medina.

1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
More and more, I must agree, over-generous aid, whether foreign or welfare for our own citizens, is totally counterproductive.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
All Comments   (27)
All Comments   (27)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
Roger, you forgot another possibility in reaction to a cut off in aid...sometimes when you cut your cousin off, he kills you and your entire family and steals your credit cards. That is not to say that I think we should continue to support these people, but I am not sure that even cutting them off will save them...or us.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
The cut-off of aid idea is like the nuke solution (one bomb, etc.) to thorny problems. If we cut off aid to Eqypt, its people would starve. If we cut off aid to the PA, they'd starve. Until the EU and UN took up the slack. Some problems just aren't solvable. You could turn the heroin addict away and he might cure himself. More likely he'd wind up dead or in jail.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Bernard Lewis' "Roots of Muslim Rage" confirms much of what you've written. The fundamental source is Islam's failure to deliver on its promises while infidels lead superior lives. Giving cash to the angry will not palliate this rage. It subsidizes the inevitable lashing out. Boston anyone?
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
The Left views all things rich and poor through the prism of the movie Trading Places. Where your life's works are reduced down to two filthy rich old men who control the stock market gets to pick the winners and losers in life and if they pick you than your a rich successful guy, no matter what your character, work ethics, or education is.
It's interesting because isn't that just what Barak Obama and his cohorts are doing with "green energy jobs." They dole out the money and make the winners and losers of society. Only, it turns out that is not the only ingredient needed for success and wealth. But alas, they never look close enough at the results only the process which is why the Left is as wrong as wrong can be.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
I recommend Dambisa Moyo on this subject of Western Aid to the 3rd World.

Google for articles and videos. Her book is called Dead Aid

On a side note: Bill Gates just called the Zambian Dambisa Moyo "evil."

http://www.bookerrising.net/2013/06/dambisa-moyo-responds-to-being-called.html

1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
"And, as we know, this unremitting anger is justified and exacerbated — and, to a great degree, caused — by religious fundamentalism."

Not exactly. It isn't generic religious fundamentalism. It is Islam in any form.

It seems to the Western mind that anyone else would look at the success of Israeli's and want to emulate them so they could enjoy the same benefits. But not the Muslims. Their mind numbing religion blinds them to rational thought.

If those with sympathy towards Muslims really felt compassion for them and wanted to help them they would do everything they could to free them from their "religion of human destruction."

I agree that any Islamic country should receive no aid whatsoever, humanitarian or otherwise. They should be left to enjoy the fruits of their religion.

Also.
"Ironically, in a bizarre switch, it is the Left that has taken over the “white man’s burden.”

I have been thinking the same thing lately, but after more thought I think it is more accurately "The condescending left assuming the "The Superior Person's Burden" (gender neutral , of course) because they want to enable the Muslim "victims" and remake the "inferior right wingers".
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Why would the progressives view the arabs any different than they view the rest of their collection of victims? Blacks cannot get a job on their own and require affirmative action laws - same for women - same for native indians - same for gays and lesbians - its a long list of victims. And that list is what the modern democrat party is largely made up of - victims. Is it no wonder why they whine so much?
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
Hey this story is similar to the 47 percent here in the US. The more money the get from the government the more they feel entitled and then do nothing to better themselves.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
The problem with the left is that they are not on racist but they hate their own culture as well. They hate our success - starting in Sparta which led to Greece, on to Rome, Europe which led to the UK and lastly to America. 3000 years of success just galls them. So their solution isn't to bring enlightenment to the "savages," it is to break the back of the west to lower our standard of living to that of the "savages." Once everyone is on a level playing field - one of squalor - they will rule with an iron fist.
1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
ISLAMISTS DESTROY, THE WEST BUILDS.
At the turn of the last century, countless Jews died of malaria while draining the swampland that was the Hula Valley. They took land that had been neglected for centuries and made it productive. In fact, that's what they did all over Israel. The Jewish state has the knowledge, technology and will to help its neighbors grow. Unfortunately its neighbors, like Egypt, aren't looking to the future. All they can do is revel in the past -- the myth of what was. They don't have the vision to see what a world of peace and mutual friendship can be.


1 year ago
1 year ago Link To Comment
1 2 3 Next View All