There was lively discussion of *Alms for Jihad* in the library community and a concerted and broad effort to make sure that the book was not removed from collections and, where it had gone missing (e.g., stolen by someone seeing its value go up), replaced. If copies are not on shelf now, they may be held for safekeeping and eventually recatalogued into special collections. See the earlier comment on the OCLC count of hundreds of copies in libraries. Academic librarians are allies of freedom in the fight against libel tourism. I hope Mr. Kimball will correct his error.

J. O’Donnell