Get PJ Media on your Apple

Unexamined Premises

Take this sign and shove it

Take this sign and shove it

I have little to add to John Hinderaker’s analysis of the Bundy ranch standoff, except this: if the Bureau of Land Management, a federal agency, thinks it can establish “First Amendment Areas” while it goes about its business, it and the rest of the federal bureaucracy need to think again. First, the moral case for Bundy (who, as Hinderaker correctly notes, doesn’t have a legal leg to stand on):

Over the last two or three decades, the Bureau has squeezed the ranchers in southern Nevada by limiting the acres on which their cattle can graze, reducing the number of cattle that can be on federal land, and charging grazing fees for the ever-diminishing privilege. The effect of these restrictions has been to drive the ranchers out of business. Formerly, there were dozens of ranches in the area where Bundy operates. Now, his ranch is the only one. When Bundy refused to pay grazing fees beginning in around 1993, he said something to the effect of, they are supposed to be charging me a fee for managing the land and all they are doing is trying to manage me out of business. Why should I pay them for that..?

So let’s have some sympathy for Cliven Bundy and his family. They don’t have a chance on the law, because under the Endangered Species Act and many other federal statutes, the agencies are always in the right. And their way of life is one that, frankly, is on the outs. They don’t develop apps. They don’t ask for food stamps. It probably has never occurred to them to bribe a politician. They don’t subsist by virtue of government subsidies or regulations that hamstring competitors. They aren’t illegal immigrants. They have never even gone to law school. So what possible place is there for the Bundys in the Age of Obama?

Well, this is what you get with gangster government. But, just as in the 1930s, when corrupt big-city machines like Tammany Hall worked hand-in-glove with both politicians and criminals — but I repeat myself — it’s going to take the public to rise up and destroy the rackets. Where is the Tom Dewey of our time, the two-fisted racket buster who sent legions of crooks to the slammer? We’re still waiting.

But a “First Amendment Area?” That’s something every American needs to denounce, as loudly as possible. No federal agency has the right to do this, and in a decent administration, the bureaucrat who thought up the idea and ordered the signs posted would be publicly defenestrated pour encourage les autres. There is, however, no accountability in the Obama administration and its corrupt enablers in Congress, for whom everything is a racket — either a source of personal enrichment or an opportunity to mete out some punishment to the regime’s ideological enemies.

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

The BLM’s stunt violated every one of the amendment’s proscriptions except the “establishment” and “free exercise” clauses, and Obamacare is working hard on those. For the record, here’s the official spokesdroid’s explanation for the zones:

While anybody can express their free speech any time on open public lands in accordance with the codes and ordinances that exist, there are temporary closures of some of the public lands related to this impound operation and those are in place for public safety. So we identified two areas where the public could safely and conveniently express their opinions without having to go through the codes and ordinance process and apply for permits.

So this is the country we live in at the moment: militarized local cops and weaponized federal agencies, whose bureaucratic whims are enforced at gunpoint. It’s not the country I grew up in, nor one in which any right-thinking American would want to live.

Comments are closed.

Top Rated Comments   
Political power and influence abuser Harry Reid is a money grubbing criminal. So are his 4 sons. The BLM are Brownshirt thugs. The Bundys have the moral high ground or the country has gone mad.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
The 2nd amendment zone was put in place to enforce the 1st amendment zone.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
Michael, you have Communist posters adorning your walls? Why? The chunk of Berlin wall is one thing, but hanging up representations of the brutes who slaughtered millions is creepy. Decorate your house as you wish, but don't ask me to think well of you for it.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
All Comments   (149)
All Comments   (149)
Sort: Newest Oldest Top Rated
Yeah. That Nazi flag in my living room and the swastika sticker on my car are just memorabilia of that wonderful summer in Dachau. Too bad Jay's son's Che T-shirt was in the wash. I never got to do the Gulag tours like you. Maybe next time one of those regimes kills millions again you and me can travel there, buy some stuff and show our support. Ah. Fun times.
13 weeks ago
13 weeks ago Link To Comment
I'm going to start wearing one of these, to put anyone around me on notice, that we're always in a 1st amendment area... http://designcr51.tumblr.com/post/82875026080/http-teespring-com-1stamendmenarea-amendment
13 weeks ago
13 weeks ago Link To Comment
About this so-called gangster government -- I would note that most criminal enterprises are interested in maintaining a facade of legitimacy. I don't believe that can be said of the Obozo regime. Carney and the other clowns in this administration tell ham-fisted lies -- whoppers -- with utter impunity. Apparently they believe the American public is just too stupid. Ditto for the tawdry, obviously fake photoshopped "pics" of Carney's household -- like Obozo sheet shooting -- it is all a fraud. A lie. And when their incompetence displays itself, they don't care -- it's part of their carnival performance.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
You want to know what's creepy? It's not Carney's commie posters, it's displaying a child's severed finger in your bookcase...(thanks to one lousy photoshop. Couldn't they afford a professional? too cheap?)
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
Can anyone translate the words on the Lenin poster at the end of the article? "Lenin" I got, but the rest....?
BTW,of course, National Socialism and Soviet Leninist-Stalinist Socialism are knuckles on the same bloody fist.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
"Lenin lived, Lenin lives, Lenin will live."

It was a bastard child of the Russian Orthodox religion, you see. Complete with the Savior, saints and sacred texts.
Those posters took the place of icons.
They had an advantage, though: They'd mummified their savior and stuffed him in the Mausoleum for the faithful to admire.
Beat that, Catholicism, with your shards of the True Cross!
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
There are some super Nazi posters out there too.......gotta get me some.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
"So we identified two areas where the public could safely and conveniently express their opinions without having to go through the codes and ordinance process and apply for permits."

Pretty much says it all. I don't think "free speech" means what they think that it means.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
I grew up in USSR, and for me the communist posters and the fascist posters look similarly attractive.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
Walter Duranty always thought them attractive also as did the whole staff of the New York Times.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
There is gonna be a reckoning soon.
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
Bureaucrats and trial lawyers have made Legal Precedent and Constitutional Lawfulness 2 absolutely different things. Constitutional Lawfulness is straightforward language that anyone can understand. Legal Precedent needs a bureaucracy of lawyers and administrative law judges to tell the rest of us what "the law" means. Why do I need to get a lawyer and 5 permits before I can bake a pie and sell it?
14 weeks ago
14 weeks ago Link To Comment
1 2 3 4 5 Next View All

One Trackback to “Irish Diary: Of ‘First Amendment Areas’ and Jay Carney’s Commie Posters”