Instapundit.com Instapundit.com

September 23, 2006

OUCH: "He’s just another talk-radio host, really — only this time by way of Yale and Mensa."

Plus, an amusing account of the origins of "Laphamization:"

There’s one column that’s conspicuously absent from this collection, and that’s the one from September 2004, which included a brief account of the Republican National Convention. Lapham wrote it as if the convention had already happened, ruefully reflecting on the content and sharing with readers a question that occurred to him as he listened; unfortunately, the magazine arrived on subscribers’ doorsteps before the convention had even taken place, forcing Lapham to admit that the scene was a fiction. He apologized, but pointed out that political conventions are drearily scripted anyway — he basically knew what was going to be said. By this logic, though, I could have chosen not to read “Pretensions to Empire” before reviewing it, since I already knew Lapham’s sensibility, just as he claims to know the Republicans’. But I dutifully read the whole book. And I discovered, with some ironic poignancy, that Lapham did have a point: some people never acquire any more nuance as they go.

Ouch, again.

UPDATE: More on Lapham here.

ANOTHER UPDATE: Further thoughts on Lapham from Roger Kimball.