I understand that children with learning disabilities present a real challenge to the classroom teacher, and can make it harder for other students to learn. OTOH, I’ve taught classes in our homeschool co-op for over a decade, and I would NEVER treat a child in one of my classes in such a manner, nor would any other parent in our co-op.
Our homeschool group has had a number of kids with ADHD, Asperger’s, and other learning disabilities. They are not always easy to deal with, and more than once I have asked my assistant to take a child out of class to chill out, but unless other students are being harassed or I’m concerned about safety (I teach science classes), I can tolerate a lot of wriggling, not paying attention, etc. Over time, they mature, gain self-control, learn how to recognize social cues, and how to manage themselves in class, on the playground, at birthday parties, etc. It takes a long time, a LOT of effort by the parents, and help from teachers, scoutmasters, coaches, etc. who are willing to help create an environment that sets limits and nurtures growth.
I don’t think I could manage kids in class all day everyday- that is why I am not a school teacher. Kids with some learning disabilities probably don’t need to be in class all day everyday- it’s just to hard for them to cope with a situation that really doesn’t meet their needs. But this type of behavior from teachers is just not acceptable, no matter what the extenuating circumstances.
