venividivici
2010-03-07 11:28:59

56

Then you agree the USA military must be disbanded? After all, war is the most collectivist action a nation undertakes.

Typical red-herring non-sequitur. The pursuit of war on the part of a nation represents that nation’s collective voluntary will to continued existence “as-is” in the face of the alternative of becoming the plaything of the potential vanquishing enemy. As such, it fits the criterion of “voluntary collectivism” in a way that the current set of Ponzi-esque financial and health-related entitlements, the paradigm of which ObamaCare would continue, do not. Also, war has typically had a finite set of goals and did not represent an open-ended commitment to an unsustainable course of action.

LEARN HOW TO DISTINGUISH AMONG NON-COMPARABLE HUMAN SOCIAL ACTIVITIES, PLEASE. You merely waste everyone’s time making what logicians would call “category errors” and then expect us to believe that your IQ is above room temperature? It is far past time when people such as yourself, with your glib false analogies and non-sequiturs, just shut up and let those capable of rational discussion lead the conversation, to which you add nothing but obfuscation.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category_mistake