Mr Keith should also be advised that the black family was far more intact in the past than it is now—even under slavery, as best anyone can estimate, the rate of illegitimate births was not as high as it is now. Black labor force participation was as high as that of whites as recently as the 1950s and early 1960s. There was terrible discrimination that took much too long to end, but they survived it and built strong families and communities which should be a source of pride in their children and grandchildren.
This does NOT excuse slavery or Jim Crow, but there comes a point when it’s time to let go the self-pity and make a life for yourself and your family and your neighbors—saying that is pretty much what got Bill Cosby so much trouble a few years ago— but even if he was wrong on a detail or two, he was right on the big picture.
So, if Mr. Keith wants to maintain all his false historical beliefs because they help him feel burning resentment and self-righteousness, well, there’s nothing I or anyone else can do. He certainly doesn’t “owe” anyone anything, it’s entirely his choice to make.
But if what works is of any importance, there are lots of examples of very impoverished people and groups who have “made it” in America—yes, their ancestors weren’t slaves, but I guess in 2008 it’s up to you what shackles you chose to wear.
