A Comment About

The Obama-Netanyahu Meeting: Ominous for Israel

May 19, 2009 - 1:27 am - by P. David Hornik
Kaleokualoha
2009-05-23 13:31:12

Naftali: You posted “I was speaking strictly on moral grounds, you turned it into an economic argument, and then you used your logic to counter an argument I never made.

RESPONSE: Untrue. You originally posted “The only relevant question regarding an evil madman like Saddam is whether you let him continue or whether you stop him.” Although it may have been your intention, you did NOT restrict relevant questions to moral grounds. You said it was the ONLY relevant question, not the only relevant moral question.

If you believe that I created a straw man by misrepresenting your actual position, rather than your intended position, please quote my specific statements that misrepresented your position. False accusations are a tricky business.

“Truth is generally the best vindication against slander.”
– Abraham Lincoln