A Comment About

Why Anti-Semitism Persists

April 23, 2009 - 12:00 am - by David Solway
Naftali
2009-04-25 12:43:01

Owens,

I asked you questions. You still need to explain the concept of sovereignty.

I asked you to clarify your definition of ‘their homeland’. You didn’t do that. You made it more confusing by saying that the Arab natives of British property have rights because they lived there, whereas the Jews, who also lived there, don’t have such rights. If I misunderstood, then you have to clarify that.

I didn’t say anything at all about the Bible. I don’t even know from where you inferred that.

And as a matter of fact, yes Britain did have that right. That’s where the idea of sovereignty comes in.

So until we get the word sovereignty properly defined, I guess we can’t really define ‘illegal settlements’.

You also completely avoided the issue of the wars, and territory acquired during a war, and how that relates to sovereignty.

So basically, this is one big question. Don’t reply as if I made one big statement, if you please.